2/ This resulted in over-enforcement and temporary suspensions for multiple users. We have reinstated accounts of some users, and are continuing to review appeals.
2/ This resulted in over-enforcement and temporary suspensions for multiple users. We have reinstated accounts of some users, and are continuing to review appeals.
Errors are inevitable. All social media companies should err on the side of caution and safety, as you are. Keep up the great work!
Ok. Chill. I too have received questionable posts/follows… Just vet them, block them and move on. Be your own control and give Blue a chance to get up to pace.
Thank you for your help in dealing with @BlueSky marauders!
Please don’t give in. Please don’t cave to those who will come on this platform to spew lies with fake accounts. Stand up to these trolls and suspend them all.
Here here😂😂😂✌️
Thank you 🙏🏼
so - that's why you put a "content warning" on a Palestinian girl asking for help for her dad? I noted that the warning you issued fit exactly 0 of the categories you listed in your help section. Moderate sure - but leave your racism at home.
Bot accounts often have gofundme links for their scam. They'll claim they're this or that person from so and so place, but reality is they're simply trying to con out of money. It's a common occurence on all social media. They're simply trying to keep it in check.
There are multiple sites available for you to donate to.This particular one was not verified at the time.No solicitations are allowed that are unverified ,and for good reason.Admin are currently drowning in bad players whose sole purpose is to grift you and turn this place into their sewer.
It's a gofundme link. Hardly suspect. If it had fit one of various categories like spam, the content warning would have indicated that.
I mean GoFundMe is full of scams
Did you click on it?
I did
Ok. Admin are swamped and had to issue a blanket(if temporary cull).They issued a warning, which is fair.. I can confidently say that racism does not apply in this case or any other.
Hoping this resolves the incorrect label placed on @lolibangbang.bsky.social profile. She doesn’t post adult content but her user name unfortunately gets flagged for csam. She hasn’t received email yet. But have appealed the label
Do what you need to.
you could just do like facebook does, and offer appeals with the disclaimer that "not all appeals will be heard" and then just send them ALL to a dead letter office...
So let me see if I get this right: You've had concerns, you decided to take extra precautions, and you plan on growing the moderation team going forward? And you don't plan on making hate part of the business model? Ummmm...thanks. Like, a lot.
lot of people could have warned you that would happen boss!
That's probably what they meant by "predictable"
Account suspension, as opposed to hiding specific posts, should never be a preventive mass measure, especially if you use a "strike" system for bans. The worst offenders, like the bots from that hate website, use throwaway accounts anyway.
I call bullshit. You didn't reinstate every account
3/ We notified users who were affected by this decision by email, and they can appeal by replying to the email. Anyone who appeals will get a comprehensive review and will be reinstated if they have not violated our Community Guidelines.
Can we share our profile links in the comment section to get followers?Is it against bluesky's policies? Please reply me.
Please don't do that; it will make you a target for scammers, bad actors, and disinformation networks. The best way to find people is to follow some feeds that interest you and have conversations with people!
Thanks ❤️
against policy? no. an incredibly shitty, horrible thing to do that would mark you in everybody's eyes as pathetic and trashy? yes.
your goal in life should not be "to get followers". go talk about something interesting with people who are interested in it.
"We notified users who were affected by this decision by email..." As someone who was affected and received NO emails whatsoever? Before my suspension AND after my reinstatement? No... no y'all didn't.
Oh no! You're gonna actually have to go through the process of moderating your platform?!
Thank you. Safety First.
Thank you! You’re doing the right thing!
Where's the email? My friend's still waiting.
👏👏👏👏👏👏💙
respectfully, being reinstated with a "FINAL WARNING" for doing something i did not do (or at least have no knowledge of doing, i cannot monitor every single account i have interacted with) is not properly fixing any false positive. if you were serious here, you'd reverse the warnings as well.
Punishing people for interacting with accounts is also terrible site design when the site is supposed to thrive on users interacting with each other. Tumblr didn't learn this lesson, but I'm hoping Bluesky will. Also get some damn human moderators, this AI moderation shit is so tiring everywhere.
I've been told the moderation team is 20 people and the site has 20 million accounts now.
Source?
You are doing a great job. We appreciate you!
Well, this is a blatant lie on your part. None of the users I know who were affected by your mass ban were notified either before or after you suspended them. Nobody received any email.
Good to know there’s a 🦋 crew to help keep us safe from toxicity. 💙
this is absolutely unacceptable and i hope it won't happen again
Can those of us who got emails containing some pretty intense allegations at least get an email apologizing? It might seem like just getting our accounts back is plenty, but when you are part of a marginalized group that is falsely accused of that as a political statement, it can be pretty traumatic
When I—as a trans person—get falsely accused of child sexual abuse, it comes across as more than, “This person made some incorrect assumptions about me.” It instead comes across as, “These people are giving excuses to remove me from public life, deny me human rights, and criminalize my existence.”
I also want to point out that several points in this are false: 1. None of us received emails. We had to coordinate to figure out what was happening. 2. When we emailed for clarifaction, we were accused of federal felonies we did not commit. 3. [next post]
3. According to the head of Trust & Safety, this was not automated. He decided a screenshot from a mainstream anime called Miss Kobayashi’s Dragon Maids was too sexual and conflated that with CSAM. He told this to press: www.platformer.news/bluesky-grow... Trust & Safety is lying a lot right now.
What an infuriating article. Cartoons are definitionally NOT CSAM. CSAM *depicts actual CSA*. That's literally the definition.
The term lasted about a week before being misused into the ground like it's predecessor.
Is that guy still on the mod team?
He is the head of moderation still, yes
Now I'm regretting rejoining.
Aaron Rodericks would fucking piss himself if he saw Popotan (the thing that the Carameldansen Meme is based on) and THAT'S ON FUCKING YOUTUBE.... Youtube is the most repressive, most censored fucking video website on the net, and it has an intro from an ecchi game. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iv_d...
yes apologies are absolutely necessary for this travesty of an action they've taken. i'm figuring lawyers won't let them at this point, considering it's already very clearly (imo i'm no lawyer not legal advice) defamation per se, and i think arguably intentional infliction of pain and suffering.
You have a good point. So many regular people getting accused of such heavy crime is pretty bad
The Bsky Mod Staff are just as goofy as every single one of those people who made "callout / blocklists" and made up bullshit out of thin air about people with ZERO tangible factual evidence to back up the claims.... if you're gunna say HORRENDOUS stuff about people, at least BACK UP THE CLAIMS....
I can create a new block list / callout list and say "everybody in this list is a cannibal" but saying it WITHOUT EVIDENCE TO BACK UP THE CLAIMS does not make it TRUE..... does it?
Of course not, because CLAIMS REQUIRE PROOF.... otherwise it's just "making shit up."
actually here is a neat idea, perhaps update your guidelines from time to time because this is seriously old
I'll be honest, this sounds like you guys are pedos and are shitting yourselves to blame queers.
You associated with Jack, and that guy went to pedo island several times.
Don't envy anyone working that gig, hope you folks are looking after them
Thank you for striving to keep us safe, and on an even keel.
Do you have any comment on claims that users who reinstated were told they had a "final warning" and would not be able to appeal if they ever get hit again? i.e. that there was no acknowledgement that the decisions were wrong, just a reduction in punishment
I was affected by this, and did not receive any email communication about the appeal process. I reached out to the support email on your website and got no reply, had to find a different email on reddit. My account was restored very promptly after that, but it was a lot of hoops to jump through
What would that email be that you found? curious because a friend is currently in this same situation
It's "moderation@blueskyweb.xyz" Best of luck to your friend!
Thanks for that.
it worked! thank you again :)
Glad to hear it! Hope your friend has a smooth time going forward
i think you should probably be made aware that libel is a crime. you are literally doing crime for all to see. if you apologize, ACTUALLY apologize, maybe none of your victims litigate. even if they do, you will have done the bare minimum morally. unless bluesky is a criminal enterprise now?
This. There is ALREADY some billionaires and their fuckbuddies hawking to try and find any angle to sue the shit out of Bluesky. THIS, is not a good image as it gives Elon and his cronies a lot of ammo to throw at the site.
Bsky hates lewd cartoon drawings -- they think cartoon drawings are the same thing as CSEM, lol lol lol.... This website is a fuckin' JOKE....
Liars.
fucking liar
Good social media is the product of good moderation. Please don't skimp on human mods.
I couldn’t agree more.
4/ We’re expanding our moderation team as we grow to improve both the timeliness and accuracy of our moderation actions. Thank you for your understanding and your feedback.
Thank you. I appreciate this platform & its caring about safety & moderation.
I'll moderate for you. Hit me up!
Thank you Bluesky!
Very glad you're seeking to ban bigotry and harm. Please continue your vigilance, most especially when it targets the already-vulnerable and those who seek to support them. Consistent collective action to reduce harm/violence/bigotry is very much needed.
Please make it so we can get unwanted peeps to “unfollow” us. When we block it skews our followers numbers, because they’re still counted as followers by YOU. Would like to be able to block them then unblock, and unhook them from following me and being counted in my numbers. Thx
And here I thought blocking someone forced an unfolllow! Damnit.
No it just blocks them. They can’t see you, you can’t see them. But if you unblock them, they’re still there following you. It’s creepy. Not to mention it effs up your Followers total. It’s way overinflated by the unwanted who followed you even though you blocked them.That irks me and my OCD lol
When you block they're still following you? I did not know. That sucks. I would like an option "remove this follower". Some accts aren't porn or maga just something you'd rather not have around. Remove follower is a gentle block. Then if they persist, Block. Except magats. Block on sight!
Over on the other site, the trick to getting them to “unfollow you”, was to block and then unblock and poof they were no longer following you. Doesn’t work here. Some creep who never tweets follows you. You block him. If you unblock he’s still following you. I don’t like that.
Technically they aren’t following you. They can’t see you and you can’t see them. But they are counted in your followers total. I prefer to shake them loose so the numbers are accurate.
Yesyesyesyesyesssssss this!
Let me know if you need an excellent paralegal/moderator to add to your expanding team!!
Thank you so much!
Thanks for looking out for EVERYONE!
Thank you for policing the toxicity and making this such a pleasant community forum. It’s refreshing
Yes!!!
It’s nice to have a place to interact with friendly people and not deal with hateful trolls!
Agreed!
Thank you. So far I have ran into very few problems on my feed. You guys and this entire community are doing fantastic
Yall are the absolute best. Thank you all for all the hard work you do.
Thank YOU!
Thanks blue sky so much better then twitter!
✅️ ✅️
Be Safe
👏👏👏👏
Agree with your interim moderation rules. The important thing is to preserve the network from excesses incompatible with a calm discussion.
Thank you for taking this seriously.
The trolls are coming here in droves because Jack Smith dropped the charges. They can't stand that they can't troll and harass people like the sadists that they are. They are sick, sick people and they voted to destroy democracy just for kicks.
Exactly. They won, but just like the cookie cutter narcissists they are, they are here looking for supply to project their invalidations onto, and without that supply, they literally start imploding. The two things narcissists hate most are: -transparency -your personal agency
There's a psychologist on here that says they actually get a dopamine high from trolling. But I like your theory about projection too.
Yes you are correct. The dopamine release comes from the reward. With narcissism, the reward comes in validation. In order to achieve this, they must invalidate their supply. If you've ever been engaged in an extensive meme war with a single actor you will notice it is similar to a crackhead
That's so interesting, thanks.
🙏🏼💜
Who is constantly chasing the next hit. The more they perceive to be winning the psychological competition between them and their supply, the greater the dopamine. Therefore when engaging them, you must be focused on two things: 1) manipulating their dopamine hits to your own strategic advantage
2) a narrative trap which is set early on, then eventually manipulating them into a position where you can correlate their behavior into validating The narrative trap.
What is an example of a narrative trap?
So I have my own way of going about this, I don't get angry, I actually enjoy challenge, it's like a game for me, and trolls are basically free toys I can break with zero consequence in the process of sharpening my engagement skills. Narrative traps are based in character development.
Yup, I’ve noticed that too.
Agreed.
📌
Transparency is so very refreshing.
Thank you.
Great! keep it up!
I am curious how you are handling moderation. I have some experience from reddit.
Go to Settings>Moderation. Every user has moderation tools available to them. Check out @skywatch.blue or look at trusted profiles. Many people have moderation lists you can subscribe to under the Lists tab on their profile. I maintain one myself.
Weird that these accounts are complaining about the safety protocols.
There's a lot of unanswered questions here yet. They really should be answering them.
How does one get hired to be on your modification team?
Excellent thank you. Reporting rampant violations on X (for example Stew Peters who spread vaccination lies about the parents of deceased children which triggered death threats) was often an exercise in futility. I look forward to robust moderation.
You guys hiring?
bsky.app/profile/jay....
We’d work for free. Would love to collaborate and our company has collective experience annotating social media content.
You guys are doing a fabulous job. Thank you for keeping this platform respectful.
Thank you for moderating.
Sadly lots of dumb kids (“Antis”) report ART/fiction w false reports that don’t actually involve real people at all Also many Conservatives also do the exact same thing just to “own the libs” -especially directed towards POC/LGBTQIA+/women/etc
Where do I apply?
Oh, good. Thank you.
Good to know you have our back.
Ill be a mod fine
Without algorithmic tools and the participation of the community, I think you will build the old Twitter which was not really just and efficient. Be careful, perhaps X is evil, but Twitter was not hell !
If you need any moderation team members give me some contact info. I've worked for on social media platforms for years as HR/PR for other folk, got a certification in it, happy to help monitor things.
Are you hiring?
Do keep in mind that their mods have to see some *sick* shit. Either go in already hardened, or be ready for a lot of therapy
They do have some internal tools to reduce what their employees have to see - they mentioned this previously, and it's nice to hear.
I've been on every social media platform since their inception. Except Tiktok. But you have an excellent point there. The animal torture stuff especially gives me nightmares. (Been fortunate enough to not see child things, don't know how I'd react besides white-hot rage)
You either learn to block it off (and it helps that the software places use now includes filters that blur the images slightly so you don't have to see every detail pixel perfect: even a 5% blur has major differences in intrusive flashbacks later) or you have a nervous breakdown.
Yeah. I've been deeply depressed before and I bet even my emotions being completely dead would not stop the revulsion
Sometimes both! Sometimes both in the same week.
With what money? All the advertisements we see?
Lol
Are you hiring former Twitter employees? They were awesome at censoring harmful and hateful content. I suggest calling the FBI for employees also. They knew all about what misinformation was coming down the pike.
Are there folks with experience at the NCMEC? Those people would be great.
Yeah, are you hiring?
bsky.app/profile/jay....
OH HEY speaking of...: bsky.app/profile/case...
Musk & donnie will direct MAGA to invade and try and destroy our platform. (Our as in I really appreciate the discussions being civil.)
It's like this Bizarro Twitter, when the CEO knows that the platform's appeal is mods, they hire more mods as the platform grows.
Certainly coincidental timing, after I shared my first experiences with "moderation" on BlueSky earlier today. bsky.app/profile/pret...
The most you can do right now is block, report, and alert your followers if necessary. Hopefully Bluesky will do its part to stop repeat offenders through bans and maybe blanket permanent bans, if the source is significant enough.
This. Always block as well as report - report to save other people down the line, but block to save yourself right now.
Most trolls get bored and move on to something or someone else, but the serial harassers need to be dealt with by moderators, ultimately.
Oh, absolutely - you need to deal with the "moving on to someone else part" with moderation. But you can get them off *your* back with a block. Sockpuppets notwithstanding, and that's a headache for moderation as well.
I always mute and block the account after reporting. Not sure what muting does, but it's an option, so I click it. Maybe it hides their comments until you click on it?
I'm not sure of the precise details, but it hides their posts from you, and doesn't hide you from them.
Sometimes we need to stick up for ourselves and not wait for someone to stick up for us. ( not trying to be mean and if you take it that way , its on you) Americans NEED to grow a backbone , i for one and tired of being "strong" all alone.
I also had someone attack me , but it was for my use of pronouns , which i dont use. I got attacked because i refused to be put in a box. I also use the block feature rather than allow that person to steal my sunshine. You also have this ability.
A lot of bitter people have recently joined here, with their sole goal being to annoy people. But this site has a tradition of blocking such losers right away and depriving them of air. I hope you find it a welcoming place, overall!
What I've noticed is, there doesn't seem to be a full fledged usage of the custom feed algorithm yet. Idea: Create AI agents that sit on top of your feed, and creates custom feed algo for you, specially. This will take load off the bsky moderation team. Would you be interested?
I'm so sorry you had to deal with this loser 😢 He's jealous because you live your authentic life, and are fabulous while doing so ❤️
Wow I didn't expect this amount of response. I'm honestly overwhelmed, as I've never had this happen before. Thank you to everyone for the kindness and understanding. I feel much better now knowing there are so many good people on this platform looking out for each other! ❤️
On Saturday, I was attacked by trolls who shidted over many posts. I hit the three dots, then clicked "Hide Reply for me," one by one. In the worst dump of each, I copied and reported. Every shidty post was gone, then I blocked them all. 2 days later, they no longer had an account. It can happen.
Let us know who they are so we can block them. There are so many good people here... unfortunately the bad ones tend to be much louder. You be you, honey. You matter.
I feel a lot better overall. Seeing how the community has come together and responded to this situation has far outweighed anything that BlueSky could have done. Thank you!
You are safe with me. I am so sorry these horrible people exist. Stay safe.
I'm so sorry you had to deal with this.
I'm sorry that you have to deal with this. It isn't okay and it needs to be handled CORRECTLY by Blue Sky!
That is horrible! I send you healing and peace. ❤️🩹✨
I hope they're able to sort this out, a strong message has been sent that their type aren't welcome (they've been complaining about it enough over on The Bad Place), so hopefully it's a matter of catching up!
Unlike Twitter, we can block people here
I am very sorry you had to deal with this. And thank you for standing up and making it public.
If the thread is still up, ping blocklist creators and let them know they have a bunch of accounts to add. At least community action can help mitigate future problems. That said, blocklists are still in their infancy and community coordination is slow still. Power will build, slowly. #blocklist
You need to post their handle so others can block Just a suggestion It works
Are you a moderator? Sorry you had to deal with this.
Likewise. No place and nobody needs that sort of harrassment.
Yes,sir, we came here to leave hate behind. Nothing cute about cowards that try to disguise themselves as bullies. We SEE YOU
I just block them
Sorry, you have been put through this. Bluesky has been a very pleasant place to be but I guess the hate mongers over at Twitter / X are short of targets since people have been leaving and are coming over here. Screenshot and share any hate and people can help by mass reporting hateful accounts.
But they're making an effort to resolve the problem. That's much more than other platforms are doing.
I found this place that lets you review a Bsky user block history and activity clearsky.app/caroline-bla... I simply block those that spread disinformation or use gratuitous insults. There are also curated lists that let you block users. No one should be bullied anywhere. Meantime we block.
Yes, Gretchen. It's all about you.
Hopefully this will improve.
I have found you can block words as well useful for blocking the common filler spam I seen on twitter here maybe it can help silence those types of messages
It's not perfect. I blocked the word "libtard" in particular and still saw a few posts using that word (in the text, which it says it blocks), so something isn't working.
Hmm will keep an eye out for my block words so far it's worked for anything pretending to be someone posting WhatsApp or telegram references and gofund like pages from people I don't follow
So sorry you have to deal with this. Are you ok?
I feel like if we ignore them and don’t engage, they will get bored and leave on their own or maybe I’m naive. I was never on X.
Can you share the link so we can all report and block?
At least you could block the ignorant pos."There is that.
Sorry this is happening to you. The blocking feature is a great start, but I hope that the moderation team can implement more robust ways for dealing with trolls and harassment so that you don't have to deal with this. Stay strong and shine on. 🌈✨
I did the same thing... a total meltdown, but here I am anyway. It's nice to know they're actually paying attention.
I’m so sorry this happened to you.
This is awful. People can be such assholes. I’m sending you a hug and I’ll do whatever I can to squash these lowlife jerks.
Well be my friend instead, I got your back ❤️
Really sorry you went through this. No words really. Xxxx
Is it down now? If not, I want to block them.
They’d rather go after “problematic” art than protect actual people, it seems.
I'm sorry that happened to you. Thank you for being here.
Sending you love.
Expecting perfection, especially with a fast growing app adding a million subs a day, is unrealistic. I am sorry this happened to you, but please give the developers some time to improve.
What is unrealistic is a company not taking user safety as a top priority, and instead constantly posting about how many new users they have and all the cool new features they've developing. That is not a company overwhelmed. That's a company that lacks direction and responsibility.
Well, you can vote with your feet if you aren't happy with how they are progressing. Some things take time. They are scrambling to get more servers to support the massive influx of users. Do you work in IT? I do, and changes can't be implemented on the turn of a dime.
Their moderation team is not the same as their IT team (or at least I certainly hope it isn't).
It looks like they are dramatically expanding their moderation team which is great news 👍
I'm sorry you had to deal with this, nobody should, but please don't blame Bluesky; They're experiencing unprecedented growth and while the Xodus is mostly good people, some trolls are here just to take up this space too. Report them, block them, and know the vast majority here support you. x
I’m sorry that happened to you. I think the Blue Sky community finds such behavior abhorrent. The Safety team seems to be peddling as fast as they can; I hope that never happens to you again but if it does, know that millions here support you. Ignore the trolls.
Can't you block this person? I blocked Elon Musk yesterday 😉
Let also make sure we root out propaganda and false stories. Let us run this place with some integrity. Please and thank you. I'm not a moderator, but I would be happy to become one!
That's awful, I'm sorry you had to deal with it. Hope Bsky's moderation efforts scale up quickly.
Trolls really are like a disease—persistent, annoying, and nearly impossible to get rid of. I wish Bluesky luck.
The irony of the person who replied to you mentioning mental disorders when they’re on here trolling and being offensive in their free time lol. I can’t.
People like that feed off reactions, so the best approach is to ignore them completely.
they are.
Only have Feed Algo Engineer and Community Marketing listed at this time. I'll keep an eye out tho.
You could try sending an open application if they have a recruitment email account listed somewhere? High chances of getting a "thanks but no thanks" reply (if you even get a reply), but it can't hurt to try.
I wouldn’t mind reviewing for pay and removing, since I do a lot in reporting and blocking… WFH 👩💻 is good! 😊
One of the work projects I've been involved in was a social network thingamajig, and I gathered from my coworkers that being a moderator can be pretty taxing psychologically; you run into all kinds of horrors that most regular users never see. Like really heinous stuff
Yes, I’d read things were pretty horrific on Twitter already years ago before it devolved into what it is now. Severe PTSD for sure☹️
Ahhh that makes sense…
for real
Wondered that same question.
I'll gladly take on a role and spend more time than is humanly safe to ensure this does not become a cesspool.
Wondering the same. Because if so sign me up lol
bsky.social/about/join
That's what I wanted to know. I would love a job like that.
Pick me! Pick me!
Let’s hope so. I have officially been a target of blackmail on this app yet the person doing the blackmail has an account still. Sent in the post, and all the blackmail messages yet they are still here. I will most likely be leaving since they either won’t or can’t protect me and my family.
Listen, it’s all good. I’m just happy to be here. I’m sure most reasonable people understand. Thank you for giving us this lovely space.
Ditto
Thank you. So far I've experienced no issues finding quick action which is very appreciated.
I'm interested in joining your moderation team. Who can I speak with?
Thank you for your transparency.
I would be happy to wreck fools many hours a day for trivial amounts of cash weekly. I live in the Aspen area. I would do it from here. I am not about to move :)
If you hire for this moderation team, let us know.
Great job! Let me know if I can help ...
If u need stay at home moderators let me know!
Thank you for being 1000 times better than Twitter. 💙
*better than X. The only way I have seen, so far, that it's better than the original Twitter is the 300 character limit instead of the SMS-limited 140 characters (+ 20 more reserved for addressing). It went downhill fast after mElonhead bought it.
It’s Twitter to me. Elmo doesn’t deserve the respect of calling it X.
Please don't call him Elmo. Elmo is adorable and loves everyone. Also he and his friends need to be rescued from the Bad Place.
Absolutely right. This whole calling him Elmo is just defaming the actual Elmo. Honestly I’m not really on board with using anything but a persons name - it smacks of childishness and the playground, no matter how awful a person is.
Trump calls people names. It’s not a good sign.
I've called elon musk mElonhead since before he bought twitter and wrecked it; he proved he was cray before that. I also believe the US government should nationalize SpaceX and put NASA in charge of it, since we have paid for its creation with billion$ in taxpayer-funded subsidies and launch fees.
Agree, Starlink is part of our national security apparatus and this dangerously unhinged pro-Putin man should not have control of it. Ironically, he'd probably entertain a large sum buyout from Trump rather than Biden or Harris so he could stick it to the libs.
yes
Bless your hearts you are alone out there doing good work, important work. Please know how deeply this is appreciated & please give yourselves the grace of self care.
I love this site, and thanks for the heads up 🙌
Thank you
Hi! If you're hiring moderators, I would like to know where to apply. I have around 10 years experience as a forum mod.
Gizza job. I could do that.
Please be sure to vet new members of the moderation team thoroughly. There is evidence that it's already being infiltrated by puritans who spread extremist ideas about fictional content, and banning people on the basis of their own misguided personal opinions.
Specifically they claim that a single artwork or story can be dangerous because it "normalizes" or "promotes" harmful behaviors, which goes against all existing science on the subject. Letting this continue would make Bluesky an incredibly unsafe place to be for any artist or writer.
This is, incidentally, the same logic that would ban video games for supposedly causing real life violence and would ban queer content for supposedly turning kids gay. A strange (and dangerous) tack to take for a place that aims to support all kinds of artists.
If the people of the moderating team wish to know more, here is a good collection of information and further resources. bsky.app/profile/sama...
What sort of art are you most concerned about? Which of these would you object to being censored: 1. Partial nudity, adults 2. Full nudity pornographic 3. Childlike cartoon porn 4. Bestiality art 5. Fetish, dungeon 6. Torture porn
Grateful for everything y'all do to keep this platform safe & rightwing troll-free.
Good luck
How do you apply to be a content moderator? I know a really tech savvy librarian who would be perfect.
I'd rather you all be overly cautious than to let this devolve into a dangerous free for all. That's why I'm here. Thank you.
💯
Just reported a Porn site & blocked it
AHAHAHA my dude, nsfw keeps places like this alive. Adjust your settings to block it because it's not going away. Banning adult stuff = bye bye website. Tumblr learned the hard way. Safe browsing, friend!
If people are flogging their site in their own posts, fine. If they're spamming replies in un-related threads, they're getting plonked.
You're going to get porn here. Go to your settings and turn that option off. It will rarely sneak up on you then. Happy posting!
You can turn porn off in your settings :) you don't need to make false reports, that's actually *checks notes...* a bad thing!
Thank you! Doing a great job!
Hi you all! Thanks for your altruism and trying. I guess what you missed was that human beings are Monsters and the only way to get rid of them is, well you know. And they just procreate. There is NO SAFE GOOD PLACE!
Thank you, thank you, thank you!!! Love you guys. 💙
Thank you for your hard work 😁
I'm reasonably fluent in identifying propaganda, gaslighting, narrative building and enforcement, social engineering, manipulation tactics, elicitation and persuasion. That being said, I just want to help others identify it as well. This is the 25 rules of disinfo: tinyurl.com/25rulesdisinfo
Thanks for your ongoing work to make Bluesky a decent environment.
Again...thank you!
My account was flagged and blocked. I have no idea why. I did not receive an email in relation to it. Are you able to assist?
Thank you for being honest and forthright.
Is moderation a paid job or a pro bono thing? 🤔
You are all awesome!
A lot of accounts impersonating and nothing being done
I've seen several that have been reported and gone. The mod team is expanding to make it possible to respond more quickly.
Thank you.
Thank you
Thank you for your excellent platform, and caring about this.
I’m just thrilled you have a moderation team! Obviously you have growing pains and those will get worked out.
Thank you for being so transparent. We all expect growing pains.
Getting a lot of new followers who seem to be all bots
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
This team should get hazard pay.
i can’t even imagine and i truly do not want to
I agree. It is no joke. A friend of mine worked at FB viewing some of the worst stuff ever. He spared me the details but the people keeping us safe are way under paid.
Yup, I have noticed the toxic accounts from the Hell Site trying to do the same here. My block list is growing fast.
'the Hell Site' 😆
They noticed that there weren't a lot of people to bully anymore and have begun to cause trouble here, especially trying to undermine the functionality of the block button so that you'd have to give all attention to the narcissists flocking here.
Yes, it's a bit wearing to have to attend to them again. But the facility of block lists to weed the buggers out in one go is great.
That's why Bluesky has the nuclear blocklists! Try subscribing to the ones at @skysentry.bsky.social
Real talk. Secondary trauma takes its toll.
I worked at Meta in integrity for 4 years, including some time in child safety. Real talk - still dealing with the mental aftermath through therapy.
Thanks for doing that important work.
Yikes. I’m sorry.
My niece married a formerTOS for aol. He monitored chat rooms. It surely took its toll. Thankfully he ended up getting out. The mentally deranged sure can effect others mental health. Hmmm
The people I REALLY feel for are the moderators as they have to see that stuff day in day out. I worked on detection, prevention, enforcement and tooling, so could somewhat limit exposure … but there was still exposure. Hope your nieces’ husband is doing OK now!
Thank you, yes. A change of profession helped quite a bit.
Indeed it does. I remember reading an article done regarding YouTube's and Amazon's safety folks. Pretty gruesome stuff!
I wrote a book about it.
(All I can hear in my head is David Allen Grier, “Wrote a song about it…here it go.” #old)
It's out of stock on Amazon
Looks like they have 14 left…
Sarah, can you please post a link?
Does this work? a.co/d/dK5jkmh
Unfortunately not. I'm regionally locked because I'm in Australia. I'll try and get my wife to work it out. On Australian Amazon, it says it's temporarily out of stock
it's a great book and tells you a lot about how this work actually happens, the hazards and long term effects, and who should ultimately be responsible it's one of the few must-read books i never shut up about
Name of the book?
"Behind the Screen: Content Moderation in the Shadows of Social Media by @ubiquity75.bsky.social. It's available via Yale books: yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300...
📌
📌
it's the ✨ trust and safety complex PTSD club ✨
Years ago I read a newspaper article about FB moderation and am still traumatied by it. Cannot imagine what this is like.
There was an item about this on Radio4 last week. Moderators suffering trauma from the terrible content they viewed as part of the job.
I can only image, having worked with child victims of some of these sick heinous monsters.
Just from what I’ve seen in the blocking mines, I’d agree
Agreed I can only image the filth that comes through.
I was a moderator for years and years (not here) and from time to time, hazard pay would have been appreciated. There are some sick people out there.
Do this right and don't repeat the mistakes of social media platforms past: make your content reviewers full time employees.
so.. you need to go through and instead of an appeals process thing you really need to check every sweeping ban and unban people yourselves. you make a mistake, you clean it up
Thank you!
I think I speak for many when I say that I just deeply appreciate someone working hard to get it right, as opposed to someone so casually delighting in getting it all wrong.
Make it easy. Just have a network engineer write some code that automatically blocks any profile with maga, trump, or 🇺🇸 patriot in their profile. Half of them are bots and the other half are the reason advertisers fled the dead bird app.
Thank you for moderating safety!! 👏🏻👏🏻
Good! It’s necessary. Let’s be very clear on to what’s acceptable and what’s not. I have felt the need to block more accounts than I hoped to.
Awesome pivot! Such a difference from Elon’s toxic pool.
Bravo!
Thank you so much 🙏🏼
Thank you. It’s appreciated.
💝 thank you for all you do for us!
Thanks for the good work 👍😉
Jesse Singal has a documented habit of leading harassment against Trans accounts. I don’t think you should wait until people get harassed off your platform to consider banning him. That puts his access as a priority over *multiple* users
Thank you for building our new home!
Thank YOU!
Any way we can help? Whether it be a hired position or community assistance? I want to help fight to keep this place the way that it is.
Just wondering how long it takes to remove Nazi posts and accounts. I mean the ones that reference ovens and such? Do I have to report for 5 days? A week?
Are you hiring , please send the link.
Damn, does this mean the Sally Mann images I had hoped to post over the next few months will mean I get banned?
You Do a phenomenal job. Looking forward to drafts wave?—, maybe 2m20s videos, and grace periods to go in to fix typos. I won’t mind paying. Twitter original used to do it for four dollars. Even though $11 for ex was quite a hike - I needed it, but I know he was starting at $11 without reason. We🩵U❣️
Thank you!
I understand. Thank you for being careful.❤️Sharyn in Texas (it's tragic here)
Thank you
You should have all your content moderators read The Body Keeps the Score by Bessel van der Kolk. Sincerely, some dude on the internet
Thank you. 👋🏼🖐🏼👋🏼🦋🫶🏼🦋
Much appreciated
#SpamAlert to help combat real spam
Thank you.
Thank you!
Please continue to err on the side of safety.
Thank you.
💕💕💕
💕💞💓💗
Appreciated
Sadly with Bluesky's growth and popularity you will have many only here with bad intentions. If you're hiring moderators, I'd be happy to apply
Thank you 😊🫶
When we report a profile or post, are we going to see any response from ‘you’?
They were working on improvements to the tools so people get updates on the outcomes of their reports about when the entire internet arrived and everything had to quickly switch over to emergency triage mode. I'd probably expect late January/early February.
That’s a feature I’d like to see so I don’t have to keep checking my Unwanted Creatures list to see if certain users are gone.
Thank you for your vigilance and action.
Thank you for your transparency. It’s very refreshing!
You do good work. Thank you!
Thank you!
I send positive vibes to the Bluesky team! I hope you can handle this! 🙌
Thank You Bluesky. This platform has been like a breath of fresh air. Thank you for your transparency and your oversight. 🦋
Appreciate you
Big culprits are the "I won the lottery" scammers, like the many multiple accounts of "Mavis Wanczyk"
Oh, so she didn't win the Powerball and isn't giving away money to random strangers. Who would have guessed it? Ha ha ha.
But, hey, did you know the Facebook Lottery is "Real and Legit?" "Sheryl Sandberg " @sheryl33.bsky.social says so!
Haha Neither is all her split personalities 😃
During the long long ago in the bad place, I once posed the questions of how many Powerball winners are there? and why did they all want to be friends with?
How many new multimillionaires replied? Ha ha ha
None, but I did get like three " brand new" followers right after it. So I had that going for me which is nice
I've already had to block several of those accounts! They keep trying to follow me and I keep having to block them.
Oh no, ma'am! MAGA has infested here lately, but bad! Luckily, we're very quick on the block button.
In Twitters early days there were 2 A/c 2 folo TwitSpam & TwitspamOrg user maintained. Initially 2 stop advert spamming but later in Green colour revolution in Iran; unmasking malicious Iranian secret service accounts spamming viral links. Trusted users like wikipedia could shoulder some of the load
Thank you for clarifying, heard today that this was happening and it got me worried. Best to everyone out there and on your team.
Hey, y'all are doing great. I do think though this would be a fine time for you to look into getting some UX Researchers to map the design of how reporting and consequences are performed by the user and offender. Do not design on a best guess.
What Joel said!
Thank you for everything you are doing to keep this a safe place. 😊
Many thanks for the honesty. 👍🏻
Transparency, a welcome change from my X
Word.
Absolutely!
A big thanks to the Bluesky team! You're offering everyone here a fresh start after Twitter and keeping it clean and welcoming. Cheers to the recent growth of the community and your proven efforts!
In a war there is friendly fire o7
Thank you for all your hard work 💕💕
Thanks for taking action w transparency.
this doesn't really fit with the emails sent earlier. are users with accepted appeals still on their last strike? are you reserving the option to ban based on liked accounts going forward? you've made an apology but not any promises to avoid the concerns that made it necessary in the first place
Thank you!
thank you!! 💙
Thank you! 💙
Please help with some kind of verification on the imposter accounts.
Thank you for this energy. I kind of...love you for it?
If there is a way to help automate better reviews on hate speech, like phrases we could use that would allow faster sorting for review, I would love to know some. I try to leave keywords in the report box, but some people make a lot of awful/trolly comments.
Getting some feedback and follow-up mail regarding our reports would be welcome. Hopefully not from an automated system like Twitter.
It would have to be automated otherwise you're doubling the workload of the people.
There’s an extension that folks have written to filter out hate. Search for it. I found one for MAGA and one for hate and bigotry. There’s also a feature in settings about filters and moderation that is quite extensive. I stumbled on one today. They instantly blocked me. 🙌
Labels and mute lists aren't what I'm talking about. I'm talking about when I report someone, I want to make it easier for the team to review so that bad actors and trolls can get suspended or labeled with "intolerance" faster, because I have "intolerance" posts set to "hide."
We’ll try and do our part too. We appreciate you more than you know.
Thanks
And thank YOU for working so hard to keep it a healthy and safe place for us.
Thank you 🙏🏻
Thank you!
Scaling up is fraught. 💙🐞🤞🍀
Bravo! Well done!
Take in consideration the only good future X has… “community notes”, it could help the moderation process and stop 🛑 the misinformation 😅😅😅😅
Thank you!!!!!
And thank YOU for your phenomenal work.
Thank you. We need to keep evil out.
I trust your judgment and hope you throttle the freaks.
This is the way 👏🏻 we trust you because we know your intention is to make the platform better, not destroy it (like the other app). Bluesky is awesome 🦋
Thank you
Are you going after those fake lottery winner posts about giving money away?
I bet there are some X employees who'd love to get out of there
Perfect messaging for your first major post-growth hiccup. I hope it all goes well.
hmu if you need a volunteer! always looking to expand my resume :)
Operation: Clarification. Surely "anyone who clicks Like on a post by someone who is then banned for serious TOS violations is themselves banned" can not be the actual policy your site is pursuing? Your individual users are not responsible for the actions of others.
Furthermore, your team has not commented on the issue of un-banning @lunabuna.sisters.moe, who also did not violate the TOS as written. What course of action should she take to restore her account?
Y'all are doing the most rn and I appreciate your work. Please accept this cat as a token of my appreciation
Can you get to the. Nazis next?
Thank U 4 concern of the safety of the users of this platform. However, I request u make an available all gif from Jan 6 there’s a tiny selection which shows u don’t want it highlighted, but some of us Americans will never forget that day, especially when we still hear the 👮 screams in dreams
Thanks Bluesky. It's nice to be somewhere on social media where ppl care about safety. 💙
Thank you
We appreciate that there actually is a team.
Thank you 💓
Just a thought, but stackoverflow has shown a community made effort can work for moderation. I'm not talking about giving anyone power, but the flagging system with a high enough bar (10, maybe 100 flags) may help hiding problematic content as long as 'just created' accounts can not flag.
+100
Thanks so much for moderating. It’s important.
@mikeo-g.bsky.social fyi 🤗😘
🥰😘
😘🤗
Thank you for having content moderation.
Thank . Thank you for taking us seriously. Thank you for building us a refuge. We will repay you with loyalty, with the best of content we have to give, and with gratitude. You have built it. They are coming.
Thank you very much
This is better than Twitter. Obviously I do not condone anything that people uploads here but you gotta know something about fictional things. It just doesn't hurt anyone unless it's a different thing...
Lots of opportunities in the replies here for The List. bsky.app/profile/did:...
📌
Between @skywatch.blue and my own list, this thread has been entirely free of trolls.
Much appreciated; both your action and your explanation.
are you hiring?
I warn people to watch out for the sex-bots/trolls here, some of whom are in lists to follow. Had to block 3 already, one who asked for money. I reported that one.
Thank you for caring enough to work hard on the balancing act!
Thank you!
THANK YOU!
I would absolutely apply if you were hiring.
I worked at AOL on their Community Action Team, which moderated children’s chat rooms and reviewed every post that was reported, upwards of 100k per day. They used automated processing software that I wrote/maintained. It was a very challenging job. You’re doing great!!
The man is brigading 2 cause harrasment of blusky user allowing account like this will cause people 2 move elsewhere abd find a platform that does not allow abuser 2 thrive this is the main reason why ppl left twitter if ur gonna do this then expect ur growth 2 dwindle and lose relevancy
Does this mean you're gonna stop banning Palestinians? (I asked, knowing the answer is "no")
The Community Guidelines is here: bsky.social/about/suppor...
Basically F around and find out. 😂
nobody f'd around and found out. the absurd amount of false bans are being undone. it was a huge misstep by the team to cast such a wide net and slash out anyone who posted or liked anything kinky in the time they have been here.
just monitor hashtags that people are using to engage in illicit activity on your platform with images blurred. i reported a bunch of them a few days ago after i got a suspicious follow and checked who they followed and i was mortified. your lazy solution should not be our final warning.
The problem is that the actual illegal content usually uses tags of not illegal content, often mixing with generic porn tags. Meanwhile frequently those who use "problematic" hashtags, know that they are posting nothing illicit/illegal. This is unfortunately a job that requires in person checking.
TL;DR: Dog whistles. They get used frequently by people sharing illegal content.
nor should i need to be exposed to this shit on your platform from merely vetting my followers. i don't have this issue anywhere else.
if you know you over-enforced it, why are you just sending "final warnings" instead of bans and requiring appeals? why aren't you proactively reviewing *all* the actions taken, *fully* restoring accounts that didn't violate the rules (with no mark in their "permanent record"), and *apologizing*?
(to clarify, by "just sending 'final warnings' instead of bans", I meant "walking bans back only to 'final warnings'", as opposed to 'striking them from the record' entirely.)
i concur with julie @safety.bsky.app you fucked up, and way to fix fuckups is to actually fix the things you fucked up. go through, look at all the inciting incidents, and clear the fuckin' names of the people who didn't do anything wrong.
they shouldn't be on a knife's edge because you got over punchy with the accusations. LARGELY AGAINST QUEER PEOPLE. it's now your responsibility to sort through everything that got folks banned and remove it from their account.
imagine if you'd been accused of this! okay, now imagine what it does to queer folks who deal with these accusations day in and day out. you owe a responsibility to the community that built this place to FIX YOUR SHIT. not a little fixed. all the way. this is just heart wrenching to me.
what's the numbers? how many hundreds/thousands/tens of thousands of people did you stop just shy of screaming "you fucking p*do!!" to? and i'm sure that's how it felt to the folks who received them. betrayed once again bc it was more important to project an image than to take care of the problem.
i'm just so done for tonight. i'm disappointed in the people running this platform, yet again. and my new followers, yet again. and in all my threads to the world, yet ag-- nah jk those are pretty awesome. i think i said things pretty okay-ly. night y'all.
I literally had one (1) post and got banned without any warning. The rest were reposts of artists or content creators. That's all it took.
that sucks Ángel and i know if it were me i'd have like a sick feeling in the pit of my stomach and i'd be worried about it i totally get that it's not just like some minor little thing.
the way this is just a blatant lie is so funny i do not envy you guys 😭😭
you are lying to everyone here i got no notice until i appealed, and then when i appealed the only notice i got was a threatening email accusing me of federal crimes for liking an unknown tweet reinstate all accounts you banned in this sweep and do your job properly. no "final warning" bullshit
what's with the threats in the emails that were sent to reinstated users? there is nothing illegal about liking posts or interacting with innocuous posts from accounts when those accounts *unrelatedly* did something illegal
None of my mutuals who were affected by this received an email notification of the enforcement. They had to send appeals on their own prerogative to get a response. I had to contact them offsite to tell them how they could make an appeal.
Why can’t we remove unwanted followers? I get followed by random bots, I don’t want that, it makes me feel stalked. Please add the option to remove followers, PLEASE! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
i have not received the email for my alternate account that was banned without reason
Is there a way to allow others to follow us, without them just following us unknown ?
I'll ban Nazis and MAGAs all day for free.
Good👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼💙💙💙💙
Why can’t we have our IDs verified?
Verification is baked into atproto. You can tie your bsky account to your website by adding your unique ID to the website (either in the DNS or at /.well-known/atproto) and changing your handle away from .bsky.social See settings > change handle
Settings > Account > Handle > I have my own domain. They seem to have moved it.
I would be interested in assisting you.
OMG —this is how it’s done!!!
You have our trust and support. Ni extremism here.
Multiple users = Bots (probably)
Thank you.