losing her lives? Does she just have trouble conceiving and this was an unfortunate accident? Was it just abnormal and the branch hitting her is what did it? It doesn't matter because all that matters is that she feels punished. I like that this book was pretty anti-StarClan and I hope this means
that the series plans to examine that more, but I'm not going to get my hopes up. This is the same series that told cats from the Dark Forest that they could never be redeemed (despite them literally helping the protagonists for the solid last books in the arc) and didn't treat this like it was a
huge problem that StarClan said that. Anyway. 5/10 -- too much telling and not showing, which really causes the book to plod towards the conflict we already know is coming way ahead of time thanks to Ivypool's Heart. Galestar is cool.
This book and Leopardstar's Honor needed their page lengths/word counts swapped.
one more thing-- the problem with books that consistently tell instead of show, is that when they do show, it nearly 100% of the time reveals their hand plotwise. character is shown to have a nice moment? well don't get too attached to them then, because they're definitely dying the next chapter.
and that's definitely true here. My Pet Peeve. if this isnt your pet peeve then i'm so happy you could enjoy this more than me bc WHEW
there is a fanwork that ascended to its own indie project that has a very, very difficult time with the above too and i don't want to say its name because i WILL probably get subtweeted to hell and back, but if you know you know.