I'll give menace points for being my favorite movie when i was six because Double Lightsaber Cool. Both it and Clones mostly leave me confused about what's happening in the plot at a basic, literal level that doesn't get any clearer when I look it up.
Like RoS' writing is dogshit for sure. In the prequels there isn't a single competent component at any level; stiff performances, boring sets, etc.
I'm not as critical of the prequels. Yeah. They're lesser Star Wars, but they're still Star Wars.