Mina all the way.

My team, quite obviously.

Remind us on the point system again?

SF? LOL

First 2 picks for each are a push but Mina’s next 3 are much stronger.

SF, WAS, and DEN are all lottery picks whereas Mina has some sure fire consistency up and down

Mina wins but Seahawks will finish ahead of SF, Detroit and Washington.

I listened to this.. and thought the whole time Mike was getting the better of you. Seeing it on paper, I only feel *great* about his Baltimore selection.

Mina

Mina, and I don't think it's too close 🤷🏻‍♂️

5 playoff teams for Mina vs 3 for Mike. Easy math

With Detroit and Green Bay, I think Mina will win this.

You and easily. You're almost certain to have the NFC championship teams, and could have one of the likely AFC ones as well. Mike has the other two AFC favourites, but wouldn't be surprised if the rest of his picks miss the playoffs altogether.

Mina has 4 division winners as well as Detroit. Mike has 2 division winners in KC & BAL and is left hoping the Niners bounce back.

Mina wins the first 5, but I think Mike's pick of the Bucs at 12 was absolutely the steal of the draft. Pretty much a lock for double digit win (11 is probably the floor) and an easy division win.

Well, Green Bay is beating Philly, Detroit, and Baltimore on the way to the Super Bowl, so you’ve pretty much got it in the bag

Lost to Philly 2x last year then spent all offseason whinny little bitches trying to change the rules

GO BIRDS

I have to think Mike, but only because Mina has apparently moved KC and BAL out of the top 5. After the last 6 seasons, I still don't know how anyone can pick KC out of the top 3. The O-line got better, and they will likely be healthier on offense.

From a Niner fan, I'll be surprised if we make the playoffs. I'd actually bet on us being 3rd in a weak division.

Really? That schedule is very easy. I think last year was a doen year but you will bounce back. Stafford may be hobbled. Gannon is a trash coach. Darnold? I like your chances. And if McCaffrey is healthy I think you will be quite good. Have a great season!

I'm very skeptical of our defense, especially the secondary. Trent Williams is gonna start showing his age eventually and he's the only reason our O line looks average at best. I'm also on the Purdy = Dalton line camp. Think rams got the division and AZ or Sea are more likely to overpreform.

I'm WAY more of an NBA head these days, though, so I'll defer my judgment to others.

BUF/BAL cancel out, otherwise I have Mina winning 3-1. DEN being Mike's only win.

If we're just going H2H on those five...

Denver's division is much tougher than Houston's though. Houston could go 5-1/6-0 in div. Denver? Maybe 3-3/4-2?

Fair. I think Denver's better, but we're just talking regular season wins, so yeah.

Mina and it’s not even close.

Mina, you win. But it's close.

No Vikings. Unserious.

You win because SF ain't going nowhere this season.

The implosion of that team has been really fun to watch

LAR?? No one??

Mike is toast

Mina has the #1 seed and 4 teams with a shot, Mike has 3 teams with a shot( really 1) kinda a bloodbath for Mina

You’re closer than he is, but he has Baltimore sitting where I would put them.

LETS GO MINAAAAAAAAA

Is there any doubt

I'm hopeful for BAL but wooof some bold picks by Mike there

Mike really going with high risk high reward (SF has cmc, but an easy sked, Jayden trying to avoid the soph slump) and Mina picking rosters with depth. But then Micah goes to GB, too. Gonna be close! I think if cmc stays healthy Mike can pull it off, but

Golic is out of his mind picking SF third

Mina is very sweet on 2025 Green Bay

You

You.

Mina by a mile. You’re hedged in the NFC North and I wouldn’t be surprised if SF, WAS and DEN make it.

You crushed this IMO

Let’s go Buffalo!!!

KC is yesterday's news.

No one agrees with you.

Don't be annoying, Max! (Already got two likes for the post; many thousands will follow.)

People like a post dunking on KC?! No way.

I would rather be you. You have the NFC winner and BUF. I’m much lower on DEN than you guys, they need to prove it against teams that have good QBs before I buy in. WAS is so old and will regress. Not buying SF at all. BAL is solid. KC I think still wins the division.

Not Mike

Mina wins

Mina san fran and denver are the 2 worst teams of this group

Mina’s picks are better by a mile

Mina

Mina! 4-3. DET very overrated this year. They lost both coordinators, their center, a guard, and that division is way better. BUT...SF? Just stop it. Most overrated team in the league. Who's catching passes for this team?? DC? REGRESSION CITY. Oldest team in the league, shady secondary. Hard sched.

You DEFINITELY got the worst pick in HOU…

Mike because he has both Super Bowl teams again (KC and Tampa)

Mina

Why do so many think SF will be that good? Lost so many good players and their WR corp is weak.

Their DL is Bosa and rookies

They think prime CMC will play a full 17 week season

IR by week 5

That Green Bay pick looking real good, you got this one

Mina!!!

So would you have picked GB higher if this took place after the trade?

Yes

You got the steal of the draft!

I’m baffled how the media think SF will win the Super Bowl. Last place in the division, tons of injuries, mediocre talent (aside from 1 injury-prone star). Their cupcake schedule may work in the regular season, but not the playoffs/SB.

I'd say you win because Washington and Denver are only going to get seven and five wins, respectively.

Mina - by a lot.