Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
The *credited* screenwriter
Cultural critic and historian, author, podcaster, non-Zionist Jew. Co-host: CHARM OFFENSIVE. Writer: THE METHOD: HOW THE 20TH CENTURY LEARNED TO ACT
8,402 followers 611 following 4,220 posts
view profile on Bluesky Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
The *credited* screenwriter
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
I guess we’ll have to wait a few years to find out that it was ghost written by Agent Torture McMurder of the NSA or whatever
CHOAM Nomsky (@samthielman.com) reposted
anyway it’s shocking that no one was able to predict that when the George W. Bush administration gave itself unreviewable powers to murder and imprison people, those powers were eventually going to get used intentionally on noncombatants
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
My main question about Kathryn Bigelow’s latest is how involved the national security state was this time.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
lmao Willie
Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner.bsky.social) reposted
BREAKING: On a 2-1 vote, D.C. Circuit denies the Trump administration's request to let Trump fire a Federal Trade commissioner during appeals. Citing Humphrey's Executor, about the FTC: "To grant a stay would be to defy the Supreme Court's decisions that bind our judgments. That we will not do."
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Read it three times, thanks. My annoyance is with how sentimental (and unscary) Del Toro’s forays into horror are, and it feels like this source material is triggering all his worst impulses.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Digging into this further… the narrator has no other listed credits or website or anything else… the company that produced it (“cicero marketing”) has a truly bizarre slate of books… I smell a rat!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
I think I just listened to an audiobook narrated by an LLM-generated voice. Truly bizarre line delivery choices, odd pauses (for ex between “mademoiselle” and the character’s surname), mispronounced words etc.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Mary Shelley isn’t sentimental the way GDT is tho.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
This is pretty much what i would have expected. Sigh.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Ah well nevertheless
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
One of Nichols (and Nicholson’s) best films!!!
rax ‘levon honkers’ king (@raxkingisdead.bsky.social) reposted
seth rogen in The Studio…the huge glasses, the silver beard…peak jewish eroticism
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Okay phew!!!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Me as I bleed out from the gunshot wound after bringing a knife to a gunfight : I still have the moral high ground!!! www.nytimes.com/2025/09/02/o...
Muppeturgy (@muppeturgy.com) reposted
BREAKING: President Trump leaves the White House this morning.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Man, the things I don’t post.
Jessica Ritchey (@jmritchey.bsky.social) reposted
BREAKING: President Trump leaves the White House this morning
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
As a former theater kid I can only imagine what the interior monologue of the ball kids is right before they run out into court.
Emissary Of Night | ليلى (@diplomatofnight.com) reposted
I remember when quite a lot of people, including some who are mutuals me, insisted that this would never become the consensus.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
BREAKING: President Trump leaves the White House this morning
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Don’t be reasonable! Fight to win!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
It’d be like if I was in sandwich research and then put cheese on a slice of ham without the bread and called it a sandwich. You’d be like “no, this might be a step towards a sandwich but it isn’t a sandwich”
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Sure, but they are not actually artificially intelligent. They do not have intelligence. The goal of AI computing research is to eventually create actual artificial intelligence, which it has not yet.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
I’m not saying these tools don’t have legitimate uses. Just like using Timesmachine or newspapers dot com is easier than a microfiche. But we should be careful to describe them accurately.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
These tools can mimic (to some extent, with many faults) the outputs of human consciousness: language, images, etc. But they do not have the actual consciousness that created those things. They do this by stealing the work of conscious beings and pastiching it.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Companies name their LLMs Claude or whatever because they want you to think of them as things with consciousness. They do not have consciousness. They are sophisticated, energy-gobbling, programs. They’re tools.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
If you are, like me, generally opposed to how Large Language Models are being positioned and used (and not regulated currently) one very simple thing you could do is to stop using the term “AI” to describe them. When you do, you’re buying into the linguistic and conceptual framework of your enemies.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
I feel like there is not enough attention being paid to LONG STORY SHORT, which is the best tv show I’ve seen in quite a bit.
Alissa Wilkinson (@alissawilkinson.bsky.social) reposted
I went to see the Wizard www.nytimes.com/2025/09/01/m...
The Slides (@theslides.bsky.social) reposted
"Air Force Communications Command," slide 16 of 24 [gallery]
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
There are at most two good bond movies and Sean Connery isn’t in either of them
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Yes the original people calling it a slur are idiotically buying into the idea that these glorified search engines have personhood
Kelsey Atherton (@atherton.bsky.social) reposted
You can't have a slur against AI, but you can against the people who believe in AI personhood, and that one is "botlickers"
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
An example of how we’ve let LLM companies dictate the terms of this conversation. using this Image that implies machines and LLMs are capable of feelings and then using this term “slur” to describe insulting…a complicated search algorithm.
Elon Green (@elongreen.bsky.social) reposted
“1936 (Taylor’s Version)”
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
It’s often that a single year has one great movie in it and it’s not in English! (Zing!)
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
How the west was won and where it got us Catapult Turn you inside out
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
JUST GUTS
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Gasped at the preview for the new Springsteen biopic... Couldn't BELIEVE T Ryder Smith is in it as a car salesman.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Amazingly for a franchise property it appears to be made by humans with an actual visual sensibility who have things they are interested in exploring in a meaningful way, which puts it miles ahead of most television.
David M. Perry (@lollardfish.bsky.social) reposted
If a dude offered to help you write crappy memos and essays, and you found out they were also helping children kill themselves, would you keep working with that dude?
Zach Schonfeld (@zachschonfeld.bsky.social) reposted reply parent
When I was a kid, there were only two movie lengths: one VHS tape long or two VHS tapes long
Tom Reagan’s Hat (@rufustsuperfly.bsky.social) reposted
James Cameron’s estimated net worth is $800M
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
(Prometheus is pretentious incoherent nonsense)
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Counterpoint: there are only two good alien properties, maybe three if you count Isolation, and so you might as well try to make the non alien stuff in your alien show interesting instead.
Parker Molloy (@parkermolloy.com) reposted reply parent
Do people not realize what sorts of incentives they set up for politicians when they say "I'll vote for you no matter what your policies are!"? All that does is tell them that yes, they can adopt the worst policies.
jamelle (@jamellebouie.net) reposted
i find this image so fascinating. it is both a literal example of authoritarianism but also a second-hand reproduction of the aesthetics of other authoritarian states. it's like a simulacra of authoritarianism whose purpose is to attempt to make the simulacra real.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
lmao jake
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Here's my big Paul Newman question: How did he manage to drink that much and be that hot for that long? Like I saw him in the bathroom line at a performance of Chicago in 1996 and he *still* looked good.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
All I ask is if you are going to run a red light you at least act ashamed and not flip me the bird as I am trying to cross the street
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
The idea in here is very clever, but the idea that adding more gamesmanship and complexity to voting will lead to improved outcomes is, I think, a little naive.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
The honest answer is that the tv is right there. Sigh.
Emissary Of Night | ليلى (@diplomatofnight.com) reposted
Isaac Chotiner interviewed Biden's close friend and last ambassador to Israel, Jack Lew, and in the interview Jack Lew explicitly defends Israel killing children. Lew's defense of this is so offensive that Isaac Chotiner interrupts him twice and then says outright that he's wrong.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Man just wait until Geraldine hears about roads.
CHOAM Nomsky (@samthielman.com) reposted
Just an incredible collection of AI slop accounts, pay-to-play follow farmers, and wizened Clinton Machine minions rallying behind Newsom as he tries to get elected president in August of 2025 like a total goofball
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Wow we really are just doing the 90s culture war playbook again.
Emissary Of Night | ليلى (@diplomatofnight.com) reposted
Very rarely is the obvious so plainly said but it is worth reminding people that one of the reasons that liberal support for Israel has plummeted is the majority, if not all, of pro-Israel arguments today rest upon fundamentally illiberal premises. Liberals, at least serious ones, don't like that.
Jonathan M. Katz (@katz.theracket.news) reposted
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Important update from the Times on the chilling effect the Trump White House is having on museums: (Gift link!) www.nytimes.com/2025/08/23/a...
K. A. “Kîck Åß” Pillë (@keithpille.bsky.social) reposted
The Breeders
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
By this piece’s own logic, the Palestinians should refuse to acknowledge Israel’s right to exist so long as Likud and its allies have not been “eradicated” www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/202...
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
I just watched RAPADO, one of the films credited with kicking off New Argentine Cinema, and I feel like there is something I’m missing. Clearly lots of people went nuts for this movie, but it seems very aimless and dull and uninspired to me.
Nea “Dracula” Ching (@thegaychingy.bsky.social) reposted
"I HAVE HAD IT WITH THESE MOTHERFUCKING STRANGERS ON THIS MOTHERFUCKING TRAIN"
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Sure, and that’s covered in the book too. I do not name and discuss every individual and organization who was part of the advocacy effort though, because there is only so much of the reader’s time one can take up!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
There was a lot of activism to save all of the various fellowships from lots of different groups, but literature was successfully saved because of a specific GOP congressman and his wife!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Gonna cover Lighght?
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
There is not! Next book (The Perfect Moment: American Art, Censorship, and the Forgotten Origins of the Modern Culture Wars) is mostly about the visual arts and performance art.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Sorry to disappoint!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
(It’d be better if panelists and the arts council also refused to meet, but I’m not holding my breath on that one!)
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
I also just want to reiterate: In its current form, the NEA is being used to further the ideological agenda of the ruling party and even if that party were liberal Democrats, it would still be wrong. Arts organizations should not work with or accept funding from the NEA in its current form, period.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Also, like many people following the NEA story, it remains totally unclear what the future of the agency is. Many of us thought it would be done away with because the original Trump 2026 budget blueprint called for that. It appears instead they want to use it to make propaganda.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Fun fact: The literature fellowships were the only arts fellowship that survived the last right wing assault on arts funding in the mid-1990s. The reason they survived? The wife of one (1) congressman convinced him they had to stay. (Look for the whole story in my new book June of next year!)
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
I just want to note, in the midst of my rage, that the idea that caving on trans kids in sports would’ve somehow prevented this or sapped the political will around this is nonsensical, and anyone peddling that shit has no place in Dem politics archive.ph/2025.08.21-2...
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Everybody knows that facts don’t care about your feelings. What my book presupposes is… maybe they do?
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
The Democratic Party leadership when they see their voter registration numbers crumble:
Dave Weigel (@daveweigel.bsky.social) reposted
Yeah, the logic is not confusing. It's the same as post-CU/SpeechNow Dem super PAC logic from Lessig et al - the court created this system, Dems can't disarm, no way to repeal it unless they take back power (for long enough to flip SCOTUS).
Travis M Andrews (@travismandrews.bsky.social) reposted
BREAKING: Kennedy Center cuts dance programming team as other top producers depart. My latest with @janaykingsberry.bsky.social. Read more: www.washingtonpost.com/entertainmen...
Mark Harris (@markharris.bsky.social) reposted
Finally some good news.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Who can forget the Chinese new year tradition of giving loved ones money in a potato chip bag
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Ikiru was amazing on the big screen to be clear but I can’t tell if it would’ve been better had the whole thing been told via the funeral with flashbacks of if the funeral sequence was like half the length.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
It’s during that period where everything Jeff bridges is in is worth watching even if it’s terrible because he’s always great. (Even like the IRA bomber one or the remake of the vanishing)
Tom Reagan’s Hat (@rufustsuperfly.bsky.social) reposted
The budget for Numan’s Cars album cover was virtually non-existent
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
What the….
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Also there are… 16 other hours in the day where they can use phones!
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Or perhaps hoping
Mark Harris (@markharris.bsky.social) reposted
If Democratic politicians do not fight this because it's a "distraction," it will simply happen. They need to get in front of every mic and say that we will not allow Trump to destroy American history. He wants a culture war? GIVE HIM ONE. There are no distractions. Have every fight.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
There’s this teenager with an incredible voice walking down my street singing a medley of my heart will go on and I will always love you full out for the purpose of annoying her friends and it is amazing
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
Yeah! But I think he's really just telling on himself. He has no commitments beyond staying in the favor of the powerful and accruing power and wealth to himself, so he assumes that must be true of everyone else.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social)
Yglesias is such a soulless, unprincipled ghoul that he literally cannot conceive of anyone having deeply held convictions.
Isaac! At the Butler! (@isaacbutler.bsky.social) reply parent
omg.