Profile banner
Profile picture

Venus Bivar

@vbivar.bsky.social

Historian of capitalism, pollution, Marseille, farming, land use, plastics, climate, and economic growth; misanthrope; hockey player; expert baker; amateur gardener; works at St Anne's College at Oxford 🇨🇦; lives in York

created July 28, 2023

11,827 followers 5,137 following 1,049 posts

view profile on Bluesky

Posts

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

2/9/2025, 5:22:06 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

31/8/2025, 6:58:54 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I used to pick every summer as a kid and then the public spots kept getting bought up by rich people wanting to build vacation homes. By the time I was 20 there were no spots left :(

31/8/2025, 6:47:33 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Jaysus.

31/8/2025, 4:36:51 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Best proposal I've heard in a long long time.

31/8/2025, 12:41:14 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Google said last year almost 30 per cent of its water came from watersheds with a medium or high risk of “water depletion or scarcity”.

31/8/2025, 12:24:03 PM | 6 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

But wait! There's more! "In 2023, Microsoft said that 42 per cent of its water came from “areas with water stress”, while Meta said roughly 16 per cent of its water usage was derived from similar areas during the same time period.

31/8/2025, 12:24:03 PM | 6 3 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

The Great Derangement indeed: Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and Meta plan to increase their capital expenditures to more than $300bn in 2025. IT consultancy Gartner reckons a total of $475bn will be spent on data centres this year, up 42 per cent on 2024. ig.ft.com/ai-data-cent...

31/8/2025, 12:12:49 PM | 21 11 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Do you not have a special area for bikes and pedestrians? We have one in York. Love it. I laugh at the suckers in the long-ass queue for cars as I speedily roll up, unload my soy milk tetra packs, and then get on my way.

31/8/2025, 11:26:56 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Got up early to write, while the husband and dog sleep in, and I have spent the 90 minutes enjoying some animal videos, eating a leisurely breakfast, reading about Arundhati Roy's new memoir, and looking at images of Girona online (gorgeous city!). I did manage to move one intertitle though.

31/8/2025, 9:02:28 AM | 76 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Also, if you're vegan for animal welfare reasons (hi! it's me!), then this article has zero relevance.

31/8/2025, 8:59:39 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

It's awful that this doesn't get more media coverage, that so little is being done to get justice for these indigenous women and their loved ones. Thanks @hollyguise.bsky.social for posting this article. www.adn.com/alaska-news/...

30/8/2025, 8:07:05 AM | 47 23 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Spring is going to be LIT.

image
29/8/2025, 12:46:59 PM | 13 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Ben Wurgaft (@benwurgaft.bsky.social) reposted

lots of sandwich jokes about "heros" "hoagies" and so forth, but nothing about how "the SUBaltern speaks," SMDH

28/8/2025, 5:27:53 PM | 20 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Amazing what is on the internet. Here is some footage of the port of Marseille in 1955! Amazing to see the Étang de Berre before it was turned into a petrochemical nightmare. fresques.ina.fr/sudorama/fic...

28/8/2025, 11:57:02 AM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

In this instance, yes, excludes Britain. Thank you for the titles! Very helpful.

28/8/2025, 11:35:02 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I am so beyond bummed that this is not available in the UK :( Back to my soy nuggets ...

28/8/2025, 9:38:29 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Breaking update: @aburass.bsky.social has come to my rescue!

27/8/2025, 7:05:55 PM | 7 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Yee haw! 🙏

27/8/2025, 7:01:56 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Oh hi. Just trying, as a total outsider, to build a reading list on the Middle East in the 20th c. without accidentally including something that is politically reprehensible. If any fine soul out there with expertise in this area would be willing to look over what I have, I'd be eternally grateful.

27/8/2025, 6:39:10 PM | 19 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

27/8/2025, 2:47:33 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

It's reading list time! Please send me ARTICLES on European environmental history from 1815 to 1914. Apparently I know only books for this period 🤷‍♀️

27/8/2025, 10:02:54 AM | 3 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Pritzker is really turning into a hero through all of this. I still remember the video about renaming Lake Michigan. Keep it coming @govpritzker.illinois.gov !

26/8/2025, 2:33:51 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Can't wait to read this given my obsession with insurance and climate. Anyone out there with good readings to suggest to @katemac.bsky.social and @70sbachchan.bsky.social ?

26/8/2025, 1:34:16 PM | 12 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

I think I'm going to have to include Fudge Kitchen in the acknowledgements of my current book ....

26/8/2025, 9:27:31 AM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

No, I did. I just lost the habit, and then started writing and didn't feel like anything was missing. I would also have to buy it again and if memory serves it wasn't super cheap and I no longer have a fat US research allowance. So I'm just forging ahead with minimal software assistance.

25/8/2025, 3:10:34 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I rather liked DevonThink at one point - used it for my first book. For the second, however, I'm just going with Word and desktop files. Lord help me.

25/8/2025, 2:59:00 PM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Look at that light!

25/8/2025, 2:57:17 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I should add: Thank you.

25/8/2025, 1:59:57 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I think we have a winner!

25/8/2025, 1:59:47 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Bit of a rough watch for a birthday non?

25/8/2025, 11:03:11 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Nightmare. I've noticed that the flags have emboldened more bad behaviour in my neighbourhood. I was harassed by three teenaged boys yesterday while walking my dog on one of the flag-lined streets. There is a toxic masculinity that goes with ethno-nationalism.

25/8/2025, 10:21:28 AM | 36 7 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Author photo!!!!!!!!!!!!

22/8/2025, 7:03:45 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Yup! Permanent job. I'll be there until I retire or until Reform leads the UK to implode!

22/8/2025, 5:48:58 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I live in York. They are all over my neighbourhood.

22/8/2025, 5:43:11 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Nor should you!

22/8/2025, 5:26:11 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

I try only to repost the best ones. This qualifies.

22/8/2025, 5:20:09 PM | 26 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

So many have sprung up in my part of town as well. It's so fucking awful.

22/8/2025, 12:54:43 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I used to live upstairs from a Chicago Symphony violinist - and I LOVED it. So wonderful to listen to her practice.

22/8/2025, 10:13:02 AM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

So jealous.

22/8/2025, 10:03:01 AM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Mic drop on AI from @historicaloracle.bsky.social .

21/8/2025, 11:50:55 AM | 13 5 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Jason Hickel (@jasonhickel.bsky.social) reposted

Yesterday in 1953, the US and Britain carried out a brutal coup that deposed Mohammad Mosaddegh, the popular Prime Minister of Iran, beloved for his progressive and pro-worker reforms, because he sought to restore national control over the country's oil reserves.

image
20/8/2025, 4:36:19 PM | 261 136 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

The number of St George Cross flags that have gone up around the neighbourhood is truly alarming and depressing.

20/8/2025, 2:47:55 PM | 6 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Did anyone in England get rain in the last couple of days? I feel like I read there was going to be a giant storm on the heels of the hurricane, but not a drop fell in York. I am genuinely worried about the water shortage :(

20/8/2025, 9:52:48 AM | 8 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Mine didn't set well, even with the pectin. At 204F the jam was spitting so badly that I was getting spot burns all over my hands and arms. So I gave up. Tips for the spitting? I suppose I need a bigger pot and a longer spoon and some protective gear. Jam is dangerous!

19/8/2025, 8:30:21 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

As someone who just made jam for the first time (bumper plum crop this year), I eagerly await the results. I myself used pectin.

19/8/2025, 7:54:26 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

19/8/2025, 7:47:25 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

The Situationnists would be proud.

19/8/2025, 3:05:41 PM | 9 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

One of the best exhibits I’ve ever seen was a solo Asawa show at the Pulitzer in St Louis.

19/8/2025, 10:58:53 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Love that book. Still remember the descriptions of the glassworks.

19/8/2025, 8:18:23 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

19/8/2025, 8:15:17 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Ah yes - this happened to me on the regular in St. Louis. Solidarity.

17/8/2025, 4:22:22 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Super - thank you.

17/8/2025, 4:15:50 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Do you have a link?

17/8/2025, 2:44:06 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Oh cool. Didn't know about that. Thanks!

17/8/2025, 2:43:17 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Love this. The butler is just so fantastically clueless. Ishiguro really commits to the naive narrator.

17/8/2025, 10:57:50 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Oh @rpanchasi.bsky.social ….

17/8/2025, 10:51:15 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Non-human animal videos are saving the internet for me.

16/8/2025, 9:00:43 PM | 8 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Thanks for sharing. This is close, but maybe a bit to technical in the legalities of a class action case for my first years.

16/8/2025, 11:13:58 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Sam has done some awesome work here - and it's great that he's sharing it with everyone.

16/8/2025, 10:01:44 AM | 10 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

French friends - any insights for the wonderful Christina? You around @picharbonnier.bsky.social? @margotlyautey.bsky.social? @parriblue.bsky.social?

15/8/2025, 8:29:48 PM | 4 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Understandable. He looks deadly. But he's a gentle giant.

15/8/2025, 5:45:32 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Loki would be very happy to assist.

image
15/8/2025, 5:09:39 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

A gift link! on.ft.com/4maRLiu

15/8/2025, 11:07:52 AM | 4 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Hardly a surprise, but so so depressing. We have to stop plastics at the source - this is not a waste problem, it's a production problem. www.ft.com/content/f808...

15/8/2025, 10:35:38 AM | 30 8 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

The kids are alright!

15/8/2025, 8:29:09 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

14/8/2025, 3:20:43 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Send me an email. Headed off on holiday now. I might be able to swing it when I get home!

14/8/2025, 1:01:36 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I think the MIT piece does a good job of explaining just how hard it is to measure the environmental impact, which in turn leaves room for all kinds of wild estimates. The bottom line though is that this is very very carbon intensive.

14/8/2025, 1:00:23 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

We had a special meeting for all of our college students in history last term. This coming term I will get all of the first-years to read this stuff before their induction meeting and we'll discuss AI then. For non-Annes students, I will ask them to read it, and will discuss in first tutorial.

14/8/2025, 10:28:19 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I'd love a piece on how AI relies on theft - so if anyone has one, I'm all ears.

14/8/2025, 10:16:52 AM | 22 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

4. And a great short piece on how writing is actually a tool to sharpen your thinking and without doing the writing yourself, you aren't really learning anything at all. www.hepi.ac.uk/2025/06/06/i...

14/8/2025, 10:16:52 AM | 77 9 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

3. This is the Black Mirror version of AI. amandaguinzburg.substack.com/p/diabolus-e...

14/8/2025, 10:16:52 AM | 35 5 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

2. This is a great explanation of how LLMs actually work and why they hallucinate. Bonus for being hilariously funny. garymarcus.substack.com/p/why-do-lar...

14/8/2025, 10:16:52 AM | 41 5 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

For all of the educators trying to deal with AI, I did a deep dive in early June and these are the four articles I decided to assign to my students. 1. This is the longest of the bunch, but so wonderfully comprehensive. www.technologyreview.com/2025/05/20/1...

14/8/2025, 10:16:51 AM | 377 169 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

This makes me realise I should post again with my edited list. I will do that now! I narrowed it down to four pieces that do slightly different things.

14/8/2025, 10:10:41 AM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

This is my favourite show in the UK. The panelists are hilarious.

14/8/2025, 8:40:17 AM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Breaking update. The moths only ruined the very first plums to ripen. For the last two weeks we have been drowning in plums. Today I am stewing and jamming and making pâte de fruit and preparing bags for give away.

13/8/2025, 12:31:39 PM | 31 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Oooooh. Will check it out.

13/8/2025, 10:04:27 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Getting caught up on @thedigradio.bsky.social this summer. This episode about the United Health Care CEO assassination is a stand out. It ranges broadly over questions of political violence, class dispossession, and alienation. thedigradio.com/podcast/assa...

13/8/2025, 9:10:52 AM | 15 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

This is the face of a very good boy who wants to know why I am not sharing my ice cream (he's already had TWO doggie ice creams today).

image
12/8/2025, 6:39:43 PM | 20 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Help a sister out?

12/8/2025, 6:04:40 PM | 3 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

12/8/2025, 6:03:07 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

If the fossil fuel companies fail to burn us alive, they'll poison us with plastic.

12/8/2025, 8:25:34 AM | 7 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Yesss!!!

11/8/2025, 8:42:24 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

As a former Pentictonite it's hard for me not to root for Ogopogo. But either way, yes, the flag is definitely the lamest choice. Maybe a wild fire? Or an abandoned mine?

11/8/2025, 4:35:47 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

This is extraordinary.

11/8/2025, 4:01:07 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Oh I don't think these are good people. Just shrewd people. People whose bottom line is too important to be clouded by the politics that usually distorts how people in power view climate change.

10/8/2025, 10:38:18 AM | 6 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Back on my insurance soap box. The best way to understand climate change is to watch the insurance industry. They are paying very very close attention. www.cnbc.com/2025/08/08/c...

10/8/2025, 10:25:05 AM | 167 49 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

We should give you citizenship based on this joke alone.

10/8/2025, 10:21:52 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

This is some very niche humour, but I see what you did here.

10/8/2025, 10:21:31 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Oh wow. Any good? I teach Paul Slack's Invention of Improvement, which covers progress a lot. It leads to good discussion, but has a pro-Britain flavour that is hard to swallow sometimes.

8/8/2025, 12:13:15 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

And what a face it is! Loki wants to know if they can be friends.

image
7/8/2025, 8:48:45 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social)

Solidarity to everyone else out there who is also working on a BA Mid-Career grant application. May the odds be ever in your favour.

7/8/2025, 8:03:28 AM | 21 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

Wow. So cool. I also hear that there is now a bike lane on Granville Bridge.

6/8/2025, 4:28:34 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

This pain is so real. I too am getting them to reverse outline essays - the first 2-3 pages of 'The Touble with Wilderness' works well. The discussion we have afterwards is fantastic - they can see the transitional sentences, how the paragraph coheres, etc. Can they mimic it? Nope. But it's a start.

6/8/2025, 9:21:26 AM | 6 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I have been researching plastic non-stop for the last 6 weeks. It is 100% as bad as climate change, and actually, you can't pull them apart given that it's all the some companies.

6/8/2025, 9:06:54 AM | 4 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

No worries! I'm the foreigner spouting off about your homeland :)

4/8/2025, 7:38:31 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I live in York.

4/8/2025, 7:20:02 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Venus Bivar (@vbivar.bsky.social) reply parent

I think I might be en route to becoming 'the older person' 🤣 as I try to make eye contact and venture a 'hiya' when passing people on the pavement. And I've had great chats with neighbours once they realise I'm open for business. It's just the first step that Brits seem less willing to initiate.

4/8/2025, 7:00:18 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view