Profile banner
Profile picture

Matthew Buckley

@physicsmatt.bsky.social

Theoretical physicist, Rutgers professor.

created June 14, 2023

2,652 followers 340 following 607 posts

view profile on Bluesky

Posts

Profile picture Bob Kopp (@bobkopp.net) reposted

The Department of Energy hired five academics to raise doubts about climate change. 85+ climate experts (organized by @andrewdessler.com) reviewed their report. Our conclusion, detailed in 450 pages of analysis: it is biased, full of errors, and not fit to inform policy making.

2/9/2025, 1:07:29 PM | 815 390 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Sean, that’s no way to talk about my last model-building paper.

2/9/2025, 12:13:30 AM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Atul Gawande (@agawande.bsky.social) reposted

9 CDC Directors going back to 1977 speak out. What RFK Jr has done to our nation’s public health system "should alarm every American." It "is unlike anything we have ever seen at the agency, and unlike anything our country has ever experienced." www.nytimes.com/2025/09/01/o...

1/9/2025, 11:23:26 AM | 11817 5156 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture jamelle (@jamellebouie.net) reposted reply parent

every day i see hundreds of comments of people spinning elaborate scenarios to explain how trump can control everything and all opposition is futile. a) i think a lot of you need to log off and stop following professional doomsayers. b) i think a lot of you are cowards

31/8/2025, 1:38:36 PM | 4629 730 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Ron

Ron Burgundy, disheveled, drinking a beer, saying
29/8/2025, 3:37:11 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Julie Flynn (@gardenstate-julie.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

Thanks, Matt!!! If people want to help or donate, they can go to julie4jersey.com

26/8/2025, 9:49:02 PM | 1 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Super proud of my friend, colleague, and leader in my union, Julie Flynn for stepping up to run against a guy who has been in office longer than I’ve alive. newjerseyglobe.com/congress/chr...

26/8/2025, 8:37:18 PM | 5 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Super proud of my friend, colleague, and leader in my union, Julie Flynn for stepping up to run against a guy who has been in office longer than I’ve alive. newjerseyglobe.com/congress/chr...

26/8/2025, 8:35:30 PM | 1 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Also, don't try to build the Dyson sphere as a rigid object. That's a rookie mistake.

19/8/2025, 7:02:41 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Kind of feel like a real-life Dyson sphere is like the Dyson sphere in Stellaris. Once you can build one, you don't really *need* one. At that point, you're just showing off.

19/8/2025, 6:59:55 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

A lot of the Big Questions these people say they need $50 billion and a Magic AI Box to solve can be answered by reading a bunch of questionable sci-fi from the 70s. I mean, you still won't be able to do it, because physical reality remains, confoundingly, a thing.

19/8/2025, 6:59:55 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

You need a fleet of Orion pulse-rockets with a drive signature that gives Pluto a sunburn, a backhoe the size of Mars, a solar panel fabrication facility the size of Mercury, and a power-transmission array that is powerful enough to violate local zoning ordinances on Alpha Centauri B1a.

19/8/2025, 6:59:55 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

"The Magic AI box will give us the plans for the Dyson sphere we need to power the Magic AI box." First off, I have questions about the chain of causality here. Second, you don't need a Magic AI Box to design a Dyson sphere. You want a Dyson sphere? Here you go:

19/8/2025, 6:59:55 PM | 6 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Going forward, all billionaires are required to build one (1) power-generating satellite or statite in the GW range before they are allowed to publicly opine about Dyson spheres.

19/8/2025, 4:00:40 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Oh for fucks sake.

19/8/2025, 3:21:53 PM | 8 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Did my now-semesterly check on how ChatGPT does on my (upper-level undergrad) homework. Fewer just straight-up algebraic mistakes from last time. However, still making subtle incorrect assumptions that lead to incorrect answers and are also *really* hard to catch if you don't know the right answer.

18/8/2025, 3:03:03 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Honestly, I am amazed too. That's never happened before.

18/8/2025, 2:59:26 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Oh wow, this is the best final exam schedule the Registrar Gods have bestowed upon me in 12 years of teaching. Great, now I'm waiting for the other shoe to drop. Also, 12 years? wow.

18/8/2025, 2:07:45 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Ok August, you win. I'll work on this semester's canvas site. But I won't like it.

18/8/2025, 1:59:53 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Me, seeing arXiv papers described as blog posts.

16/8/2025, 4:58:29 PM | 14 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Well, I did go into physics for the money and power. ...it's possible I was misinformed.

12/8/2025, 2:37:09 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Call me old-fashioned, but I feel like objective reality exists and as a society we should acknowledge that.

12/8/2025, 1:31:28 PM | 24 6 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

10/8/2025, 9:55:28 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

He’s copying ideas from bad 1980’s military sci-fi (which don’t work. Which is mildly annoying if you’re claiming to be hard scifi and hugely annoying if you’re putting it on arXiv).

9/8/2025, 8:55:49 PM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Sauron, who loves mess, gets a bunch of orcs to go rescue the BABY EATING ASSHOLE from a tree, then lets him go again so he can go be messy somewhere that's more entertaining to the Eye. The *drama*

8/8/2025, 1:34:18 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Strider (Aragorn son of Arathorn, Elendil's Heir, the Dunedain, Estel Hope of the West, Elessar Telecontar the Elfstone, Envinyatar) drops Gollum off with the (often pretty assholish) Wood-elves. Wood-elves decide that the BABY EATING ASSHOLE deserves better than dwarves, let him go play up a tree.

8/8/2025, 1:34:18 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Strider captures Gollum. Gollum is an asshole to Strider. Strider (Aragorn son of Arathorn, Elendil's Heir, the Dunedain, Estel hope of the West, Elessar Telecontar the Elfstone, Envinyatar) is kind of an asshole to Gollum, because, surprise the BABY EATING ASSHOLE is kind of a jerk. *ahem*

8/8/2025, 1:34:18 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Here's what this new movie wants to cover: Gollum mopes in a cave. Gollum leaves the cave, hates the Sun and the Moon Gollum, and I cannot emphasize this enough, EATS SOME BABIES Gollum goes to Mordor. Torture Gollum is set loose by Sauron, because Sauron loves mess.

8/8/2025, 1:34:18 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Chris Lintott (@chrislintott.bsky.social) reposted reply parent

PS if you’re a member of the press: I and my colleagues will happily talk about 3I/ATLAS until the (interstellar) cows come home. But my only comment on whether it’s an alien spacecraft is: Avi is talking nonsense on stilts, and doesn’t understand comets.

8/8/2025, 6:09:13 AM | 122 18 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Now I might be but of simple country lawyah, but isn't it true *Mayor* Gamgee, that not only are you the beneficiary of Mr. Baggins estate, you were an accomplice of Gollum? One might say you were *friendly* with him? It says here you offered him po-ta-toes?

8/8/2025, 1:14:02 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

"The adventures of Gollum between The Hobbit and LOTR": stupid. boring. a cheap money grab. Courtroom drama "Bereaved Beornling Families v Estate of B. Baggins Esq. (served current resident of Bag End, one S. Gamgee)": thought-provoking. gripping. also a cheap money grab.

8/8/2025, 1:10:54 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

There is no ethical consumption under feudalism.

8/8/2025, 1:01:37 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Small domino/big domino meme. Small domino says
8/8/2025, 12:59:17 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

"Pity? It's a pity that stayed Bilbo's hand...The pity of Bilbo may rule the fate of many." Pros: Bilbo's possession of the Ring begins with an act of mercy, not cruelty. Starts a domino-chain that ends with the defeat of the spirit of malice. Cons: No way to sugarcoat this: buncha babies got et

8/8/2025, 12:56:31 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

He was eating babies. Is this movie going to show him eating babies? Because, canonically, Gollum was eating babies.

8/8/2025, 11:17:07 AM | 9 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

OpenAI has really streamlined future thesis defenses for my PhD students. All I need to do is ask them how many "B"s there are in the word "blueberry" and if they get it right, they clearly aren't at PhD-level yet.

8/8/2025, 12:28:07 AM | 43 5 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Dr. Doofenshmirtz saying
5/8/2025, 12:52:53 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Someone telling you we're going to Moon to mine helium-3 is like an alien telling you they're invading Earth to steal our water. Basic physics tells you they're lying, now your job is figuring out *why* they're lying.

5/8/2025, 12:51:33 AM | 7 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

I mean, we did build a working nuclear jet engine. We tested it! It totally would have worked, for certain values of "worked."

5/8/2025, 12:20:17 AM | 11 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

- Hafnium nuclear-pumped isomers. Because you want all the fun of the nuclear x ray laser (that doesn't work) at home. - Nuclear bombers. Not bombers with nukes. Nuclear bombers.

5/8/2025, 12:10:04 AM | 14 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

- Nuclear pumped x-ray lasers. Now, you might ask: do these work? No. Are they cheap? Also no. Will we carefully investigate the science before wasting a lot of money? Buddy, you are not going to believe this.

5/8/2025, 12:10:04 AM | 22 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

- Everyone's favorite: Project Orion, aka Ol' Sparky. Look, if you have a better idea of how to get the USS New Jersey on station around Neptune to fight the Fithp on short notice, I'd like to hear it.

5/8/2025, 12:10:04 AM | 16 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

- open-cycle gas core nuclear rockets. You weren't planning on using that orbital path for anything else, right? - XK Pluto, aka fuck this planet in particular.

5/8/2025, 12:10:04 AM | 13 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Fine: top insane shit people suggested for nukes (dredging canals doesn't even make the top 5): - Nike-Ajax, aka "You're not allowed to nuke our cities, only we're allowed to nuke our cities, and coincidentally now we need to invent neutron bombs. But not for the reason you think"

5/8/2025, 12:10:04 AM | 11 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Revisiting terrible nuclear ideas from Days Unfortunately Not As Gone By as one would have hoped reminds me that For All Mankind really went downhill when they ran out of deranged 1960's-70's era rocket plans to put onscreen.

4/8/2025, 11:57:13 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

The Arkhangelsk incident in 2019, which was at least sometimes claimed to be some form of nuclear-powered cruise missile.

4/8/2025, 11:44:46 PM | 7 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Onboard the Orion is probably the safest place if you insist on being in the same gravity well. Assuming the shock absorbers hold of course.

4/8/2025, 10:41:49 PM | 2 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Orion pulse engines. When you absolutely, positively must put an Iowa class fast battleship in orbit around Jupiter. Accept no substitutes.

4/8/2025, 10:37:35 PM | 7 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Best viewed from a convenient neighboring continent.

4/8/2025, 10:34:09 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Can I interest you in open-cycle gas core nuclear rocket engine? Perfect for interplanetary travel, take-offs, and landings. Just, you know, only on planets you don't like.

4/8/2025, 10:24:24 PM | 10 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Peter Venkman, Ray Stantz, and Egon Spengler from Ghostbusters talking, with Egon saying
4/8/2025, 10:19:53 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

That already came up a few years ago. Except it was Russian. And didn't work. And killed a bunch of people.

4/8/2025, 10:18:37 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Of course, if we're dusting off dogshit ideas from the 1960s, my solar panels will be made the way the steely-eyed missile men of the era intended: as open channels of mercury boiling away in the sunlight.

4/8/2025, 10:15:48 PM | 6 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

I’m not falling for that trick again.

4/8/2025, 9:56:40 PM | 8 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Look, just because yours "exists" and "would work by the laws of physics" is no reason to turn up your nose about this other one, which in its defense will waste a ridiculous amount of time and money and also not work.

4/8/2025, 9:45:58 PM | 10 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Hafnium isomer hand grenades. Accept no substitutes.

4/8/2025, 9:42:15 PM | 10 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

There's interesting sci-fi about creating a facsimile of a person from their digital imprint. Whatever the merits of that fictional idea, now that I'm running into people who seem to believe this possible in real life I have to assume all of them are confounded by the concept of "an inside voice."

4/8/2025, 9:06:03 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

If I had a nickel every time one particular tenured lunatic got press for saying it was aliens when it absolutely was not aliens, I’d have three nickels. Which isn’t a lot, but it is absurd it has happened three times.

30/7/2025, 9:36:47 PM | 9 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Hubble flow limits the volume in which anything could be said to be headed towards Earth.

30/7/2025, 5:14:41 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

30/7/2025, 5:11:57 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Of all the things which are not happening, this is not happening the most.

30/7/2025, 5:10:24 PM | 15 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

In my professional capacity, I cannot emphasize enough how much an alien spacecraft nearly 7 miles wide headed towards Earth is not happening.

30/7/2025, 5:08:58 PM | 39 7 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

I give it a few weeks before major publications start breathlessly describing human cognition as “AI.”

29/7/2025, 2:02:28 PM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

I’m back from vacation and ready to make that everyone’s problem.

28/7/2025, 9:46:50 PM | 7 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

There are six Democrats running for Governor. On behalf of our union, my committee spoke with all of them that would sit down with us. Of these, Newark Mayor Ras Baraka was the clear choice for our endorsement.

6/6/2025, 2:47:33 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

That means we have a real opportunity to get candidates who have won because they appealed to the voters, not because the county party bosses rubberstamped them.

6/6/2025, 2:47:33 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

My day job is being a theoretical physicist, but two years ago I took on chairing the legislative committee for the union. Thanks to work by a lot of great people in our state (including the now-Senator Andy Kim) we have, for the first time, primaries that don't have the unfair "county line"

6/6/2025, 2:47:33 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Real talk, are we all collectively too online?

5/6/2025, 8:33:33 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Now look, every other person with niche subject matter expertise eventually succumbs to Poaster's Madness, but I'm sure I'll be fine.

K-2SO from
31/5/2025, 4:57:09 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Ah, a technicolorist

30/5/2025, 11:29:53 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Marge Simpson captioned as “theoretical physicists” holding a potato labeled “scalar fields” saying “I just think they’re neat.”
30/5/2025, 11:14:29 PM | 9 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Don’t mention ghost fields, don’t mention ghost fields…

30/5/2025, 10:45:12 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Butterfly meme. Butterfly labeled “literally anything,” man labeled “theoretical physicists” saying “is this an excuse for another scalar field?”
30/5/2025, 10:36:35 PM | 19 2 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Internet Matts: not even once.

30/5/2025, 10:09:18 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

As a physicist, I just feel that we have an obligation to try to do cool shit sometimes.

30/5/2025, 9:03:35 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

More evidence for my hypothesis that reality has it out for theorists born after 1975.

28/5/2025, 10:22:22 AM | 10 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

What a coincidence, this looks exactly like what you'd get if you asked ChatGPT to hallucinate a wearable doodad that looks like it was designed by someone from Apple.

27/5/2025, 3:55:05 PM | 3 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

I understand. In my opinion, right now our voices could be used most effectively in highlighting a leader who is doing the right thing (and, more importantly, the civil rights of those he was fighting for), not turning the rhetorical focus elsewhere.

9/5/2025, 8:29:04 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Dark matter viralizes through gravitational interactions. That brings the initial overdensities into the roughly spherical halos composes the dark matter around galaxies and galaxy clusters.

9/5/2025, 7:31:38 PM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Unless of course, dark matter just got magically poofed into existence in the form of macroscopic clumps very early on.

Hermes and the Professor from Futurama looking at Bender smoking a cigar next to a burned-down house, underwater. Hermes is saying
9/5/2025, 3:33:21 PM | 8 1 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

But getting down to the scale of a snowball cooling without anything *bigger* being affected is difficult. Hard to say it's impossible, but seems very tricky. So in the case that dark matter is a bunch of macro-scale objects, you'd expect to see deviations in larger gravitationally-bound structures.

9/5/2025, 3:33:21 PM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

We know gravitationally that dark matter halos aren't cooled on large scales (the size of a galaxy), but just as a galaxy of normal matter has cooled (that's why there are stars and a gas disk) and the normal matter in a cluster isn't collapsed, you could have dark matter cooling on smaller scales.

9/5/2025, 3:33:21 PM | 6 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Fortunately, it is actually pretty hard to get dark matter into the form of snowballs (or a 20 lbs particle, as per the xkcd comic). To get a lump of matter (dark or otherwise) you need to have the matter cool and collapse.

9/5/2025, 3:33:21 PM | 5 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

This actually would be one of the most diabolical forms of dark matter. As I say in seminars and talks, if dark matter were made up of something the size and mass of a snowball, we'd be pretty screwed. xkcd.com/3085/

9/5/2025, 3:33:21 PM | 21 4 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Thus, I think it is reasonable to conclude from Andor that Emperor Palpatine constructed the Death Star so he could stop having to go to boring parties.

4/5/2025, 11:55:09 PM | 7 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

In A New Hope, the minute Palpatine has his Death Star he dissolves the Senate, believing he no longer needs the administrative infrastructure it provides to maintain his grip on the galaxy.

4/5/2025, 11:55:09 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

We also see that the Senate comes with a busy social calendar -- one seen as an obligation. Presumably, like all monarchs in history, the Emperor will have to participate in these social events to ensure that key Senators see the personal advantage to their participation in the imperial project.

4/5/2025, 11:55:09 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

So in Andor we see that the Empire needs to use local powers to maintain its grip on power. They have vast resources, but not infinite. We also see that part of keeping those powers on board is maintaining the Galactic Senate as institution -- a rubber-stamp body sure, but one that Palpatine needs.

4/5/2025, 11:55:09 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

Can’t wait for Bantam’s three book series about the adventures of Paparazzi Droid.

3/5/2025, 2:50:18 PM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

For theorists, we need a journal of "terrible ideas that look plausible at first" just to prevent others from falling down the same rabbit hole.

23/4/2025, 5:56:00 PM | 3 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social)

One of the first physics ambulance-chasing events I was around for as a real grown up scientist was kicked off by someone taking a photo of a slide in an experimentalist's talk. This was just after the introduction of smartphone cameras.

23/4/2025, 5:51:34 PM | 4 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Undergrad specific impacts: Research Experience for Undergrads. This is how we get people into research. There are fewer opportunities now.RE

REUs Research Experience for Undergraduate (REU) grants. NSF program to support undergrads obtaining summer research experience. Pays for personnel (faculty & staff) to manage program, and the costs to pay students. In the grand scheme of things, these aren’t enormous costs (see previous) Standard 3-year cycle with the expectation that the university will reapply and likely be given the new grant (modulo changes in federal budget) My understanding: Rutgers and other universities who were applying for new grants had the grant approval pulled after panel-review stage and at an approval step that in previous years was pro forma As a result, many institutions (I don’t know how many, I’ve heard at least 20%) had to cancel their REU programs.
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

This slide is already out of date.

What Has Happened So Far? Late January: NIH cancels panels. This threatens all NIH grants for next year, as NIH is on 1-year review Early February: Trump Administration announces F&A rates for all grants will be immediately reduced to 15%. This will hit the Rutgers budget for ~$100M Last I heard this was enjoined by a court. February/March: Many NSF panels for next year have been cancelled. NSF and NIH grants with keywords (climate, mRNA, diversity, bi, trans,…) in title have been cancelled. NIH grant channels for underrepresented groups cancelled (removing those applicants from the pool) Late March/early April: Some NASA grants have been revoked March: Significant number of staff (program officers, etc) have been fired (Reduction In Force -> “RIFed”) in NASA, NIH, NSF,… Several universities have had broad swaths of grants pulled (UMaine, $100M in DOAg, JHU $800M in USAID, Columbia $400M in NIH, Brown $500M, Northwestern, Cornell…) Some of these actions have been ordered reversed/held by courts. Unclear if those actions will be upheld. Would only apply to existing grants. Broad sense that future grants will not be forthcoming.
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Theory grants are on the smaller end, and lots of it is taken up by fringe (health care and benefits) and overhead (goes to university operations). Is this the only way we could build a system to do science? No, but if you take this away without a new system in place, that's a problem.

What Does a Grant Pay For Specializing to High Energy Theory grants (NSF and DOE) There are small, medium, and large grants. The program officer will fit your grant application into one of these boxes. Our grant combined grant (6+ PIs) pays for PI summer salary, 1-2 grad students and part of a postdoc. Travel + personal computing gets crammed in around the edges. Typical rule-of-thumb is 3 theory PIs gets 1 postdoc on a grant Grants get charged fringe: covering health insurance and benefits. For every $1 spent on salary, we pay $0.38 for federal fringe. For state grants, we pay $0.80 for every $1 of salary. Grants get charged overhead (“F&A”): covers the cost to the university for “incidentals” that aren’t directly charged to the grant. “Incidentals” include: The electricity. The building. The staff. Every $1 of direct spending on a grant has an overhead of ~$0.57 Universities rely on F&A as part of their operating budget. ~$200M for Rutgers
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Being a PI is a continual cycle of applying for grants, explaining what you did for the grant, and trying to get a new grant. Is this the most efficient system? Maybe not, but it is the system we work in.

Life Cycle of a Grant Most physics grants are on three-year cycles: Year -1: Apply for grant (10s to 100 pages, lots of documentation working with university staff) Start hiring process in the expectation you’ll get a grant Year 1: get grant. yay! Start doing science. End of Year 1+2: submit paperwork demonstrating you are doing the work and being a good steward of money. NIH grants must be administratively approved yearly Year 3: submit final grant report, submit your new grant Year 4: “No cost extensions”
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Every person I've ever worked with treats the money we are entrusted with incredibly seriously. The grant process is tedious, lengthly, and relies on massive amounts of volunteered time as well as expert grant officers in the funding agencies.

What is a Grant? Public grants are obtained through a competitive process: A public “call” outlining the scope of the grants, application process “Principal Investigators” (PIs) submit applications describing the science that will be done, who it will be done by, and the necessary costs for the science (personnel, equipment, etc). A panel of experts is assembled by the grant agency to review all the applications. Non-trivial time investment (multiple day meetings and lots of reading beforehand). An expectation that you will agree to be on a panel if you are a grant-holder (“being a good citizen”) Everyone I’ve ever sat on a panel with takes this very seriously. Final decision made by Program Officers in funding agency, taking in to account financial realities.
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

Note Bene: I know how DOE and NSF grants for theoretical physics work, because that's my system. I know the ins and outs of other systems far less well.

What is a Grant Note: I know my grant structure the best. Extrapolating and have spoken to colleagues in other areas to try to understand the landscape National funding agencies: National Science Foundation (NSF), Department of Energy (DOE), Department of Defense (DOD), National Institutes of Heath (NIH), NASA. Also USAID, NOAA, Department of Agriculture… Rutgers has ~$500M/yr in federal grant money State grants and private grants are also significant: ~$400M/yr (Total Rutgers budget is $5.6B/yr)
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 1 0 | View on Bluesky | view

Profile picture Matthew Buckley (@physicsmatt.bsky.social) reply parent

None of us got into science to manage people, but to be honest, *most* people I work with in science do take that responsibility seriously. Every interaction I have had with other PIs as we worry about the future of science funding has been focused on protecting the people we are responsible for.

How Science is Funded A Note: Most of us didn’t get in to science to manage people. And it shows Being the person responsible for hiring and paying people is a responsibility that most of us take really seriously. Don’t work for people who don’t take this seriously if you can avoid it. No one who takes this seriously ever wants to be in the position where we can’t pay someone we are supposed to be responsible for supporting. Uncertainty in funding means we might be put in that position, and people are likely to take “conservative” approaches to avoid hiring people and later being unable to pay them.
22/4/2025, 1:15:59 AM | 0 0 | View on Bluesky | view