*hand waggle* I liked them both for different reasons. Very different takes on the character, but then Kelvin!Spock *is* a different character, which is something I think a lot of fans too easily forget about the Kelvinverse crew as a whole. I do agree that Peck excels as a truer-to-TOS Spock.

I am going to sleep and will continue tomorrow 🫶🏻

Woke up to a lot more likes! We will see if I want to go up to 55 lol This is a series of OPINIONS. I don't need to be corrected. Hold it in, men. I know you can do it 😂

22. I don't like when Star Trek (or any show) has something major occur and then time snaps back (Year of Hell is best example) and everything we saw & everything they went through never happened. The same with "it was all a dream". Cop out! No like!

Yeah, the 90s shows did this kind of thing a lot. I appreciate episodes like "Yesterday's Enterprise" for the Elseworlds plots that they were but the franchise at the time was allergic to long-term consequences for plot decisions.

23. The JJ Abrams movies are fine, but they aren't Star Trek. That dude was auditioning for Star Wars and he has even said it in the press. He isn't a Trekkie, he didn't grasp the fundamentals of what Trek is about. They are average scifi movies but they are Star Trek in name only.

Sister!

24. Wesley is great. Leave him alone. Loved him as a kid, love seeing him now. He gets very unfairly ripped on.

25. I believe I echo Marina & Frakes when I say that we should have gotten the Riker/Troi rekindling and marriage much sooner! They are a fab couple and I really wantes to see their journey back to each other in more depth. Should have done that instead of Troi dating Worf in TNG s7.

Worf made a lot more sense with Jadzia Dax to me

26. Chakotay was not good enough for Janeway and while I respect the shippers, he isn't great and she deserves a much better, cooler guy. Janeway deserves romance & & love & all the good things. Prodigy helped develop him a bit more, but I'm still meh on him.

27. As a teen I shipped them but as an adult, I have grown & I recognize how someone worthy of Janeway should act (& be written) and Chakotay ain't it. He's a snooze and too self-righteous.

It doesn't help that I have issues with the actor. The writers of my favourite Trek shows largely worked with what the actors were giving them, and Beltran wasn't committed to his character in the same way that (for example), Robert Picardo or Nana Visitor were committed to theirs.

28. Perhaps also a common one: I don't like seeing the biracial characters hating their "alien" side. B'Elanna needed more to do than self-hatred and anger management. It sends a terrible message to biracial viewers, among other things. Entire essays have been written, seek them out.

29. A lot of things that rile up Trekkies honestly do not bother me. Especially in the post-Disco era. I'm happy to have so much Trek now, and if I am not hugely into something, there is lots to watch! If I hear people whine about the Klingons' appearance in Disco, just gonna roll my eyes.

Two of their cold opens were the kind of thing I *wanted* in Trek...and then the rest of the movie happened. I want the movies that led to those cold opens!

Zachary Quinto is a more *human* Spock. Ethan Peck is the prime *Vulcan* Spock. Kelvin Spock very much went more towards his human/emotional side than Prime Spock.

I don't agree with you here, but since these are my opinions, I don't need to get into it.

I can envision Ethan Peck's Spock growing into Nimoy's Spock. One of the very few "build up to an established character" castings (and writing) I can say that for.