Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Someone call Jake Tapper!
UBC CS PhD student - formal verification of hardware and software (also occasionally theory of computation) - hobbyist nature photographer - #CovidIsAirborne
157 followers 152 following 737 posts
view profile on Bluesky Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Someone call Jake Tapper!
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
existence of analog AI implies existence of digital true intelligence 🤔
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
are you my first phd advisor 😂
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I'm waiting for all the people that way to start protesting against the US government owning 10% of Intel since that's central planning 👻
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Though fish can have other fun things like mercury 😷
born miserable (@bornmiserable.bsky.social) reposted
opening a Spirit Halloween where my patience used to be
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
👍
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
It's not just "fair criticisms" against the acts, they're written by people who fundamentally don't understand how technology works. They're both ineffective at their intended purpose and a privacy/censorship nightmare.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Did you even read the article you linked? They explicitly say they’re against arbitrary ISP blocking, not defending the site specifically.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
@edzitron.com has spoken quite a bit about how this is why management loves AI - if your job is meetings and emails instead of actually producing something then this seems amazing.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
About as scientific as any other airborne precaution policy 😛
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I recall seeing that the BCG vaccine for TB was associated with reduced dementia risk in men too.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
If they won't take precautions for airborne viruses then what's a little particulate matter on top 😷
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
excuse me sir, do you have a moment to talk about DEET
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
value = (mc + discounted)^2
T. Ryan Gregory 🇨🇦 (@tryangregory.bsky.social) reposted
And boy do they project their hopes and rationalize everything he does.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
We were hoping you would achieve enlightenment in the wilderness and lead us out of this ☹️
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
😂😂😂
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
as an economist you decided storage today is worth more than the same storage next weekend 😛
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
He’s learned from Ford/Trump/Brexit/etc that if you don’t communicate a clear plan then your voters can just project whatever they want onto you.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I brought one such direction up to my advisor and he told me the joke “Two economists are walking down the street and pass by a $20 bill on the ground without stopping. The first one says ‘Was that a $20 bill?’ and the second replies ‘No, if it was then someone would have picked it up already.’
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Showing this video to everyone who complains about lithium car batteries' potential for catching fire.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I find it so fascinating how people threw a huge tantrum about the public health measures until they were lifted, but then they simultaneously seem to think that if the virus was that dangerous then someone would be telling them to wear a mask or stay home.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
“If the government, who I disagree with, can’t force Cracker Barrel, who I disagree with, to change its logo back to the old one, which I disagree with, then I will have to become an even bigger libertarian, who I disagree with. By Glenn Greenwald”
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
We're also fucked for the current pandemic 😷
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I lost respect for him after he called someone out for "plagiarizing" his screenshot of a CBC broadcast lmao
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
They'll try telling people and discover that doesn't work either 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
But what if one of them was doing good enough research to get a fellowship? 🙀 /s
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Well yeah, how else will they justify their next goal of forcing online platforms to break secure encryption? 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Plus Discounted: A Value Story
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
About as long as it will take them to realize it's airborne 😷
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social)
A barred owl at Jericho Beach yesterday evening. @bskyphotos.bsky.social #owl #barredowl #bird #birds #photography #NaturePhotography #JerichoBeach
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
existence of baking soda implies existence of diet baking soda
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Fascinating! A few years ago my optometrist noticed I needed prism glasses for reading (for me it's not long COVID but ME/CFS)
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
It's kind of confusing that online booking (at least for routine appointments) hasn't taken off more - seems like it would save everyone time.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Sunk cost fallacy is a helluva drug 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Back to work legislation defeats the purpose of unions 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Very cool! I’m just hoping Health Canada gives some extra scrutiny to the fact that this particular FDA approved it 🧐
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I feel that way more broadly towards people afraid of AI becoming smarter than humans - if *gestures broadly* this is the best that human intelligence can do then let's give the machines a try.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
The point I'm getting at is that the AI in the article above was not trained on any art or writing - it's a statistical model to predict a variable. You're conflating AI with LLM's, and so your criticisms of LLM's aren't even applicable here.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Ok, great, but that's not answering my question.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Genuine question: in what way do you think the AI in the article above is stealing from artists and authors?
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Personally I still consider that terrifying 🙃 Either they're supervising it enough that they may as well just do it themselves anyways, or they're not and letting LLM hallucinations into their work.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
The paper they cite uses machine learning (as opposed to deep neural networks), so it would also be accurate to say they're using statistics in healthcare. Calling it AI is a double-edged sword since it gets funding and publicity based on the hype, but also hate from the "AI = ChatGPT = bad" crowd.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
For clarity: MY reason for disliking LLM's is that I think trying to squeeze the entire internet into autocorrect is fundamentally a silly idea that won't lead anywhere near AGI.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social)
I suspect that people gravitate towards this criticism because it's harder to argue with than their real reason for disliking LLM's (believing that training AI is theft, being afraid of having their job automated, believing that only humans can think and create, etc.)
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
For a fun case study on this, look at all the mailing list drama related to introducing Rust into the Linux kernel.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Evergreen skeet 😵💫
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
or cosmodesic, depending on the language 🤔
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
a) this is why you get a prompt showing the full file name asking for admin privileges when you run a new executable on Windows now b) Do you have any idea how many people would be lost after accidentally changing or removing a file extension and it suddenly “not working”?
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Not sure why it’s originally this way, but I imagine it saves tech support a lot of headaches so no one’s calling for it to be changed.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
It’s also taking advantage of already disabled people willing to try anything because the medical system can’t cure them.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
*jordan peterson voice* What does it even mean to take time off? Surely you can’t cease EVERYTHING.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
as value continues to fluctuate, plus discounted is increasingly critical
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
That’s the way you do it
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
That was already obvious from their “CEO says a thing” pieces without any intelligent questions
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
existence of lidposter implies existence of jarposter
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
*left handed high five*
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
And tsk’d loudly at the shark’s breach of ✨decorum✨
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
“We stabbed the shark in the eye using 8 pointed questions in our letter” - Chuck Schumer
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
“A rising tide lifts all boats*” *we have excluded the Titanic from our dataset
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Economists generally agree that a carbon tax is the most effective solution to climate change.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Or if you don’t wear a mask indoors you might get to experience it yourself 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I think this merits a Smiling Man 😃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Or the brown shirt leadership, who were useful right up until they posed a threat.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I’d speculate it’s not the queries as much as the fact it’s trained on human-created content.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Just in time for back to school 😷
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
existence of cattle prod implies existence of cattle QA testing
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Translation: I need to run more focus groups before picking a position on that.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Most people also don’t understand the math of transmission and exponential growth. “Rare” times the entire population is a bigger number than people realize.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
"The question of whether machines can think is about as relevant as the question of whether submarines can swim." - Edsger W. Dijkstra
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
The technology exists but it’s being suppressed by big nap.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Declining hardware costs don't matter if every new model keeps requiring more 🫠
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
If someone wrote the past decade or so as a fiction novel it would be rejected for being too weird and unbelievable.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
The difference when people want to be helped is amazing 😂😭
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Once you discover proper transit infrastructure you never want to go back!
Jill Weinberger (@jillybobww.bsky.social) reposted
If you consider yourself an ethical, intelligent, & informed person & you insist on any version of, "We have to stop fighting for the rights of in order to achieve our other goals," I don't know what to tell you other than that you are not ethical, intelligent, or informed.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
The Guardian (@theguardian.com) reposted
Scientists find link between genes and ME/chronic fatigue syndrome
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Personally I wouldn't base a decision around that (though I think I'm more skeptical of LLM's than you are in general). Remote options like Google Colab (or academic compute, companies selling LLM queries at a loss, etc.) wouldn't tie you to this year's laptop hardware for those capabilities.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I think so. I've heard good things about Apple M chips, but personally the premium you pay for the hardware you get still puts me off of it.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Probably. Though in general being good at numerical computation is on the opposite end of tradeoffs to what one typically looks for in a laptop (battery life, weight, cooling, etc.)
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
It would help if cities started actually enforcing traffic laws again.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Corollary: d/dx MC^2 + f(land, capital, energy, residual) = MC^2 + f(land, capital, energy, residual)
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I've heard lawyers say the advice on the legal-focused subreddits is extremely bad too.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
If they knew there were other options would they be Tesla fans? 😛
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Be the change you want to see in the world 🤗
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Could you narrow it down a bit? 🫠
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Oh absolutely it's nothing new. I'm just kind of disappointed by how many people I thought should know better started going along with it then.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
This idea was normalized to a lot of previously-left leaning people when society collectively decided that some disabled people dying (and lots of people becoming disabled) was an acceptable price to pay for ending COVID containment measures.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Most people simply aren’t aware that invisible disabilities exist 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
If it’s anything like how university administration chooses IT contractors they simply ignore the relevant experts’ input 🙃
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I wonder if they know what the “V” in HIV is 🤔
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Hopefully MRNA technology can cure AI cancer soon 😞
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
That too! I always ask why we're not allowed to donate blood if it's a psychological problem.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I find that the process of becoming a doctor selects for people extremely good at following instructions, so they tend to be a bit lost when they encounter something they weren’t given a clear solution to in med school.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
To some extent, but it’s also hindered by e.g. the Cochrane review recommending graded exercise therapy that they refuse to retract (they changed the definition of “improvement” so that even people who got worse from it were counted as benefiting).
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
I strongly suspect that it's because those issues are ~4x more likely to affect women. I've noticed a disturbing difference in how helpful doctors try to be now that I'm attending appointments as an adult man vs when I was a child and they were primarily interacting with my mother.
Patrick Devaney (@patrickdevaney.bsky.social) reply parent
Yeah, the little silver lining of COVID for those of us with ME/CFS is that this is the most attention doctors and scientists have ever given it 🫠