(i do think the User Poll has that same recency *negative* bias that people have with e.g. WoW expansions though. I mean, Gatewalkers and Wardens of Wildwood worse than Serpent's Skull or Jade Regent? Age of Worms and Savage Tide in the top 10? c'mon.)
![When it was first released, just before my 2021 guide to Adventure Paths, [Abomination Vaults] was extremely highly regarded and often recommended as a great introduction to the Pathfinder system. Over time, that perception has faded. Abomination Vaults went from the community’s #2 favorite of all time to well back in the pack. Most of the criticisms leveled today at this AP come in three forms: 1) The rooms are too small; 2) It’s not logical that all these powerful creatures would simply be hanging out a few doors down from each other; and 3) there isn’t much incentive to roleplay.](https://cdn.bsky.app/img/feed_thumbnail/plain/did:plc:blo3bvqyphvulft6v5bgoifr/bafkreibu7kf3peutzpkx25z7f6exwqqzlgdgtmmnb6h76dzdoxx7bb4zha@jpeg)
people were upset with the ending of Tyrant's Grasp??? the ending of Tyrant's Grasp is sick and those people are babies
oh you can actually put this tip into every AP printed before 2024 🙂
Things I'm more interested in after reading this: Crimson Throne, Agents of Edgewatch, Hell's Rebels, Seven Dooms Things I'm less interested in: Council of Thieves (i guess it's good setup and 0 payoff) A common theme here is "this AP could be a 9 with some changes but as written it's a 4" 🫢