These people seem not to understand any laws at all. We should already know how this should be from when George was dumped in a camp.
These people seem not to understand any laws at all. We should already know how this should be from when George was dumped in a camp.
Remember when we spent years renegotiating NAFTA to get USMCA? Good times. Now, we're throwing that out the window. Because, apparently, 'my way or the highway' is a sound economic strategy.
With all the meth/adderal he’s taken his memory is a memory and he’s so busy thinking up his next Lie, he can’t keep it straight. When he dies, there will be 2 deaths, 1 of him and 1 of his mouth 👄. He needs to go to the place where people are dying to go and the neighbors are silent=The Cemetery
🤬
Exactly. You look Latino. We THINK you're here illegally, & now you're being trafficked. That's NOT due process. 😡
So only the INDIGENOUS peoples would be there And much better off without all the aliens right back to the MAYFLOWER
The whole confirm they are here illegally is code for, did they enter the country without permission, which makes them illegal. Now they just confirm you’re the target. They’re like sharks now. Even Americans who can prove they are Americans aren’t safe. They have a quota.
Matt Walsh is another MAGA idiot who thinks he's the smartest one in the room, I guess, if you consider he is in a room full of MAGAts.
This country has hated everybody. No Italians no Irish no Indians no Japanese no Chinese no black people. Except without these people this country would not exist. Cuz you know the white fucking establishment would have never gotten their hands dirty.
That’s whole part of confirming they are here illegally is due process. He just doesn’t understand that and doesn’t like the legal system.
Horrible
I’m sick and tired of this new nomenclature. People are not “illegal aliens” - they are undocumented immigrants.
And George, this is why I have always asked when was America ever great? She’s had her shining moments. She’s done some good things, but there’s always the people factor which makes her imperfect and striving. And now? It is so similar to Hitler 90 years ago!
"...confirm they are here illegally." How does that happen? And deporting to the country they came from is one thing, but kidnapping them and sending them to a gulag where they will die is not what America does.
And by "expel them from the country", we don't mean send them to prison in a foreign country.
Punishment is supposed to fit the crime. Sending people to a death camp for life is way to harsh for just being in this country illegally. Trump is so racist that he's working on ethnic cleansing. The white Nazi and other white hate groups are much more of a threat to us than illegals.
Have they learned a lesson? I pray they have.
I am remembering the 🍊💩’s last assault on our Asian based citizens which resulted in violence and severe consequences. 8647 now!
They deport non whites while desperate to bring in white South Africancs under the falsehood that they are oppressed. Its clear whats going on.
As with all other persons there is a presumption of innocence. Why isn't that being pointed out and being pushed into the faces of trumps' overweight stormtroopers ? Only a judge can determine if a crime has been committed. Heavy-handed new hires don't carry much credibility.
It is all so Trumpian stupid.
The US Constitution disagrees with Matt.
SECOND AMENDMENT TIME Y'ALL
Obligatory zero-charisma hipster record store clerk version of Matt Walsh, seen here without his beard or chin.
A disgrace then. A disgrace now. And we keep being fed bullshit about freedom and bravery and the best country. Fucking bullies with propaganda.
I’m so sorry George that you have to keep reliving that experience now.
Any argument that includes the words "these people" is a dog whistle for dehumanization.
But, we don't have illegal 'aliens'. Other life forms aren't stupid enough to set foot on this backwater WTF world. Hey Carlenix, 'Crazy Planet' is on! Oh, I love this one! Is this a repeat? Nope, same situation different Humans. They didn't learn, did they? Nope.
The interesting language is you confirm (as in ICE confirm). That's not what due process should entail, it'd not judge jury and executioner. An independent party- the judge - should confirm the facts
the cruelty of these people in power now is disgusting. definitely the type of people to run the gestapo.
So you just round up anyone you want in off the street? Seems like profiling to me.
And Walsh continues his infinite-day streak of being unworthy of respect.
I don't know why this is so hard to understand. Having ICE stormtroopers decide who is an illegal alien and deporting them, is like the cops deciding you are a criminal and sentencing you to 10 years in prison on the spot.
It's no wonder minorities overwhelmingly support Democrats. They know what that's like.
Or simply executing you and claiming that it was because they felt "threatened."
That's a problem of its own and definitely needs to be dealt with. It's related to the issue, but police using deadly force so often because they are cowards is not something I want to conflate with deporting people without due process. It's apparently hard enough to understand already for MAGA.
Like with a lot of media they see Judge Dredd as an instruction manual rather than a piece of entertainment, or a warning.
We grew up with Dirty Harry. Looks so reasonable on screen, when you know who the bad guys are.
I grew up knowing he was called "Dirty" Harry because even in his world he was a bad guy. The script just pitted him against even worse guys - he was never a hero.
That's how a fascist regime works. #Trumpism
These same people defend cops sentencing "suspects" to death too, so I think the analogy would be lost on them, unfortunately. But you're right.
Judge Dredd territory, FFS!
My soul mourns for you and your people for what happened to all of you during the war. My soul mourns for our nation that we learned nothing from it.
Matt Walsh better worry about war criminals getting due process
My biggest worry is when people like George aren’t around to remind us of the visible sins of the past, we will lose the last voices on how tyranny happens here.
Matt Walsh is not the brightest bulb in the box. He brags about never graduating from college.
Do you talk about those years somewhere? (In a book or interview..?) I knew this happened. In Holland as well (with people from German heritage). But i didn’t know it happened to you. Wonder how you management to stay (or become?) so positive/empathetic despite this experience.
@georgetakei.bsky.social 👆🙏
I don’t know how other sansei feel, and it’s not as if my father talked about it much, but my spidey sense has been going off since Trump’s first term immigration roundups
Not Sansei (mom is Japanese and the first in her family to come to America, so my family didn't experience the war from America), but same here -- as soon as they started spouting about rounding up "illegals" in "detention centers" that 1st term, the alarms were ringing in my head. Fuck MAGA.
Métis here [half Mohawk half European lineage] and anyone who knows about colonisation was screaming right along with you. We knew exactly what was coming, because when they rounded up people the time before the Japanese Americans, it was us. Only they rounded us up to exterminate, not contain.
You can thank Franklin D Roosevelt (Democrat) for that wonderful experience.
I’m surprised Walsh would allow them the dignity of being confirmed as being in the U.S. illegally before being not deported but tossed into an El Salvador prison or trafficked to a country that isn’t their country of origin. Of course, he thought he was agreeing with what’s been happening.
It's interesting that in WWII they put the Japanese in prion camps, but not the Germans. They must have been too white.
Good lord, due process involves defense, trials and real evidence not just because the name is similar to someone on a list put together by idiots.
Reminds me of when nazis said, "we will decide who is Jewish and who is not"
Matt Walsh, sod off. You know nothing about the law and we are not interested in your opinion.
Unfortunately, Conservatives only remember Jspanese Internment camps existed when they need to try and accuse Liberals of being racist.
I get sick to my stomach when I see them referring to immigrants as "these people".
Who's matt Walsh and when's the last time he ate a bag of dicks?
Matt Walsh is a subhuman pedo monster.
How are you going to confirm they are here illegally?
Somebody ask these fuckfaces this: If you're pulled over for doing 45 in a 30 mph zone, DO YOU GO TO JAIL? No? Why not? Because it's a CIVIL OFFENSE, not a CRIMINAL one! FUCK, it's that easy!!! I always hurt hearing your early childhood story, George. This country can really suck sometimes.
If there is a trial or many trials over this racist nightmare, every lawyer should file a motion in limine preventing DOJ from using the word "illegals" before the tribunal.
We shouldn't even be calling them deportations anymore, they're not being sent back home. They're being abducted and sent to an abusive foreign prison without any due process. Violations of the 4th, 5th, 6th, and 8th amendments.
George Takei, we are sorry that happened to you and your family & friends. & just bc you all looked a certain way, it was not proper you all never were given Due Process! But MORE importantly --- internment camps are wrong, just like the #wack azz Detention centers are all across #America!!
I would like to deport bloviating, self-important white men. I am a liberal, but I guess I’m tired bc I don’t gaf if they get due process before they get drop-booted to somewhere else. Whew. Ok yeah, I’m too tired to be on here.✌🏾
👍
Fascism sucks
America repeating history... @georgetakei.bsky.social I am sorry you went through that. We need to be better.
I don't see any mention of "send them to be locked away forever in a foreign prison paid for by the US government" either
"locked away forever" is a death camp
America is outsourcing its first Holocaust -- as is the American Way.
It's a good joke Kira, but it's also literally the Nazi game plan. Nazi Germany outsourced the first death camps to Poland, also "out of their jurisdiction"
Yes, but then they invaded it and took over. Bringing back genocide to Germany.
There were death camps in Germany as well, notably Dachau and Buchenwald.
Yes, I'm merely pointing out the parallel of the first one being 'not our jurisdiction' in a separate country There is a purpose to that
Was it ever "not their jurisdiction"? Didn't they set them up after invading?
I live in Germany, born in Poland, one grandad fought the Nazis, the other got killed by Polish collaborateurs - and I am here to tell everyone in the U.S.: Welcome to #UnitedStates1933Style Yes, it is a perfect mix between Nszi Germany and Putism that is happening right now. NOW.
History and what happened and what did it teach us is a part. But it won’t be replicated. People voted for and supported the deportation of criminal illegal immigrants. They didn’t vote for a roundup, no due process, and no imprisonment in a foreign country with no charges, proof, or time table
The Trump regime's next step is also probably invading another country, though I think they'll pick on Greenland and keep El Salvador for later
Yup, The American Way has been goose-stepping and wearing swastikas for a long time: wrapped up in the American flag, but just under that is the Nazi uniform.
Fuck you, they didn't "outsource to Poland". They built them on conquered Polish land and rounded up Poles into them as well.
* second. The first was colonisation.
You're *absolutely* right, my mistake! And a callous mistake, at that -- I apologize.
No worries-and not a callous mistake at all 💜 Hard to remember what they won't teach you!
Buy the smugglers have taught them to play the asylum card. 9 out of 10 will fail but in the meantime their paroled into the country and as long as they report can work for years before a hearing.
Without due process we are all at risk of deportation to the hell hole of choice by Noem's corrupt, incompetent Homeland Security good squads. We are living in dangerous times.
As Coffee Indiana pointed out, and needs to be repeated until it sticks... deportation does not include being sent straight to a death camp. Deportation is being greeted by immigration officials in your home country and trying to re-assimilate.
I'm sorry your family went through that, George. It was wrong and shameful then and it's wrong and shameful now. This is not who we should be.
Its sad that you ACTUALLY know what these people are feeling! I never grew up where any of this was possible. So it deeply saddens me that people actually think about this stuff. If push comes to shove, we are ALL immigrants, unless you're a NATIVE AMERICAN, there is no place for this shit!
So the Cato Institute, just reported that 50 of the immigrants sent to El Salvador, actually had entered the country legally! So it is clear the government is not even applying that due process.
Matt Walsh also believes women have no rights and shouldn't vote
So sorry you and your family were subjected to internment, George
No one seems to care that people are being put in concentration camps in El Salvador. That is imprisonment not deportation. cbwrong.blogspot.com?m=1
It's much worse. "They will only be able to leave in a coffin." glaad.org/john-oliver-...
It’s not really being reported much by media. They are now covering LA riots but not really showing us what it is really about… they rather show the crazy blond spokeswoman of the whitehouse telling the world they are having to release a human trafficker 🤦🏻♀️
When we assume that procedures will be carried out as they should, the result is often that the procedures themselves become a formality, and justice no longer belongs to the accused, but to those who manipulate the rules.
When you mentioned that experience, my heart was really tight. That is not a story from history textbooks, it happened to us. Because we looked like enemies, we were deprived of our freedom and skipped due process. This is not an abstract policy issue, but a naked violation of human rights.
You send them back where they came from, with a cola and a sandwich. Tell them that if they continue to enter illegally, their chance of ever receiving citizenship will end. Why wld we purposely hurt the poor? & yes, "finding out" if they're here illegally IS due process!
And sending them back where they came from is NOT the same as sending them to a maximum security prison in a different country.
Most people look like the enemy. As long as they don't look like a Native American, they ARE the enemy.
If you speed, you should be arrested on sight and receive the worst possible punishment without hesitation. That's illegal after all
Whenever I am near Jerome or Rohwer I think about your family and I remember sitting behind you at the opening of the Clinton Presidential Library. I fear not enough people understand the peril we face.
They are not just deporting these people. They are sentencing them to life in prison.
Except it ain't.
We should catch Matt Walsh, See if he is legal insane, throw him in detention till we get around to figuring it out, if ever .. due process .. job done..
FDR was no stranger to this kind of hardball politics. He was quite an “authoritarian strongman” in a wheelchair. And many other terrible things. But the most highly decorated unit in the war was on our side. All Japanese Americans.
And yet you don't want them to do that same thing to other people?
That’s what the devil will say to Matt too!
💯!
All 4 of my grandparents emigrated here. Both of my parents were born prior to them becoming citizens. Do I need to fear deportation because I may not be a citizen in the eyes of ICE?
Why are all of these undocumented people such a threat to them all of a sudden. There’s something else behind their motives for removing them.
Sorry about your family in camp.😢. Or any one wrongfully treated this way.
I am so sorry and sad that this country did this to you and your family George.
and also the 'alien' part. That is a dehumanizing term.
AND Guess who was at Trump signing party for this new "law" www.bbc.com/news/article...
Walsh is another example of legalese ignorance. Apparently they are multiplying. Bet he will know what it is if he is arrested.
Same for my son's paternal great grandfather, who was one of more than 1 million US citizens forcibly exiled to Mexico under Herbert Hoover for the crime of looking "Mexican" to racists. Julian was 10. The US tried to draft him, in Mexico, for wwii. They knew they'd sent citizens away.
Wow
They’re missing the humanity in all this. It reads like they’re describing monsters—not people. These are human beings who deserve dignity. We treat criminals better. Many pay taxes—sales, rent, even payroll. They help sustain our lifestyle. They deserve better.
🤬🤬🤬🤬
the “confirm they’re here illegally” would be a step in the right direction. The problem with Kilmar Abrego Garcia, for example, was that nobody checked to see whether he was here illegally before they shipped him off to El Salvador
Okay, but can we also talk about the "capture them" part? It makes immigrants sound like hunted animals. Also, shouldn't we make sure they're here illegally BEFORE we arrest and incarcerate?
G_d bless, George. You've always been right. I've taught your situation at USARPAC - I remember.
Due process is confirming
Their “confirming” is whether some random person maybe suspects something fishy.
This is making me angrier than most. MAGA is not meeting your “low” bar, Walsh!!! That’s how it was before!!!! They are kidnapping people off the streets!
Matt Walsh is endorsing fascism. The confirming needs to be done by an impartial judge, not by Trump's incompetent Gestapo thugs. And these people have not merely been expelled, they have been sent to a brutal torture prison where they are likely to be stuck for life despite not being convicted.
Listen to George he's a wise man. This isn't the first time we have seen this in history. It wasn't good the first time in America and it was far fucking worse in the Third Reich.🤦🇨🇦
I say leave them the fuck alone if you want vegetables and fruit to eat.
Trump is now judge & executioner.
“Confirm they’re here illegally” = Due process in court! This is not hard to understand. "No person" is to be deprived of liberty without due process. Period. 5th Amendment. Full stop!
The give-away racist, xenophobic dog-whistle is 'these people'. You can see the writer believes they are non-people, untermenschen. It's part of American exceptionalism, and cruelty.
Due process is the quiet oath beneath our flag—promising liberty with fairness, not force. It’s the shield of the powerless, the restraint of the powerful, and the soul of a nation that dares to say: justice must serve all, or it serves none at all.
Exactly right and i was pleased when people booed the representative who said that immigrants don’t get due process. These people need to take the citizenship test that immigrants who speak another language take. Stupid as Hell, Everyone is entitled to due process under our constitution
Holy shit, I had no idea you actually experienced those atrocious "internment camps". I was in high school when I learned about them -- as an American-born half-Japanese girl. I am so sorry you and your family experienced that, Takei-san. I can't believe America is doing it again.
In all fairness, it’s not like they vet or prove any of their other “facts”, why would they start here? Btw love your work
Glad we are all on the same page, too bad CONFIRM did not happen for most of them.
It’s kinda allowed during war time and there was a war raging
This is so ugly.
Let's just send people who are thoroughly vetted and admitted legally into the U.S. on a grant of verified asylum straight to spend life in a violent prison in a foreign country that we pay. That seems fair.
I have documentation that I belong in Canada, and all of those documents can be nullified with 4 words. "Those papers are fake." How am I going to prove it when they are the original document holders responsible for verification? They've got the cards. I don't even know how to find the pack.
Before they rounded up Japanese Americans, it was my people that they rounded up for mass extermination, likening us to "cockroaches." Because you know, savages and all. They're coming for us all, my country included.
He’s so close! Cmon Matt. You’ve almost got it!
So why'd so many here legally get sent to prison in El Salvador? I mean if you're verifying their status I assume it's in a government database
USA has a history of treating "illegals" (in their mind) for so long. And I don't need to count em, we were taught about it in school (am Swedish), Hope Americans was as well -& still are being taught about it. What they did to you Mr Takei, and your family. I can only say- it was despicable.
Unfortunately what little controversial history the Americans were taught was cancelled by the right wing (on the grounds that some white kids feelings would be hurt - the reality was that the parents complained about it because THEY were the ones whose feelings were hurt...)
that's the most clear message we need. It's not the children they're "protecting". It's their parents being *"butt hurt".
Oh look. Matt Walsh is being a terrible person again. Must be a day ending in, “y”.
This has made me think many times of the horrors of what you, your family, and SO many others went through. Thank you for speaking out. Rights CANNOT be ignored, or they are NOT rights but arbitrary privileges.
confirming they are here illegally is "due process." SMH
When did we lose all compassion and decency as a people?
Depends on the people, but most definitely at least since 2016 when the slimeball got elected the first time and was openly a compassionless, indecent person, which empowered people that they didn't need to hide their lack of compassion and decency in order to "blend in with everyone else"
Yes. Trump has given his followers permission to be the worst version of themselves.
Due process is how you find out if someone is here illegally, and what if any other factors are at work. IE what's actually going on. Without that these federal raids and deportations are simply government endorsed terrorism based on race & nationality.
Thanks George. Walsh got turned around, again.
I feel this is why MAGA pushes hard against teaching US history. Understanding the past makes it much harder for these tyrants to repeat those atrocities.
In every way, at every level. I managed to knock over a US Army member who thought that Japanese incarceration in Hawai'i was valid. It was not easy. As the Command Historian USARPAC, influencing the USFK in Korea - they're coming for all of us.
As a Canadian, confirmed. We begin learning about our shitty past (residential schools, war crimes) in grade 2. Makes *most* of us not want to go back there. Especially those of us who come from the legacy of the residential schools. Those stories live in our heads rent-free.
Two guys showing their white privilege.
And a crime-this is the same except they are not on US soil and noone even knows if they are alive
Matt Walsh is admitting that he hates the US Constitution.
Of course he does. He used to ref backyard neo-Nazi diaper wresting matches. He is all about that fascism. www.youtube.com/watch?v=hdZn...
As Mr. Takei points out, you don’t have to be illegal to be denied due process. History is repeating itself! AND we need to Demand PROOF IF LIFE for every person that has disappeared. Existing is not a deportable crime. #ProofOfLife #AndryHernandezRamirez #NeryAlvaradoBorges
Deporting people to a concentration camp is not simple deportation. That is a crime. It is a transnational crime, organized intentionally by leaders of nations and keeping political prisoners. #DemandProofOfLife #unmaskICE #ProofOfLifeCECOT #CECOT
Interviewed 18 families that were interned for my MA thesis at UVa ‘91-2 & the multigenerational stories I was exposed to from varying perspectives was absolutely horrifying. Proud the JACL were able to successfully litigate & set precedent in spite of all the challenges they endured. 🉐 Respect! 🙇🏻♀️
I didn't exist until multiple decades after the internment of our Japanese Americans, but damn, it makes me feel horrible just imagining it. Here we are again, but this time for everyone who pisses off the oligarchy.
Demonizing? Like we've never seen that in history
And to be precise (coming from an immigration attorney) there is more to it than that - depending on the individual circumstances. Thus, due process.
Pfft. Look at the smarty pants over here saying "they need to judge you by the content of your character instead of your skin colour and place of origin" as if that's expedient or cheap. Won't someone think of the poor billionaires? /s
“capturing” is an inappropriate term. A suspect would be written a citation (police don’t hold people charged with misdemeanors). After that:
I wish you could speak to Congress about your story.
I don’t think George’s family should get any publicity considering the racist things his father said about black people. Disgrace
Is this world serious?
trump told everyone he could LOOK at an immigrant and know they were criminals
And THAT was WRONG!
Oh, another thing..they act like Dems never deported any illegals. That's a BIGLY crock of shit.
True, the thing is, if they WERE here legally, or CITIZENS, they have a chance to prove it. A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT! Even if they're NOT LEGAL! And then fine, deport away! Sending somebody to a different country's prison,orher than the one they came from isn't deportation. It's human trafficking.
confirming they are here legally is due process YOU FUCKING MORONS
I've always found the Japanese American internment atrocity less about "looked like the enemy" and more just straight-up white supremacy. My family, all of German descent, looked like the enemy too, but no one interred them.
"Determine if they're illegal" WET MULCH! THATS CALLED DUE PROCESS! YOU MAKE THAT DETERMINATION IN A COURT ROOM!
The "they're criminals here illegally" argument pretty much falls apart when you're inviting ganglords & cartel runners to live here.
I was appalled when I finally learned of what happened to Japanese Americans and I was probably in my 30s or 40s. They don't teach this in school, or they didn't went I went.
I don’t have much sympathy as the Japanese are incredibly racist against black people
Such INCREDIBLY ASININE bullshit. NO ONE is vetting anyone they have kidnapped and disappeared.
“these people”. The Hate.
How many were waiting on the process? They came here; applied for documentation; waited; waited; waited; waited; etc.
Confirm.that.they're.here.illegally? well apparently in hindsight 20% of them were not. So you people fucked up 50 something of 250 some deportations. Not really an acceptable figure in any industry, doncha think?
Congress needs to create an Immigration Court that is part of the Judiciary. Immigration judges are currently part of the Executive and subject to coercion by politicians.
I would like to know how many of these missing kids have been picked up by ice
Isn't this Matt Walsh guy in the states illegally? No need to ask a judge, just deport him.
I only knew about Japanese internment camps because of a book I read in high school for English Lit. Never heard about it in American history. Terrible.
The shocking thing about the “confirming” point is that THEY HAVE A RIGHT TO CHALLENGE ANY EVIDENCE AGAINST THEM AND PRESENT THEIR OWN EVIDENCE. The “deport them now!” folks don’t like the idea that (a) they might be wrong and (b) someone gets to call them on their bullshit.
Wow. How old were you?