Profile banner
Profile picture

Jeremy Schulman

@jeremyschulman.bsky.social

Senior News Editor, Mother Jones/CIR

created November 13, 2024

63,320 followers 528 following 1,064 posts

view profile on Bluesky

Posts

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

yes, that is me, "spending ZERO time criticizing" the GOP

2/9/2025, 6:09:32 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

If we all went back to Twitter, it would be happening over there. It's not like there was a healthy, respectful, cross-ideological exchange of high-minded ideas going on there in the before times.

2/9/2025, 6:06:57 PM | 5 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

I would define "Blueskyism" as the tendency to angrily reject any suggestion by a center-left person that there is merit to any conservative-coded critiques of what Democrats or media did between 2019 and 2024. But none of this is actually inherent to Bluesky; it's just where it happens right now.

2/9/2025, 6:03:02 PM | 11 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture George Conway 👊🇺🇸🔥 (@gtconway.bsky.social) reposted

Fifty-one of the 85 Federalist papers were written by a guy born in Nevis.

1/9/2025, 2:39:25 AM | 15766 3346 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Update: Florida law enforcement keeps arresting people for using chalk to commemorate the 49 people murdered at the Pulse nightclub, according to ‪@wesh2news.bsky.social‬ www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zr6U...

1/9/2025, 12:07:35 PM | 10 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Amid a wave of mass shootings, Florida cracks down on chalk www.motherjones.com/politics/202...

1/9/2025, 11:43:34 AM | 97 19 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Kid: Have you ever won a trophy? Wife: Yes, I won a trophy for debate. Kid: What's that? Wife: It's like arguing. Kid: Oh. Was anyone else complaining? Wife: No, it's like trying to make people agree with you. Kid: So... was anyone else complaining?

1/9/2025, 12:30:59 AM | 10 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

"Surfaces are very important to me..."

31/8/2025, 2:00:17 PM | 4 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

here you go

image
31/8/2025, 1:02:56 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Yes, things are going just great in California, Illinois, and New York...

image
31/8/2025, 1:01:10 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

I agree that the Newsom tweets are hilarious. But I'd be annoyed if my tax dollars or campaign contributions were paying for them.

31/8/2025, 12:52:39 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Every dollar, every minute, every staffer writing all-caps tweets has an opportunity cost

31/8/2025, 12:51:05 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

"Sure, my family can't afford a house in California," the swing voter who just moved to Nevada said. "But did you see Gavin Newsom's sick burn on the social media site formerly known as Twitter?"

31/8/2025, 12:48:55 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Hot take: Dem governors should spend less time trolling Donald Trump and more time turning their states into models of successful liberal governance that voters across the country would be likely to choose over Trumpism...

31/8/2025, 12:46:00 PM | 17 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Garrett M. Graff (@vermontgmg.bsky.social) reposted

If you don’t believe that Trump’s authoritarianism can be defeated, look at how scared MAGA is of chalk:

30/8/2025, 9:53:17 PM | 2549 733 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Seems like we’re setting the bar unnecessarily low here

30/8/2025, 11:37:28 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Wait, have people seriously managed to convinced themselves Trump is dead, or is it a joke, or so of each?

30/8/2025, 11:34:48 PM | 10 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Letting your 80-pound German shepherds attack your security detail and publicly berating and posting video of your landscapers are both absolutely sociopathic boss behavior

30/8/2025, 10:00:36 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture jael holzman (@jael.bsky.social) reposted

“The claim that trans people are disproportionately responsible for mass violence in America comes up every few months. It has never been true.” USA Today fact check from their extremism beat reporter www.usatoday.com/story/news/n...

No, there is not an 'epidemic' of shootings by trans people Portrait of Will Carless Will Carless USA TODAY
30/8/2025, 5:21:34 PM | 1305 315 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

The president’s posting one-star contractor reviews on his proprietary Yelp site while DHS tweets about the true meaning of fire-fighting…

30/8/2025, 7:36:58 PM | 20 5 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

It would be extremely funny if the result of nuking universal injunctions ends up being that the tariffs exist only in red states whose AGs are too afraid of Trump to sue...

image
30/8/2025, 6:24:24 PM | 30 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Joel S. (@joelhs.bsky.social) reposted

Chris Van Hollen is literally calling for a ceasefire and end to the war here, and he has been more pro-Palestine than all but maybe one or two other senators, but a lot of the replies here seem angry at him for deigning to talk to Israelis at all.

29/8/2025, 11:42:34 PM | 82 17 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Is that just, like, non-ideological authoritarianism? Principled, consistent opposition to free speech?? It's weird!

29/8/2025, 2:10:17 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Who are the 1/3 of Trump voters who think opponents of same sex marriage should be banned from speaking on campus??

image
29/8/2025, 2:09:12 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

So much fascinating stuff in this poll www.theargumentmag.com/p/when-ameri...

29/8/2025, 2:09:12 PM | 3 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Anthony Michael Kreis (@anthonymkreis.bsky.social) reposted

I think we can start to consider whether this is a trend of actual grand jury nullification. We will never really know given secrecy. The sandwich case was dreadfully overcharged. That said, given the rarity of no bills… these jurors are not rolling over for prosecutors in this moment.

29/8/2025, 2:00:18 PM | 202 37 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Henry Carnell (@hencarnell.bsky.social) reposted

"To blame the unnerving prevalence of mass shootings in America on the existence of trans people here isn’t just a dangerously stigmatizing, politically motivated take. It’s also bad math." - @abbyvesoulis.bsky.social

28/8/2025, 9:49:21 PM | 366 112 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

It's shocking how many people claiming to identify "patterns" are apparently unfamiliar with the concept of a "denominator"

28/8/2025, 3:21:11 PM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

I just think her death is a tragedy. She paid the ultimate price for her catastrophically bad decisions. Recognizing her prior service doesn't bother me in the same way that other J6 revisionism does. I don't object to people disagreeing with me about this, though.

28/8/2025, 2:46:43 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Trump's attempts to whitewash and even valorize January 6 are generally outrageous and appalling. But I don't really object to this... thehill.com/policy/defen...

28/8/2025, 2:21:40 PM | 4 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Max Dubler 🏳️‍🌈 (@maxdubler.com) reposted

Here’s the clip of CM Padilla bragging about reducing the size of a 100% affordable housing project in her district and increasing the amount of parking while arguing against the transit oriented upzoning bill SB 79. (ED 1 is an affordable housing program in LA.)

27/8/2025, 10:03:10 PM | 853 140 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

It would be an outrageously absurd outcome if Trump, Biden, and Hillary Clinton all got away with this but John Bolton went to jail

27/8/2025, 10:54:21 PM | 4 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

The replies to this are completely deranged. Even if you are too short-sighted and amoral to care about the ethics of this, what's described in this story is quite obviously going to be just as politically effective as putting donor cash directly into a paper shredder

27/8/2025, 8:23:56 PM | 8 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Bowser seems to be in favor of federal law enforcement working with MPD and against ICE raids and checkpoints and the National Guard occupation. If she were able to end the latter things by embracing the former thing, that would probably be pretty popular in DC. Big "if," though...

27/8/2025, 8:16:26 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

They are creating an unemployment crisis in DC (which can't possibly be good for preventing crime), but those jobs still need to be done, so they are involuntarily importing workers from elsewhere and creating labor shortages in those places

27/8/2025, 3:27:41 PM | 3 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

This is insane. DOGE fires NPS workers, ostensibly for "efficiency" and to save money. DOD then removes National Guard members from their full-time civilian jobs in Mississippi, pays to house and equip them in DC, and has them shovel mulch. www.washingtonpost.com/national-sec...

27/8/2025, 3:13:19 PM | 36 24 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

If there was a truly a silent majority in DC that was grateful to Trump for "liberating" the city, you'd think that would show up in grand jury indictments

27/8/2025, 2:59:53 PM | 13 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

These "tragic mishaps" keep happening. They are either not "mishaps" or not something the Israeli government actually believes is "tragic." apnews.com/article/isra...

image
26/8/2025, 5:16:03 PM | 4 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

My controversial opinion is that legally arresting and successfully prosecuting people illegally carrying guns makes DC safer, but that illegally arresting people for carrying guns and having to drop the charges makes DC less safe!

26/8/2025, 2:14:30 PM | 15 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

I don't dispute that if tariffs do end up causing massive inflation and/or the AI bubble bursts, that will matter at the polls. But amid the absolutely chaos and catastrophe of 2020, Trump lost by like ~40,000 votes.

26/8/2025, 1:56:02 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Democrats have spent the last decade insisting that the latest Trump outrage will surely tank the market and crash the economy and then voters will learn their lesson and vote for Dems. That keeps not happening, so Dems are just gonna have to convince people that living in a police state is bad!

26/8/2025, 1:45:44 PM | 17 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

(I don't actually think that's a good idea, but as bad ideas go, it's both funny and relatively inexpensive.)

26/8/2025, 1:33:32 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Have Democrats considered simply trying to get the SCOTUS conservatives to overturn Arizona State Legislature v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission?

26/8/2025, 1:32:24 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Andrew Lawrence (@ndrew.bsky.social) reposted

been offline for an hour or so to reflect on everything and decided that as long as the federal reserve remains independent and we keep getting commercial packages from japan that everything is going to be ok

26/8/2025, 12:45:35 AM | 913 82 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

wut

25/8/2025, 4:29:40 PM | 3 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Bill Grueskin (@bgrueskin.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

And @sulliview.bsky.social theorizes that the Times might have held off reporting the payoffs they witnessed (only to follow The City’s scoop) because they were “working on a bigger, more sweeping investigation” … and today’s NYT story supports that theory. www.nytimes.com/2025/08/25/n...

25/8/2025, 1:40:38 PM | 79 34 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Bill Grueskin (@bgrueskin.bsky.social) reposted

@sulliview.bsky.social is no longer at the Washpost and NYT, but she’s still asking tough questions about the choices their newsrooms are making. margaretsullivan.substack.com/p/cash-hando...

25/8/2025, 12:49:09 PM | 124 38 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Gertz (@mattgertz.bsky.social) reposted

1) ABC/NBC should lose license or pay hefty fees because their reporting is mean to him. 2) MD should maybe lose bridge repair funds because Wes Moore was mean to him. 3) The feds should investigate Chris Christie for Bridgegate because he was mean to him.

image image image image
25/8/2025, 1:24:35 PM | 10177 3451 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

This is increasingly outrageous. They've basically rendered him stateless. Canada should give the whole family asylum.

25/8/2025, 2:06:18 PM | 15 5 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

"When I was your age, son, we had to learn two contradictory definitions of 'liberalism' just to pass civics class..."

25/8/2025, 1:59:31 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

It's funny that, thanks to Donald Trump, the American definition of "liberalism" and the international/historical/polisci definition of "liberalism" have completely converged

25/8/2025, 1:58:16 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Same reporters; bigger story www.nytimes.com/2025/08/25/n...

25/8/2025, 1:18:18 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Clara was right!

25/8/2025, 1:17:40 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Tim Murphy (@timothypmurphy.bsky.social) reposted

and *that's* why the Times had all those photographers and reporters at various Chinese-American political events in the city before the chips story www.nytimes.com/2025/08/25/n...

25/8/2025, 12:14:45 PM | 15 6 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

A more productive line of research for these groups would be figuring out how to more effectively communicate that police states are indeed bad

24/8/2025, 5:23:38 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Monika Bauerlein (@monikab.bsky.social) reposted

This is a smart piece by @abbyvesoulis.bsky.social that applies to DC, but also more widely. Protest and resistance don't necessarily take the form of big marches, but that's what we (and media in particular) have conditioned ourselves to expect. www.motherjones.com/politics/202...

24/8/2025, 4:42:26 PM | 91 27 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

It's very weird that powerful Democrats can look at what is going on right now and think it's a good time to give the Trump administration new tools to suppress political satire www.nytimes.com/2025/08/20/o...

24/8/2025, 2:59:48 PM | 5 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

OK, but did this event successfully save the oceans?

24/8/2025, 2:36:09 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Also not sure we want to hold up the post-WWI negotiations as a model for achieving peace...

24/8/2025, 2:30:08 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

He obviously right that this war is only going to end with some sort of negotiated settlement, but that's a pretty wild thing to say about WWII!

24/8/2025, 2:28:57 PM | 6 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

That how Republicans portrayed it, anyway. The money was also supposed to go toward making sure the Jefferson Memorial wasn't toppled by the woke waters of the Tidal Basin www.washingtonpost.com/archive/loca...

image
22/8/2025, 3:47:39 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

In 2009, Republicans had an absolute meltdown because Obama's stimulus bill included funding for re-sodding the National Mall...

22/8/2025, 3:41:37 PM | 7 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) reposted

Rep. John McGuire on the FBI raiding John Bolton's home: "I'm glad they're going after him."

22/8/2025, 1:07:58 PM | 513 103 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Media Matters for America (@mmfa.bsky.social) reposted

Fox News panel expresses concern over FBI's Bolton raid: “There is a great concern about whether this is retaliation against a political opponent”

22/8/2025, 3:04:40 PM | 202 54 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

I was kidding! I do not actually think he used to take young Eric to DC on Amtrak to see the dinosaurs fossils

21/8/2025, 6:07:49 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Aaron Reichlin-Melnick (@reichlinmelnick.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

Mr. Escalona's case exemplifies how the problems in "Tren de Aragua" identification predated Trump — and how flimsy most evidence of "gang ties" really is. The U.S. government declared a man a gang member because he was wearing one of the most popular shoes in the world, and still stand by that.

21/8/2025, 3:06:15 PM | 145 26 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Aaron Reichlin-Melnick (@reichlinmelnick.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

The ONLY evidence that the U.S. government has ever offered to suggest this man is a gang member is that in 2023, he was on a bus in Guatemala and U.S. officials in the country doing migration checks saw that he was wearing Air Jordans. Seriously. That's it. Wearing Air Jordans. That was it.

21/8/2025, 3:04:18 PM | 224 86 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

americanhistory.si.edu/explore/exhi...

image
21/8/2025, 3:01:27 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

What, you don't think he'd take his kids down on the train for the weekend to help them learn about dinosaurs?

21/8/2025, 2:56:05 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

nmaahc.si.edu/explore/exhi...

image
21/8/2025, 2:47:12 PM | 9 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

It's extremely weird that these folks are claiming to be under the impression that the Smithsonian museums don't already "talk about hope and progress."

21/8/2025, 2:42:06 PM | 28 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Mark Copelovitch (@mcopelov.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

Once again, Congress, under both parties, created an imperial presidency from WWII onward that depended entirely on shared norms about democracy/the rule of law & not abusing that delegated executive authority that no longer exists. When we get through this, of these things need to go.

20/8/2025, 10:41:19 PM | 285 63 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

People do actually understand that the Vance couch meme is completely fake ... right?

20/8/2025, 8:11:54 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Kashana (@kashana.bsky.social) reposted

People are so excited that we might be on the verge of civil war. I’m not. I’m a basic bitch who likes basic things like pumpkin spice lattes and not getting shot at in the grocery store.

19/8/2025, 10:49:28 PM | 15609 1787 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

such speech. very freedom. wow.

image
19/8/2025, 1:41:23 AM | 6 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

probably shoulda just stick with SpinCo

18/8/2025, 1:57:15 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Dave Itzkoff (@ditzkoff.bsky.social) reposted

they've already got a great new logo for MS NOW

Mr. Burns pointing to the letters (from his perspective) M and S on a sundial
18/8/2025, 1:35:30 PM | 296 30 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Delaware has one House seat...

image
18/8/2025, 1:29:11 PM | 13 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Dan Friedman (@dfriedman.bsky.social) reposted

Crowd cheers as cops leave.

14/8/2025, 2:09:04 AM | 1669 275 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Dan Friedman (@dfriedman.bsky.social) reposted

ICE is gone but DC cops are still out at V and 14th, getting heckled by an angry crowd after one person was supposedly arrested by feds in a roadblock aimed at immigrants

14/8/2025, 2:07:05 AM | 376 112 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

'God save thee, pink polo shirt Guy! From the fascists, that plague thy head!— Why look'st that way?'—With my Subway I humiliated the FED.

14/8/2025, 3:07:25 AM | 6 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Stephanie Mencimer (@smencimer.bsky.social) reposted

Your weekly reminder that DC's sole congressional delegate, who might be counted on to protest Trump's latest assault on the city's autonomy, is 88 and too old to drive. www.motherjones.com/politics/202...

11/8/2025, 4:21:48 PM | 376 85 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Tearing down hostage posters has to have been one of the most counter-productive forms of protest in human history. Freeing the hostages is the anti-war position in Israel, and it's insane that it is the opposite here. www.timesofisrael.com/families-of-...

10/8/2025, 2:16:40 PM | 2 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Mother Jones (@motherjones.com) reposted

"Trump is asking Texas Republicans to redraw the maps that they just drew in 2021 to get him five more seats to protect his majority in Congress, because he’s worried about losing it in the next election."

8/8/2025, 5:21:20 PM | 868 311 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

Yes, because of how Katsas decided the dispute, he would — as Pillard says in dissent — technically go "further" than Rao. But, look at Katsas's closing (left) v. Rao's closing (right), and tell me who is more extreme. (And, also, lol that Rao technically left proceedings open. Sure she did.)

The district court here was placed in an enormously difficult position. Faced with an emergency situation, it had to digest and rule upon novel and complex issues within a matter of hours. In that context, the court quite understandably issued a written order that contained some ambiguity. And it quite understandably made oral remarks that it later walked back. This proceeding does not concern the lawfulness of the AEA removals made on March 15 and 16. Nor may we decide whether the government's aggressive implementation of the presidential proclamation warrants praise or criticism as a policy matter. Perhaps it should warrant more careful judicial scrutiny in the future. Perhaps it already has. See A.A.R.P. II, 145 S. Ct. at 1367-68; A.A.R.P. v. Trump, 145 S. Ct. 1034 (Mem.) (2025). Regardless, the government's initial implementation of the proclamation clearly and indisputably was not criminal. Given this analysis, I concur in the order granting the petition for mandamus and vacating the probable-cause order. And because no prosecution could overcome the fatal ambiguity explained above, I would also terminate the criminal-contempt proceeding. Whether to proceed with criminal contempt is a choice left to the district court, which “enjoys a discretion akin to the non- prosecution power in the executive.” Potter, 126 F.4th at 725. With the issuance of this writ of mandamus, I would not assume that such an extraordinary step is forthcoming. See D.V.D., 2025 WL 1832186, at *1 (assuming the district court will comply with the Supreme Court’s decision and “cease enforc[ement]” of the stayed injunction). In any event, today we correct the particular error before us. If the district court chooses the problematic and uncertain path of criminal contempt, the government may seek relief from this court to remedy any specific harms arising from the district court’s actions. * * * The district court used the threat of criminal contempt to coerce the Executive Branch to comply with an order it had no authority to enforce. And it directed that coercion toward the Executive’s exercise of its foreign affairs power. The significance of the district court’s error, coupled with the potential for abuse in future cases, justifies our intervention at this stage of the proceedings. Considering the “totality of the circumstances,” the writ is appropriate. In re Kellogg Brown & Root, 756 F.3d at 762. For the foregoing reasons, I concur in the decision to grant the government’s petition for a writ of mandamus and to vacate the district court’s order.
8/8/2025, 2:59:16 PM | 120 12 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

Rao, unsurprisingly, is more extreme here, calling Boasberg's actions — not the Trump administration's moves — "egregious."

Punishment through criminal contempt might still be available in these circumstances, but the district court cannot use the threat of such punishment as a backdoor to obtain compliance with a vacated and therefore unenforceable TRO. The district court’s abuse of the contempt power is especially egregious because contempt proceedings against senior Executive Branch officials carry profound “separation of power[s] overtones” that demand the most “sensitive judicial scrutiny.” In re Att’y Gen. of U.S., 596 F.2d 58, 64 (2d Cir. 1979). Lacking the authority to compel obedience, the district court nonetheless pressured the government to take custody of alleged alien enemies held in El Salvador. This intrusion on the President’s foreign affairs authority “constitute[s] an unwarranted impairment of another branch in the performance of its constitutional duties.” Cheney, 542 U.S. at 390. Because the order exceeds the court’s authority and amounts to a clear abuse of discretion, mandamus is appropriate.
8/8/2025, 2:48:59 PM | 139 25 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

This, in sum, is the grounds on which Katsas decided the matter:

At the end of this dispute lies a much simpler question. By its terms, the TRO prohibited the government from “removing” suspected TdA members. This prohibition could be interpreted in either of two ways. It might have barred the government simply from expelling detainees from United States territory. Or, it might have barred the government from surrendering custody of the detainees to a foreign sovereign. All agree that the government did not violate the TRO under the former view, so the contempt question boils down to a straightforward interpretive dispute over what constituted “removing” within the meaning of the TRO. For purposes of criminal contempt, ambiguities in the underlying injunction must be resolved in favor of the alleged contemnor. At the time of the alleged contempt, just hours after the TRO hearing and before any transcript of it was available, the district court’s minute order could reasonably have been read either way. Thus, the TRO cannot support a criminal-contempt conviction here. The government has sought review of the probable-cause order by way of appeal and mandamus. There is no basis for interlocutory appellate jurisdiction. Nonetheless, mandamus is appropriate because the government is plainly correct about the merits of the criminal contempt, and our saying so now would prevent long disputes between the Executive and the Judiciary over difficult, contentious issues regarding the courts’ power to control foreign policy or prosecutions, or to impose criminal sanctions for violating injunctions entered without jurisdiction. In circumstances much less fraught than these, courts have reviewed interlocutory orders through mandamus to prevent extended inter-branch conflict.
8/8/2025, 2:45:32 PM | 93 15 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Dara Lind (@daralind.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

“Motte and bbailey” is the perfect term for this phenomenon thank you

8/8/2025, 2:43:23 AM | 62 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Bluebberrygeddon is delightful

8/8/2025, 12:49:16 AM | 5 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jamal Greene (@jamalgreene.bsky.social) reposted

I think the Harper's letter was fine. I declined to sign it, but I did not disagree with any of it then, don't disagree with it today, and take no issue with anyone else having signed it. Here's the link. It's fine. harpers.org/a-letter-on-...

7/8/2025, 4:20:26 PM | 10 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

theonion.com/dnc-aiming-t...

7/8/2025, 3:31:48 PM | 9 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

yes... maybe? the right-wing discourse around them seems interrelated to me in a way I think is fascinating but can't quite articulate

6/8/2025, 7:43:47 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

I have some suede shoes that I wear in the rain, and I'm comfortable with that life decision

6/8/2025, 7:32:14 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

Kinda seems like Democrats are a bit *too trustful* of "medical researchers"

6/8/2025, 5:32:02 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

JFC -- remember the outrageous when Bill Clinton talked to Loretta Lynch on the tarmac?

image
6/8/2025, 4:48:23 PM | 6 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

Like ... come on www.cnn.com/2025/08/05/p...

6/8/2025, 4:46:46 PM | 6 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

I still think there is essentially zero credible evidence that Trump committed any Epstein-related crimes. But this is ridiculous... abcnews.go.com/US/trump-adm...

6/8/2025, 4:40:30 PM | 6 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social)

There are many reasons why Trump should not, and legally cannot, "federalize" DC -- but "LOL it's funny and good that Big Balls got car-jacked [insert misinformation here]" is definitely not one of them

6/8/2025, 1:39:06 PM | 12 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jeremy Schulman (@jeremyschulman.bsky.social) reply parent

No specific deadline — just a topic I’m interested in getting pitches for that we’d consider assigning

6/8/2025, 12:23:19 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view