Phang: They never learn, do they? There’s a slew of federal district court and appellate court judges telling this administration that what they’re doing is illegal and unconstitutional—but they don’t care. In response, they just call them “rogue judges.”
Full video from Katie Phang’s YouTube channel here: youtu.be/NordC4Akbck
All this puts the lie to Alito's "Lords of the District Courts". They're better jurists then at least 6 of the Justices.
Than.
Good work.
Because they will then take it to SCOTUS and be free to do what they want.
Fucking Cristo-Fascist SCOTUS...
E Pluribus Unum From The Many One Fascist Nationalism, Is Full Of Treason!
Then they sue them. All of them. They have in fact learned. They have evolved. They learned all the wrong lessons and are winning. It’s all illegal and should be shut down. Unfortunately the Supreme Court disagrees with those judges. Rogue judges you say, I’ve got a few in mind…..
All this puts the lie to Alito's "Lords of the District Courts". They're better jurists then at least 6 of the Justices.
They have the Police and the Military in their pocket. You are powerless! Classic Russian Oligarchy in play. NY to be given to Theil to run as a Charter City Corporation. chartercitiesinstitute.org/intro/
And the Supreme Court endorses the criminality. What does that tell you about America?
When are they going to start arresting people? Nah, I'm just kidding. The supremely corrupt court has stated that this right wing nut job of a government can do whatever the fuck it wants.
Because the SCOTUS is protecting the felon
And around and around we go.The admin and the criminal felon are doing illegal and unconstitutional actions so say a slew of federal/appellate court judges...okay, so who and how are the courts enforcing accountability for these law being broken? Let me guess. No one. So what's the fucking point.
Laws are only useful if the SCOTUS upholds them. Lower courts have no power if they aren't supported by the Extreme Court
Exactly
No fully consolidated fascist regime has ever been defeated through peaceful means. None. Only war, coups and violence have ever worked.
Where's the contempt of court charges already?
NO, NO, NO! Your sound bite is WAY OFF Acyn! The emphasis NEEDS TO BE the ROGUE, ILEGAL, CRIMINAL ADMINISTRATION & ACCOUNTABLILITY!!! YOU are making THIS sound like the judges are rogue. WRONG SOUND BITE & MESSAGE TO CHOOSE Acyn! CAREFUL you are tipping the scale by placing your thumb on IT!
DEMOCRATS IN CONGRESS HAVE A PEOPLE'S MANDATE AND RESPONSIBILITY TO: 👇25th AMENDMENT/IMPEACH trump's DEATH SPIRAL IS PULLING US INTO F_A_S_C_I_S_M!!! trump is not part of an ideology. trump is pathologically taking the USA down a DEATH Spiral!!! youtu.be/SMtOUwYH1lw?...
Because the administration knows SCOTUS doesn't respect the rule of law.
Revolution & when we take democracy back Red congress will face Trials-bc Trump w be Powerless to protect you.. you have 1000 reasons to Impeach & none not to
Bc their SCOTUS ace in the hole always gives him what he wants even if they have to ignore the Constitution to do so. They are his instrument to dictatorship & they are rewriting our laws to accommodate him.
Learn what? That they can get away with anything? Complaining about their crimes means nothing. How are they going to be held accountable?
It’s how dictators get away with taking total control and power!
Fascist
The "Catch Me if You Can" president
They don’t care about the people and they don’t care about the law.
Thumbing their nose to the law, judges, and the Constitution one defendant at a time! Thanks, Chief Justice JOHN ROBERTS!
As long as John Roberts and Sam Alito say Trump’s admin is only violating the Constitution, the law, and due process ONE PERSON AT A TIME, and not as national policy, Stephen Miller and Tom Homan will continue thumbing their nose at the Law & common decency.
Correct. “They don’t care.” They are breaking the law, and they don’t care. So you’re ALMOST there. You ALMOST get what’s happening… You ALMOST see what’s coming… WHY don’t they care that they are breaking the law???????????????????????????
Time to organize the PEOPLES lock'n load emergency act!Protect ourselves!(Bear spray, Pepper spray, emergency survival whistles)children,stay home,stay inside!America needs to shut down, no work, no shopping! BBB delays the hate until after midterms!Our time is upon us! substack.com/@cat4truth/n...
Trump’s MO has been to disparage and ignore any rulings that go against him.
Thank goodness
It will go in front of the supremes, the final stop.
Stick this administration in some rogue jails.
How do we stop this shit from continuing then?
It could not be clearer in the constitution - we shall see if SCOTUS abides by their job of upholding the constitution or again deferring to the yo-yo in our White House.
Arrest them .
We the people need to take over
It's not that "they don't learn." It is that they don't care. And, so far, no one is making them care by administering consequences.
Thanks to everyone fighting for rights & Justice
She hit it when she said they don't care.
Federal district courts can say whatever they want….they no longer have any teeth….trump knows he just ignore them..the rule of law has gone
And Trumps shitty six on the SCOTUS will over turn them every time.
Yeah, because somebody has to *enforce* it. It's not like career criminals like Trump will just stop doing crimes themselves.
It’s not that they don’t learn, it’s that they never gave a shit in the first place. They are incapable of learning.
Government the bullies by the bigots for the billionaires #DivideDistractDominate #FIRE #AlligatorAuschwitz #Kidnapping #ConcentrationCamps #DenyDistractDistortDismay. #Idiocracy Get up, stand up. Stand up for your rights. Get up, stand up. Don’t give up the fight. ~ Bob Marley
Because there’s no contempt of court , there’s no enforcement or penalty for not following the order. Just more bs and more chances.
I just hope she finds thicker brimmed glasses before her next show
We have a rouge Constitution.
The empire would call him a rebel.
I believe so many federal judges have to be thinking "WTH is the Supreme Court DOING?"
They don't care because the playbook is to get it up to Thomas and Alito and they'll write the laws and unwrite the Constitution. And it's working as planned.
Yep. Why not. If I ran the stop sign on my corner every day and nothing happened, why would I stop?
It would be nice if the Roberts Court would go rogue in defense of democracy.
Plus, SCROTUS will side with tRump eventually.
I miss Katie. And Joy Reid. Shame on you MSNBC!
Because there's no enforcement of any of it...multiple arrests should have been made multiple times!!
Why should they care? No one is stopping them…
Until they’re actually held accountable they’re going to continue to ignore the rulings.
What we have is a criminal & rogue mob boss & crime syndicate passing themselves off as government. Remove & prosecute them all.
#SelfDefenseEdu #WhatIsICEsFunction #AligatorConcentrationCamp #WhyAutocratsCrySocilists @katiephang.bsky.social youtu.be/aO8qKVJY7Yk?...
America is not without its flaws. It was built on FREEDOM. FREEDOMS we have all enjoyed. So WHY in the HELL does half the country want to hand over these FREEDOMS to a FELON? A HORRIBLE HUMAN BEING who is running this country like a criminal enterprise? I digress.
Never forgive and never forget the Republicans utter betrayal of the Constitution and America for #TraitorTrump and #Project2025... VOTE THEM ALL OUT IN 2026 and 2028. Remind young voters what NOT voting cost them, their grandparents, sick and pregnant friends and younger siblings. GET OUT THE VOTE!
Because the Roberts Court bails them out. AND they know that will happen
I would argue that they do learn, unfortunately.
They'll keep doing that until there are Consequences for ignoring these rulings. Is that not contempt of court?
Taco rogue. Now there’s a great new name for first felon!👍🇺🇸🇨🇦🇺🇦🇫🇷🇪🇺
… and take the case to the SC to be rubber stamped.
All the issues against executive orders should be class action lawsuits, the only check left on the judicial
Link to the latest doc in the case: www.courtlistener.com/docket/70651...
Everybody acting all surprised… Everything they’re doing is laid out in black-and-white in project 2025. They’re following it verbatim, in order, and they’re doing it well unfortunately. When you have zero respect for the law, the constitution and the courts… It’s here people!
We just have to keep showing up, exposing their biased rulings, let the Whitehouse know we’re not backing down. This is the sustained 3.5% rule in action. They cannot succeed if we don’t allow them to. It’s gonna take everything we’ve got over the next years. We hv to keep reinforcing each other! 👊🏽
Trump doesn't care if something is legal, the question is who will stop him? He bets that he'll get most of it.
In Canada, we have a provincial leader who has done the same since he has held office, 2018 onward. Ontario’s Doug Ford. I suspect Alberta’s Danielle Smith is as arrogant but I haven’t been paying attention to er.
Most corrupt administration ever- condoned by corrupt Supreme Court Justices.
THE most corrupt, MackenzieGirl, yes. 🧢
✊Viva la Rogue!
Such a huge waste of our tax money. Trump should be held accountable for all these frivolous lawsuits/appeals.
SCOTUS is backing him up all the time now though.
Constitutional Treason by Far-Right
🎤 THIS IS SO FUCKED UP. WHY ARE WE NOT FUCKING REVOLTING. AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO DOES NOT WANT TO GIVE THEM A FUCKING PENNY OF MY MONEY. I'M NOT SUPPORTING THIS FUCKERY. WHEN ARE WE THE PEOPLE GOING TO DO SOMETHING? There will be a time when it is too fucking late. It's coming ‼️
Too bad FOTUS.. follow this.. you are NO king. “We The People” who you are working for..
Since they're "rogue judges," they should act accordingly by locking their asses up.
They don't care because they know SCOTUS will allow this administration to do whatever the hell they want.
Because SCOTUS declared a sitting POTUS is omnipotent and untouchable. They ignored the 14th Amendment. They denied states independent election rights. Trump Musk and their fucking Fascist Republican Klan will burn our Democracy to the ground. Sounds like Tyranny.
If Colorado and a few other Democratic led states could've kept their restriction against Trump being on the candidates list, he still would've won. The worst ruling was giving presidents complete immunity in office, and mostly when out. The second worst was Cannon ending the documents case.
The 3 other biggest problems were the lack of a several year sentence after the 34 felony convictions, the lack of the federal election interference trial, and Trump getting away from a trial for the Georgia arrest. He would've been convicted in all 4 arrests on at least multiple charges.
Why is everyone so scared of this fraud? Sad world in the US
Trump should be careful with this as Melania became a US CITIZEN on July 28, 2006, and Barron was born on March 20 2006. Which makes him a birthright citizen! BORN 4 months before his mom was a US CITIZEN!
Barron would still be a US citizen since his father is a lifelong US citizen and resident.
Isn’t that their definition of chain migration though? They want to expel people from the US for that.
No, this is the “jus sanguinis” approach to citizenship that virtually all nations apply - that citizenship is derived from your parents. Chain migration is when a legal resident (not citizen) brings parents / siblings. Some nations allow parents. Very few allow siblings.
But unless we get someone that WE can rally behind and that WE believe in to unite us and give us direction, it’s going to b more of the same. But once someone steps up, we’re good. The longer it takes or it goes to far, it will b chaos and civil war. Thanks Democrats! Appreciate it!
Fight, without any kind of direction. The few option we ACTUALLY have for leadership, aren’t willing to step up to it. All any of them want to do is talk. There r so many non-violent protests we could do that would b so much more effective. I have a few ideas, but I know there would b more out there
Like anything would happen. With ALL the shit he’s already gotten away with, u REALLY think anyone is going to do something like this now? The amount of proof that WE have of his crimes. DAILY! And still they do nothing. They just keep on allowing him to dismantle the country. Then call to US to
They just appeal until their case gets before SCOTUS, which will do whatever Trump wants.
I always hold out hope that our judicial system will survive, but this is not going down the right path, and the current president and Stephen Miller don't give a shit. This will not end up well!!
Didn’t Kavanaugh specifically tell the judges to do a class action suit?
If it's over half of the judges then it's pretty clear that rogue just means antifascist.
They don’t care because nobody is stopping them.
then go to the not so Supreme court and get what they want.
Yes, they learn. They learn that the courts TELL them something is illegal and/or unconstitutional, but nobody STOPS them from doing the thing. They learn there are no consequences. So who cares what the courts say?
They know that they only have to wait for the SC
YOU don't get it, this regime doesn't give a fuck what the courts say. There is no law they won't happily ignore.
We can write a letter asking for removal. Heres the script I was sent this morning . 👇 www.instagram.com/p/DK018wqu5C...
So does SCOTUS. Thanks
YES.
And there's the core of the problem: how to deal with a government that is quite willing to flaunt the law and the USA Constitution?
So, where’s the contempt charges? Indictments?
they're establishing the front lines of the war you'd better wakkke up and stop focusing on clickbait love y'all but you'll get mowed down like grass by fascists they'll shoot your dog too
.....and the SCOTUS majority will back them. 😔
They know the 6 scotusmagats will ignore the constitution and overrule the lower courts.
Why are we not seeing any consequences of any of the lawlessness?
Because there’s no precedent for the lawlessness we are living through right now.
They're not rogue anything because our Government has gone rogue.
Arrest them WTF
They defy learning. These jackals must be FORCED to comply. They only respond to force - nothing else.
I feel obliged to continue to remind everyone that the courts have no guns. The 300 or so words of Article 3 did not envision the possibility of the Executive not playing nice.
Thank you! For that perfect explanation
Rhetoric is valuable only to those that are capable of comprehending. maga cult mentality is ?
And then the 6 at SCOTUS over rule them on the shadow docket,
Hold them in contempt for violating court orders. Any further illegal acts violate direct orders. Those acts no longer are "official" and are not protected by immunity. That opens the door to massive civil rights lawsuits. That's how we get them. Make them ALL pay. From top to bottom.
I cannot recall ever noting in writing how a female news commentator-journalist presents herself. But fwiw: I feel unbounded joy, in these Mar A Lago conservative womens aesthetic days, seeing a passionate woman doing her job with excellence while looking real rather than like a Trump Barbie.🙌💖
NAW, that's Krasnov's "ROGUE ADMINISTRATION "
They only like judges that rule in their favor. True about any entity. So called journalists that kiss his butt get rewarded. Those that don’t meet his scorn. Even Elon lost his favor. DO NOT DISAGREE WITH HIM 👹
Judges need to respond accordingly!
There is no reason for them to "learn"...absolutely NO accountability to date... why would they change their behavior if nothing happens to make it change. j
It's like having Sarah Palin in the Administration.
ANYONE who disagrees with them is illegal or evil or criminal or woke or weak or whatever - it is black or white - you are either for them or against them, there is no middle ground - it is incredibly sad state of affairs
Seeking truth is now considered going rogue!
They also continue to just defy the orders given by the judges.
Emil Bove gave permission for this. He'll get his coveted judgeship on that bona fide.
Leftist Radical Extremist Socialism Communist Marxist Rogue These words have no meaning to them. They are mere insults to be employed when necessary.
Took you long enough to say what we have been seeing.
Unfortunately the Supreme Court doesn’t care either
Six rogue judges are sitting on the highest court in our country.
Next, they'll be enemies of the people. Then a few addresses and kangaroo trials and the judges will fall in line.
Funny how that works, isn't it? They call them rogue judges and simply ignore them.
They are lawless and power-grabbers. They never believed in the rule of law, justice, equality, or the constitution. They believe in greed, power, and hate.
They’re whiny, spoiled babies who can’t ever believe that things don’t always go the way they want.
The Supreme Court is both complicit & afraid. They keep giving him room to out maneuver the lower courts standing. At the same time they are not taking on the real issues with his tactics because they have nothing to back them anymore if they say STOP Roberts’s blinked & lost to a dictator
They handed our country to a corrupt administration. What do 47's backers have on SCOTUS? Something so heinous even SCOTUS is scared.
Fascism.
Project 2025 at work This man, the director of Trump's policies is the man behind t he throne. He controls everything, the final arbiter of policy. Russell Vought.
Unconstitutional
They just wait for SCOTUS to say it's all ok and legal.
Why should they care?there’s NO accountability 4 their criminal activity so it emboldens them.Our courts are paper tigers. Only ppl they can intimidate are the poor, who have no $ or power.There is no fear from those with power/money or both. Time to face that reality head on & then VOTE 4 change!
we need to revolt
It's no longer an administration, but a regime.
What rouge is the Rump administration
The Supreme Court says what he is doing is not illegal. They gave him all the power he wants. Never has there been a more corrupt Supreme Court in the history of this country!
Thank you Katie Phang! Every win for Democracy needs to be known! #PressOnPressOn✌🏼💙🦋🇺🇸
One Million Rising: Strategic Non-Cooperation to Fight Authoritarianism · Indivisible share.google/OaqSPPenrmZW...
So who’s gonna stop them?
Supreme Court gave him carte Blanche laat year🤬What pissed me off is Biden was still president & never took advantage!! He could have done so much more than he did at the end 😢
He couldn't. Mitch McConnell blocked him at every turn and he knew it. Of course we all believed that Kamala would win and I still believe she did.
It’s a rogue administration ignoring the law and the will of the majority 🤬
trump has never cared what courts say...that's not how he is going to be stopped
The US Supreme Court and Chief Justice Roberts says it's fine. They crowned him king.
working as intended. now that they own the SC, none of the other courts matter
Listening to the full show, why do you think they'd lose with THIS COURT? They already rewrote one part of the 14th Amendment, invented immunity out of whole cloth, but you don't think they'll say this part was about slaves? You sure about that? They're to start stripping citizenship.
Hey Americans, this is the red line, in case you were curious
Democrats need to start calling Roberts a Rogue Judge!
What is the punishment for continuing to be blatantly unconstitutional? At some point there has to be something besides impeachment, right?
The fact that the ATTORNEY GENERAL of the US doesn't understand what is happening is beyond disgusting and ridiculous. Nationwide injunctions done through a class action case is still allowed. 🙄
Because the lower courts follow the law … whereas The Orange Felon’s Supreme Court Six get to do whatever the hell it wants … and what the Supreme Court Six want is to please The Orange Felon. 🧢
I still don't get it !! How does this brain sick person have so much power over so many supposed intelligent people ????
They always double down. Even when reality hits them in the face.
Just imagine if Bove becomes a Judge. Any Republican that votes for him should be removed immediately.
In a country with more 🔫s than people, who SCREAMED about their 2A rights to defend against a tyrannical government, all I hear are crickets. Because, you are HERE. Just my observation. 🤔
They are brazen, cold and cruel.
👍
Or wait for the the Supremes to bow down to Trump.
And…no one stopping them…
If Trump and his mates r dumping stock then he may stick to the Tariffs this time
They've got SCOTUS In their pocket. Who cares about district or appeals court judges?
The clear assumption they are operating under, we will stay in power forever. 😧
JFC - is there no stopping them??? 😢
They don't believe in obeying the law.
Trump’s LAWLESS Administration.
Entering the US illegally is a felony.
Entering the US, applying for political asylum (which grants applicants legal status while waiting for the court date), attending said court date is lawful. But being kidnapped/ trafficked by ICE/ Border Patrol before a judge’s decision re political asylum is unAmerican, barbaric assholery. 🧢
Kidnapping doesn't take you back home
The United States is currently negotiating with 11 African countries to take in trafficked people forcibly removed from the United States. Think about that for a moment. The US is CURRENTLY NEGOTIATING with 11 AFRICAN countries TO TAKE IN TRAFFICKED PEOPLE FORCIBLY REMOVED FROM THE US. 🧢
We are? Link me.
It started in January with two countries but has expanded to 11. 🧢
Anti-Constitution is LITERALLY Anti-American
Which is kind of the problem WE have. Our major tool to resist, per the Dem Party, is the Law & Judges but our problem is Trump & his crime syndicate don't CARE about the Law, they've corrupted Judgeship up to & including SCOTUS, and they control all Federal Law Enforcement (& many local Sheriffs).
When you're up against all that..with a Constitution that is woefully unprepared to deal with the Trump/MAGA phenomenom with the one of the two major Political Parties unable/unwilling to resist...what the hell have really got?? What then...must we do? That's a tough question fraught with peril.
It's a slippery slope. You diss judge, and what's real criminals learn? Go after who have the most money and you will not going to be punished. It needs to be repeated all over again. Take a gamble on judge and pay with your wealth.
Who didn't see that coming. The orange fuckface has pissed on the court system for most of his life.
And then SCOTUS overturns the appellate rulings so whatever.
Learn? They don’t care about the law. Trump can do whatever he wants and he can pardon everyone else.
No, no, no. They HAVE learned. They have learned that no one is actually capable of stopping them, if they decide they don’t want to be stopped.
Exactly.
In the W years, they called them activist judges.
They call them rogue judges because some moron will think that's a license to visit them with a hammer and solve their problems for them.
Right, without enforcement, nothing decided by courts matters.
Katie's analysis is invaluable. I think MSNBC made a huge mistake letting her go.
Because they know SCOTUS will swoop in and make their crimes legal.
We turn on the heat and expose them
So triggered, so bitch. You do nothing.
I really can’t stand her. Fuck NBC. They went after Harris unusual hard* Because they are a bullshit network.
They are going to be the proverbial Bull in a China Shop for as long as they can get away with it. The goal is to wreck it. And have their oligarch loot the treasury. Pick up land acquired through bankruptcy. Houses of the medically impoverished. The homes of the disappeared. Remember Andry
Either We abide by the constitutional rule of law, or shit gets bloody and traumatic. I remember my oath, and I'm close to adopting the dead-man-walking attitude necessary to carry it out. Think hard about your place in history.
The real “rogue justices” sit on the SC. The Roberts court has to be the most extremist and corrupt in American history
All the time -the actual "rogues" are in the White House
Thank you Katie!!
He has the corrupt SC he doesn't care what other judges say. Any Democrat not running on expanding the SC shouldn't be taken seriously.
Thank you for all you are doing! So important.
Mmm hmm And he takes it to the bought and paid Supreme Court who seems to typically overturn the appellate and district courts
Because SCOTUS is ok with destroying democracy!
But they are not releasing the Epstein list? Wonder why?
You laid out an excellent, logical, reasonable argument here. But you could also have probably just summed it up with "THEY DO NOT CARE."
