Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
There is no differentiation when the country is committing genocide.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
There is no differentiation when the country is committing genocide.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes you are by defending Israel.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You not only support genocide and starvation of children — you’re also insufferable.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You claim it’s not an ethnostate but it was founded as a Jewish state. That. Is. An. Ethnostate. Ethnostates are racist and bad and if it isn’t one there was never any justification. Enjoy your fucking genocide and death, your heart is pure black to support it.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You’re claiming it’s not an ethnostate. If it wasn’t founded on Zionism, which is an ethnocentric ideology. then there is no justifiable reason for the Nakba and removal of the Palestinian people from their land Nazi. You’re simping for a state starving and killing children. That says everything.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I keep saying Nazi because supporting a genocidal state is something only Nazis do, actually. You didn’t respond to my last comment either, just tried to misdirect as Zionists Nazis always do.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
If it is not an ethnostate/“jewish state” as you say than there was zero justification (not that there would be anyway) for the Nakba, Nazi.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Israel does not represent all Jews. I’m Jewish and am anti Zionist. It is an apartheid state by nature of what happened in 1947 and the subjugation of the Palestinian people. Go away Zionist.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
But I thought the entire reason Israel deserved to exist was because Jews lived there 3k years ago after slaughtering the canninites. If it’s NOT s a singular “Jewish state” there is no justification for the Nakba (which there isn’t anyway)
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Are you saying it’s not a Jewish state? Uhhhh
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
No, you’re immigrants, because the United States (for someone so concerned with the name of things, it’s the United States of America - you could be referring to North or South America), despite what our current leadership wants, is not an ethnostate. White ppl colonized it from Native Americans.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Everything is well documented re what happened during the Nakba. Israel poisoned the water in Gaza after stealing the Palestinians land. I sit. Care if you think whatever the fuck was happening 3000 years ago matters for the last 100, it’s a dumb fuck opinion. Enjoy being a Nazi.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Israel is an ethnostate that colonizes, subjugates and has tortured the Palestinian people, your ethnicity is irrelevant and gives you no standing here if you’re defending genocide.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You are defending genocide, Nazi.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Defending genocide and subjugation very much makes one a Nazi.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
“How old were you when you became anti genocide” ok Nazi
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
38 and yes I grew up with Israeli indoctrination in Sunday school as a Jew. I also took a history of Islam class in college that went over the conflict.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes you nazi cretin because up until the current genocide there were living survivors of the Nakba. I assume they have died from Israel’s actions. Israel has taken so much from them. No one from BC is still alive.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I’m a troll because I want progressive candidates to fight and do better for children starving to death being shot in the head while they try and get aid?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
She said immoral for a reason.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
👏👏👏
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Are you calling Omar pathetic too? x.com/IlhanMN/stat...
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I truly do not give a flying fuck if there was a kingdom named Israel in 938 bc. I care what happened to people 76 years ago.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
www.dsausa.org/statements/o...
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Being anti genocide is the exact opposite of being a Nazi you dolt
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
First off - it was an amendment that simply struck 8076 from the bill. Second, it’s pretty fucking pathetic that mtg has a more leftist stance on Israel than our supposedly leading progressive house member. Third, fuck your nuance while starving children are getting shot in the head instead of aid.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You think she wrote a bill? Lmao
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
*not
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
She supports funding their iron dome. That goes against the Palestinian cause. Any funds towards Israeli defense frees up their budget towards their aggression. Did you miss what just happened in Syria or do you think the world revolves around you?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Jesus fucking Christ Google is free legiscan.com/US/rollcall/...
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Your reply was to my comment regarding f he 888 dumbass.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Then why is she advocating for something similarly asinine and fascist?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
www.congress.gov/bill/118th-c...
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Also this isn’t hr 888 that vote was like two years ago
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes, the one where she says Israel is genocidal but advocates for funding their defense? Would you have donated to Nazi germany’s defense?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Then why did she vote yay on hr 888
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You already said that Nazi
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
No it is not.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
ALL the amendment did was remove 500k of funding for defense. It did not reappropriate said funds for offense. It struck down section 8076 of the bill.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
No one cares Zionist
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Announcing it is so fucking funny
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Ok Nazi
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Well she’s certainly not going to vote against it, is she.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Just want the leading “””progressive””” rep to actually vote as a progressive and also not to gaslight like she did here. Her record on Israel is neutral if you look with rose colored glasses at best.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
No one is fucking saying the vote itself is life or death. They’re saying it’s indicative that AOC plans to continue to vote in favor of defense spending on Israel which directly harms the Palestinian cause. THAT is life or death if she runs for president.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
The land of Israel is a historical and biblical term referring to a broader region that includes parts of modern-day Israel, the West Bank, Gaza, and sometimes areas of Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria. The modern country of Israel was established in 1948 on stolen land.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Oh fuck OFF I am a Jew, I’m aware of the history of the land and area. I don’t give a fuck who lived there 3k years ago. I very much care who lived there 76.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
The actual scum are the ones who made the Nakba happen actually. Sorry about your family though. I wish it had never happened so that wouldn’t have happened to you.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Israel has no right to exist on stolen land.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Well for one, I have eyes and can read, so I don’t really need to visit to know it was founded on colonization, subjugation and stolen land.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Thanks for boosting the comment tho
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Israel is absolutely a racist genocidal apartheid state.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
For someone who likes calling people dipshits that one was crazy. It is WAY too early to say if she will be challenged and after this I highly suspect she will be. I’m not in her constituency anyway but will canpaign if she’s challenged by a real progressive.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Lmao we both want her gone for very different reasons (free Palestine) but I suppose whatever makes it happen.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I’m book-marking your page so I can return when she loses her re-election next year.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
“According to a Data for Progress-Zeteo poll released last week, 71 percent of likely Democratic primary voters say that the U.S. should end its arms transfers to Israel until it “stops attacks on civilians in Gaza, supports Palestinian rights, and commits to a long-term peace process.”
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Zionists gonna be fuckwads as usual
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You aren’t seriously saying Palestinian activists and supporters are a worse misfortune than bombs and star actor. The actual fuck
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Sure at least I’m not a fucking Nazi like you
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Ok so it’s ok if the brown people die just not the white ones. Got it!
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
SUPPORTING THE IRON DOME FINA NC IALLY DIRECTLY SUPPORTS RHE GENOCIDE you fucking Nazi, buying into her liberal ass posting as a progressive. You deserve her and not for the reasons you think.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Would rather be a dipshit than a Nazi like you.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Yeah because Israel makes that so easy, right? Fuck off
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
She literally said she supports the iron dome in her statement you illiterate Nazi
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I don’t think I deserve more comfort or safety than a starving child who is shot point blank when they try and get food they e been promised.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Girl I’ve been mad at AOC since 2021 and she voted present, this isn’t anything new. She’s trash for the railroad workers strike vote too. Also hr 888.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I think the screenshot is pretty telling. It’s not about “being a hater” it’s about having morals.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I said without retaliation.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Bad faith argument, they’ve offered to release the hostages over and over
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
What I want is for Israel to stop killing Palestinians and committing genocide.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
They’re only able to kill Palestinian lives without retaliation due to the iron dome. You can’t say you want Palestinians to live while supporting the iron dome.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
😂
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Are you also going around calling Green, Omar and Tlaib Nazis?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
In the facist because I didn’t want 500k to go to the iron dome? Goooooot it.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Oh FUCK right off. Do you think starving kids in Gaza fucking care about “nuance”? I don’t fucking care what method helps soothe a fucking genocide two years in. Sounds like you’re the Nazi if you think ideology is more important than their lives.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I support Nazis because…I don’t support genocide? Be so for real
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
So if she apologized in 2021 why is she doubling down in 2025 POST GENOCIDE?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Hey op blocked me - what are they saying about data? Genuinely curious. If there’s anything negative I’m open to proof.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I disagree. I think MTG has genuinely become anti Israel, just for completely different reasons than the left. I’m Jewish - if she’s anti Israel because she’s antisemetic I don’t give a flying fuck as long as it benefits the staging children behind shot point blank as they seek food before they die
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
As well, after the hr 888 vote she deployed the same gaslighting tactics to avoid addressing it, the uproar was just louder this time.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
*now
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
It’s meaningful for me because: A. Her reasoning was horseshit B. She has a history of voting for Israeli defense and has not outright said it C. She has also voted to affirm Israel’s right to exist, that is not progressive D. She decided to lie and gaslight rather than tell the truth
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
👏
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
The dems are genocidal fuckwats and I do not believe I deserve more comfort or safety than a child in Gaza.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Lmao
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
THEY ARE COMMITTING GENOCIDE. “If you want to stop sellin weapons to Nazi germany, clearly the right move is to keep Nazi Germany’s defensive capabilities intact” They will can use their own funds. Not sending them money just means they have to use that money for their defense not offense
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
A. They’re a genocidal nation. Nothing will stop them from using the funds for offense B. Even if they don’t, it frees up money for their genocide and aggression C. The only reason they’ve been able to be aggressive without retaliation is the iron dome and we’ve see what happens as a result.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
*representstive
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I’m sorry but we’re allowed to criticize the foremost progressive candidate for her shitty vote that didn’t align with the base’s wishes. “The rights work” fam I just want my tax dollars to stop murdering babies and AOC said she supports the iron dome. 🗑️🚮
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Calling people bots because they disagree with you is crazy work. Its just real leftists with actual morals, unlike AOC lmao
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Why is it 500k for the genocidal nation and not 500k for their victims as they’re starved to death and shoot in the head when they seek aid from honey traps?
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes because she defending her choice as DEFENSIVE said knowing FULL WELL any defense aid they receive also contributes to freeing up money for their OFFENSE/GENOCIDE. That statement is SPECIFICALLY why this is a breaking point for so many people. “Nazi genes deserves our aid”
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Calling legitimate and real leftists with actual morals bots because they’re not “yasss queen”-ing is not the move
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
I advocated for voting for Harris and pushing the party left. I don’t blame anyone who abstained or voted third party when the choices were genocide or slightly worse genocide. I almost threw up casting the vote.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
You said you agree with me but AOC flat out said she thinks we should Fund the iron dome. Nothing you said means we can’t criticize reps who don’t vote with our best interests and wishes in mind. She knew full well her base wouldn’t have wanted her to vote nay.
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
*murdered
Joshua W (@charmingdefense.bsky.social) reply parent
Are Omar and AOC still friendly at this point? I hope not.