Up To Here - The Tragically Hip (1989): The debut studio album from the band (they released an EP before this), it included the songs Blow at High Dough and New Orleans Is Sinking. The album earned diamond status in Canada (1 million sold). It won a Juno and reached #13.
These are the guys who were Film Studies classmates and casual friends of mine during my time at Queen's! This is really the only album of theirs that I like. I remember them best as the unofficial house band at the Grad Club on campus. They did a killer version of "(I'm Not Your) Stepping Stone".
This is an impossible choice.