cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
(and media, etc.)
Writer, editor, artist, scientist; she/her
167 followers 105 following 1,550 posts
view profile on Bluesky cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
(and media, etc.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
The justification is published trials, FDA approval, and post-marketing data, a massive amount. Does he want representatives of the pharma firms to justify their products to him in a private audience? ... Oh, I see; he means bribes: they need to pay up, like law firms and universities.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
It is David Koresh. It's not supposed to be an image of the poster; instead, show Koresh in a MAGA hat, to be edgy, I'm speculating.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
The problem is that most people have no idea how a clinical trial is designed, run, and analyzed; it all must seem like a black-box mystery, so RFK and random internet conspiracists can spew nonsense, and who's to dispute it in the echo chamber of online antivaxx chatter?
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
This is absolute trash. Investigators do not "reassign" AEs to the unvaccinated (or placebo, or control) group, ever. In a double-blinded trial, investigators don't know who's in which group; AEs are reported and tracked by participant number.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
"Princeton could use a guy like Joel."
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Props for invoking the Glasgow Coma Scale.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
It sounds extraordinary. Thank you.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
(Forgot the parentheses, but you all know what I mean)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
“Don’t Go Back to Rockville”
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Thanks! I appreciate the recommendation! (My TBR pile is also large but I take personal referrals to heart.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
It made me angry. I felt betrayed; I’d been relating to the raw writing about a disintegrating marriage (they are in Italy, as I recall), and then sputtered (inside), “She has a BOOK DEAL while she’s doing all of this?” I think I threw the book on the floor; I remember that I did gasp out loud.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes. You can strive to do the right thing— not to get an A but to be a decent person, to try to save your neighbors’ or faraway humans’ lives, to work for the common good—and not apologize for it when it’s mocked or denigrated or rejected. You keep doing the right thing and hold your head up.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
That’s what I mean; it was really disillusioning as a reader. (I was more naive then.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
One has to wonder who's the editor of that section, ie, who read that piece before it went to press? "Paris Is Burning" and "Harlan County, USA" are cousins as groundbreaking radical documentaries, not a study in contrasts (as everyone here has noted). Did nobody in the loop check? (I know; "no.")
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
(I don't begrudge authors their book deals, just that the idea of ending a marriage and seeking one's soulmate in Indonesia on Penguin's dime made the whole endeavor seem contrived to fulfill a narrative rather than reflections on experience.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
... but I can't shake the fact that, when I read "Eat, Pray, Love," I thought the first section had honest writing about her marriage, but then she mentions a call with her editor. I gasped aloud because it dawned on me that she had a book deal, and the rest of the book I could not abide.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Thanks for giving props to Jia T.; I had started reading the piece without having noted the author, and the writing was so compelling that when you named her, I thought, "Ahh, of course." As for Gilbert, she has a generosity of spirit that I can't deny... [cont'd]
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Alcoholic! Genius! Also, great in Elaine May's undersung "Mikey and Nicky," with the inimitable Peter Falk.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
In sum, the rush to AI (and massive financial support of it) is fundamentally anti-human.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
ChatGPT gives the illusion that “you” control the “PhDs” (biased, stolen morass of information being churned through pooling layers); promoting on that illusion is more appealing than consulting human scholars (or existing documentation created by knowledgeable people).
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I have been reminded of Andropov, a (lesser known) Soviet prime minister from my youth, whose decline and death were very murky.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Billionaires and morons (often one and the same) should not be “interpreting” scientific studies they do not understand. (Mike Lee: “Oh dear!”)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
No doubt. I gave him partial credit for "one twelve," which is at least only 10 off. Still wrong, F, you fail, good day, sir! But less wrong than 1112, or the answer given by his dumb son, or his dumb, "practical" daughter. U Penn is not sending their best.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
As I hear it, OranGump says, "It's eleven-twelve, it's one-twelve," which is admittedly better than I thought he'd do. (As we know, the answer is 102.) He had 20 sec. to do it in his head (and likely somebody fed him the answer and got it wrong.) Donj and Ivanka can't do mental math either.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
(Should have typed "And/or," because he could still be dead.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Or if someone overseas was managing the account for that shift and forgot about the time difference.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
And people with medical training, such as Makary and Bhattacharya, are the worst enablers, in that they are choosing to reject what they once, long ago, must have believed, or at least paid lip service to, in service to a systemic wrecking ball and death wish.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes. They think they are paying for [certain] results. I also think that, across this regime, a fundamental suspicion of/lack of interest in science means they regard most biomedical and other research as an indulgence, as if scientists "ought to be done by now," or similar reductive thinking.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Just had to drop this in here [it's live, so, not featuring Page and Jones, but incredible]:
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I liked Roger Moore best, because he was the Bond of my childhood, but once I had seen the Connery films I realized Moore was sort of an '80s, more palatable Bond. (Not an opinion, but): I was delighted to learn that both Jimmy Page and John Paul Jones play on Shirley Bassey's "Goldfinger."
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Thank you; watching that brought me joy.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Possibly my favorite quote; I drop it every chance I get. Thanks for getting it in here.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
It is grotesque how this regime actively seeks to degrade accomplished Black women who have worked for decades in public service in positions of expertise and authority. Similarly dismissive terms were directed to the head of the Library of Congress, Dr. Carla Hayden, and Gwynne Wilcox of the NLRB.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Anna Bower's Lawfare liveblog on the hearing is excellent. She includes a statement by one of the children (I expect all of them have similarly heartbreaking situations): -- www.lawfaremedia.org/article/emer...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
APHA (Am. Public Health Assn.) has demanded RFK's removal; Defend Public Health, a grassroots org. of researchers and public health workers, is vocal in demanding that RFK (as well as his cronies at NIH, FDA, and elsewhere) resign or be fired. Many other orgs. are defying RFK's directives.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Physicians are in an uproar, but I suspect that day-to-day responsibilities curb many people's abilities to organize. Only Trump can remove RFK, but Congress can impeach. We need to drag RFK into hearings day in, day out, and put in front of the public just how dangerous his actions and ideas are.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social)
The AMA has issued multiple (upward of a dozen) statements opposing RFK's actions, expressing grave concerns about his impact, calling for reversals of decisions such as his dismissal of all the members of ACIP (vaccine panel). To my knowledge, AMA has not yet outright demanded his removal.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Noting his mirror/backward image, with "AS" showing on the cap (which my mind automatically finishes as "ASS").
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Agreed -- from this narrative, the 1st incident is 100% independent of the 2nd. Why include the "good samaritan" event unless as cover for something else? (Will we learn that RG was "struck at high speed" from behind by someone involved with the alleged DV incident?)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Wow. I had always assumed Riley was the daughter of former Olympic swimmer Rowdy Gaines, which made me sad, because as a young age-grouper I'd looked up to him. I'm glad to find out he's no relation. Brad looks crazed; no doubt he's aligned with his bigoted, self-pitying, non-podium daughter.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Grotesque. Note the chyron, "Blackburn: Communities Want to Feel Safe," with footage of armed goons in camo abducting workers. The dissonance is so strong. Communities truly feel safe when people can just go about their daily lives, unthreatened.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
From the narrative, the 1st incident is 100% independent of the 2nd. Initially, I thought Giuliani had been struck while pulled over on the shoulder (not uncommon), but officers arrived and RG left. Then, RG was just driving. Why include the "good samaritan" event unless as cover for something else?
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
There is always room for love between racists.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes, the "low trust" is "low trust of established, credible, non-corrupt experts."
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
She misses what my [immigrant] father used to deride as "Goddamn formless American bread." (Yes, I realize she is from the UK, but we exported our garbage bread to them.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Many of the people tossing around "seed oils" as though it means "lighter fluid" couldn't even tell you what seeds those oils are made from.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Anna Merlan is a fucking national treasure and an excellent reporter. Jezebel, especially when Anna was there, and Mother Jones have done (and do) great, incisive, breaking work, and the DHS shows its dumbness and playground-level tactics by taking cheap shots. (Go, Anna!)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I don’t know, but I remembered (semi-accurately!) that Andropov’s death (Russia, 1984) was very murky. www.rferl.org/amp/karimov-...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Can’t wait to hear this album. Thanks for the tip!
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes, absolutely. See also David Gorski’s thread, below: bsky.app/profile/gors...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
“Signed, Ozymandonald”
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Hot tub = communicable diseases; that's all I can think. Good luck with that Legionnaire's, sir, now that we no longer get alerts about outbreaks.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Both Vance and Trump repeat variants on "didn't say thank you" with such petulance and unselfconsciousness, as if this were a normal, professional way to discuss diplomacy or policy. Their thinking is so stunted that they can only parrot lines from a disciplinarian childhood.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Implying, moreover, that Melania, a Slovenian, would have any diplomatic power or insight (let alone even attend a meeting) as to the war on Ukraine?
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
And the chud just named acting director of the CDC is Jim O’Neil, former director of the Thiel Foundation and of the Thiel Fellowship. Thiel’s people are everywhere.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Seemingly he only likes the big '80s shows -- Andrew Lloyd Webber (Evita, Phantom, Cats) and Boublil/Schönberg (Les Mis). It fits -- those are from his NYC heyday, and they're all big, overblown spectacles; watching them requires no empathy, joy, wit, or working memory.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I was happy to see "Prince Ali," but I think you meant to post this one! youtu.be/3mA5zI18ga8
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
That's a hell of a letter -- heartbreaking, disillusioning (as if one had any illusions left), angering, and written with steely, incisive clarity. Charles Borges has my deep respect and gratitude for his service, honesty, and integrity.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I was relieved that their fraud was identified and punished, years ago now— yet, in this regime, the disgraced and uncredentialed David Geier can apparently be the “lead investigator” of a massive “study.” — Thanks so much for your interest; I hope this is useful information.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes, the volume of sketchy phishing that goes on across all devices, hourly, increasingly, is unbelievable. The Geiers created a nearly closed system that enabled them to conduct nonsense (not proper studies) which was published in flimsy journals and got huge publicity from the anti-vaxx lobby.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
And here is the explanation for the retraction of one of their trashy studies, which contains a link to the trashy article itself: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes, I learned about them a while ago. Below I'm linking to a rundown of some of their corrupt actions-- including that they and their associates served as their own IRB. (Protocol for human studies must be reviewed by an IRB, so I couldn't understand how their crappy methods were approved.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
The Wikipedia page is very good.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Are you talking about Mark Geier? He is no longer living. His son, David, is not an MD and did not study under anyone. Mark Geier attended Columbia; got a PhD and MD from George Washington U. Here's his Wikipedia page (no mention of mentors): en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Ge...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
The gendered aesthetics of this Fox clip are worth marveling at: blondified white woman, dressed for a 1970s ladies' lunch at a country club; grizzled white man in a suit, with salt-and-pepper, steampunk-meets-Mennonite facial hair.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I am so sorry. What a disgraceful phrasing of a cruel and stupid decision. Sending all good wishes your way.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes. This passage jumped out at me as a verbatim explanation for the regime's cancellation of funding: “These are the [types of cancers] that have very poor outcomes, often in relapsed patients who haven’t responded to prior therapy, and patients for whom the chance of survival is very low."
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I had forgotten about Thiel's trick balcony; thank you for bringing that back into my consciousness.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
REM in 1984 at Clowes Hall in Indianapolis (I can’t change where I grew up); The Minutemen as openers.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I should clarify that by “monitor,” above, I mean “get feedback when the product is malfunctioning” (eg, reinforcing suicidal plans or giving other unacceptable, life-endangering responses).
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
(And I agree with Brian that OpenAI needs to be named and blamed specifically.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
A study of this sort cannot evaluate the intensity of responses over time, as in Adam Raine's case. I find it unconscionable that chatbots have been promoted as therapeutic agents - they are utterly unregulated, with no provision to monitor users' experiences.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I believe these models (and specifically ChatGPT) should be taken off the market. This study, published on Tuesday (the same day that Adam Raine's suicide was publicized) found that AI bots respond inadequately to users' expression of moderate suicidal risk.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
If asking about Geiers: Mark and David Geier are father and son, autism conspiracy theorists who unethically managed to publish a couple shoddy studies that then had to be retracted. They served as their own IRB (internal study review board). Father was an MD but son has no training.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Not to mention your dignity and self-respect.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
*Geier, singular; the elder Geier is dead but the son (who has no medical or science degree and was fined for practicing medicine w/o a license) was named lead investigator of RFK’s intended autism study.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I’m of the impression that to stick around they would be asked to suppress or falsify findings, engage with unethical people (eg, Geiers of the autism “studies”), and other compromising actions. I get where you’re coming from, though, and reciprocate the thanks!
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes. That’s why the CDC director is litigating. The others at CDC who resigned are division heads (not subject to Senate approval) who have resigned with dignity and are documenting the unethical issues that impelled them to resign.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Those interested can read the resignation emails of the 3 former CDC leaders (chief medical director, NCIRD, NCEZID directors) here: insidemedicine.substack.com/p/breaking-n...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
And it should be noted that CDC director Dr. Susan Monarez is refusing to step down, in spite of having been “fired,” as only the president has the authority to remove her. She has filed suit. That is “staying and fighting” for the rule of law.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Hmm. I just scroll up and it’s there; David Lurie reposting an Aaron Rupar post where RFK is on Fox blithering about SSRIs and violence.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
He (in his racist, urban-hating, demented vortex) also ignores that many people are murdered at home in the halcyon enclaves of Indiana or Iowa. (“One of those ‘I’ states,” as people, such as Trump, lump them together; I type this as a former Midwest resident.)
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I keep noting how small the text of “American Workers” is — the banner is basically screaming, “Trump FIRST,” which is exactly what it is intended to say.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I hope you didn’t think I meant “post” as in this BlueSky post; I mean in his post as head of USDHHS (and, of course, in all his private life behavior).
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
His insistence on pushing a misguided pet theory less than a day after children died in a mass shooting incident is grotesque. I have read no indication the shooter was taking an SSRI or anything else. RFK’s behavior in this post is disgusting and dangerous.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Jeremy Faust helped break this news on his newsletter, Inside Medicine— here it is: insidemedicine.substack.com/p/breaking-n...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Freshman dorm conversation, yes, but the kind you eavesdrop on for a couple minutes in the lounge while schlepping your laundry or waiting for your leftovers to be done in the microwave and then get the hell out of there because it’s so tedious, racist, pretentious, and awful.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Thank you for this excellent physical description. Although I would much rather have Bud Bundy on this panel and then watch him walk out in disgust; Bud had humanity.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reposted reply parent
The below piece is in MedPage Today, re: AI models and responses to suicidal risk. (The NYT article on Adam Raine quotes a coauthor of the study but does not expand.) That these bots are being used, unregulated, as a therapeutic stand-in is terrifying. Study: psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
The below piece is in MedPage Today, re: AI models and responses to suicidal risk. (The NYT article on Adam Raine quotes a coauthor of the study but does not expand.) That these bots are being used, unregulated, as a therapeutic stand-in is terrifying. Study: psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/...
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
It’s like a panel with a dumber Legion of Doom.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
I think the process of AI-bot dependency has parallels with substance addiction. The "empathetic," reinforcing, ever-changing bot response is the drug. It is modulating the brain of the user, and the feedback, with 24/7 availability, makes them want/need more. This is insidious.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Absolutely. As a parallel, a drug that had several suicides associated with it would immediately be yanked off the market and the manufacturing company would be held responsible. This AI bot is dangerous and unregulated; there is no process in place for monitoring its effects on users.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
“They have to be put away” can mean either incarceration/ institutionalization— or dead. I realize he was referring to the former, but he would prefer the latter.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
Sure, I’m aware of those dismissals and many others. I pay attention. I was describing the contents of Harriott’s piece, because some commenters were just dismissing it because of CNN, and I wanted to help boost Sherrilyn Ifill’s reposting of it.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
It is profoundly embarrassing that the president of the US is more concerned with the appearance of a chain restaurant logo than he is with performing the duties of a chief executive.
cluftnyc.bsky.social (@cluftnyc.bsky.social) reply parent
“Good fun” is an appalling phrase to use in the context of concentration camps, even if the NYT won’t call them that. What editor wrote that headline? Are they not ashamed? And the “all” (of course, part of the idiom) makes it even worse. What “all”? All of the torture? The terror? The illegality?